教育王國
標題: 禮賢會出錯信 [打印本頁]
作者: 08BB 時間: 10-11-12 17:15 標題: 禮賢會出錯信
我yesterday收到禮賢會的acceptance letter, 今日收到佢地電話話我個女係備取生唔係正取生...我既反應係 "咁都錯得?!?"...
作者: haydenden1023 時間: 10-11-12 17:28
好差下喎..
比我都會幾嬲!
作者: sonyerica 時間: 10-11-12 19:41
You call the school check again
作者: 02040314 時間: 10-11-13 00:34
我都係受害者, 真係超嬲, 空歡喜一場, 犯咗咁嚴重嘅錯誤, 對呢間學校完全失望!!!
interview果日, 我個女表現好好, 問d問題答得快而準, 個老師仲話佢好快喎, 但無讚佢叻 or乖, 我已經覺得佢哋好無愛心, 好似趕住收工, 家下發生呢單嘢, 令我覺得佢哋好唔認真!!
好想好想閙佢哋, 但又怕阿女連 waiting都冇埋, 如果唔係等緊其他學校 offer or interview, 我真係想閙爆佢!
作者: calbee6 時間: 10-11-13 01:28
又會有咁人都出錯? 唔通好似d機位咁, 先超賣, 再博你唔讀...
作者: cheukkiki 時間: 10-11-13 01:46
我都收到佢地電話話攪錯左, 個刻我都係想鬧爆佢, 咁既錯真係接受唔到.........不過我都抑制住自己無鬧佢........但真係對呢間學校好失望呀, 就算佢12月話收我囡囡我都未必會比佢去讀呀!!
作者: mayinhk 時間: 10-11-13 06:35 標題: 回復 4# 02040314 的帖子
02040314, 我跟你一樣, 女兒in得非常好都唔收, 我今日遇到隔離屋太太, 佢朋友個仔唔識講野都收左(但唔知有無出錯信), 真係無言以對。
作者: davywm 時間: 10-11-13 12:01 標題: 回復 2# cheukkiki 的帖子
俾著我一家慶爆, 加閙爆
作者: meimeichu 時間: 10-11-13 12:09
真係好激氣，收到禮賢會電話2547 0608簫主任話老師攪錯咗，因上午班短缺要我考慮下午班，如果讀下午班就交留位費啦！好彩我唔係第一志願，真係一場歡喜一場空，唔係個個家長頂得順GAR，禮賢會學校做嘢小心D啦！
作者: sonyerica 時間: 10-11-13 12:12
情緒起伏如坐過山車.
希望以上的ma ma能有更好的offer
作者: w_y 時間: 10-11-13 12:16
meimeichu
你幾時收到電話?
我而家都驚緊, 電話一響, 好驚係禮賢打來...
作者: meimeichu 時間: 10-11-13 12:22
唔聽电話都冇用，因為我今曰收到禮賢2nd Letter更正！
作者: meimeichu 時間: 10-11-13 12:22
唔聽电話都冇用，因為我今曰收到禮賢2nd Letter更正！
作者: happy0405 時間: 10-11-13 21:39 標題: 回復 5# meimeichu 的帖子
妳都唔駛咁激氣, 我個小朋友玩o左成廿分鐘垃圾先有人理都係咁啦!!!
作者: cheukkiki 時間: 10-11-13 22:05 標題: 回復 8# mayinhk 的帖子
係呀, 我今日都聽到朋友話佢個囡囡in得唔好, 但都收左, 不過就係下午班!!!
happy0405
你小朋友玩o左成廿分鐘垃圾先有人理????有無攪錯呀.好過份喎!!!
作者: 02040314 時間: 10-11-13 22:52
cheukkiki, 我都好希望阿女有其他學校收, 等佢叫我比留位時閙爆佢!!
其實, 我心目中嘅學校係一條龍女校, 只不過禮賢會收咗會安心d, 但睇嚟呢間學校收生準則好有問題, 我相信如果有返佢哋教就會入硬, 因為我之前聽過有父母特登扮基督徒返禮賢會。
究竟有冇學校唔睇家庭背景、宗教, 而係睇小朋友嘅表現收生呢???
作者: maktszching 時間: 10-11-14 01:04
請問係邊間禮賢會?
作者: kuromi. 時間: 10-11-14 01:35 標題: 離哂大譜啦!!!
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: siulili 時間: 10-11-14 02:25
原來係港島禮賢會，因剛剛有朋友同我講九龍禮賢點好點好，我仲以為乜咁大出入。 原來唔係同一間。
作者: cheukkiki 時間: 10-11-14 12:36 標題: 回復 4# 02040314 的帖子
我都好後悔個日佢打黎個陣無鬧爆佢呀, 因為原本諗住waiting list都仲有機會, 不過而家再諗真d, 就算佢話收我囡囡, 我都唔會去讀呀, 咁既垃圾學校.........
希望你囡囡最後能入到心水學校啦, 不過其實讀邊間都唔緊要啦, 千祈唔好比咁大壓力小朋友同埋自己, 最緊要開開心心~~
作者: ellako99 時間: 10-11-14 12:59
我上年都好想ar仔入般含道個間禮賢會, 但結果我個仔衰左, 記得上年interview時好混亂, 1個班房有好多小朋友, d老師唔係話1個對1個, 或者1個負責1張枱, 係有成3-4個老師係d枱度團團轉, 根住又係度講呢個小朋友點點點, 你根本唔知道做乜? 我個仔又衰gei, 玩性格, 唔理睬老師又搗亂, 但係d老師不停問佢叫乜名ar? 又唔會坐低同佢傾計, 呢個問完到另一個問, 一共有成3個定4個老師問佢叫乜名ar? 我個仔可能覺得佢地又煩, 就負氣大聲講自己個名, 望都唔望老師, 比我感覺是根本冇一個老師認真in d小朋友, 我上年in左5間, 除左禮賢會之外, 全部都係由1位老師坐定定, 認認真真同小朋友 & 家長傾計, 睇吓小朋友的能力, 但般含道個間禮賢會就好低能lor.....而且今年連取錄信件咁重要的文件都可以出錯, 呢間學校的管理就好有問題,我唔係話佢唔收我個仔, 我就話佢衰, 只係我覺得, 作為一個家長, 如果你間學校唔好, 口碑唔好, 我連填form都費事, 但當"見識"過之後, 咁就發現原來是另一回事lor
作者: pccandy2000 時間: 10-11-14 15:00
我朋友個女都係話攪錯左囉~~仲以為la間學校好好,點之連la d咁的事都可以攪錯~~真係掂呀!
作者: ftcl 時間: 10-11-14 16:52
我亞仔甚麼消息都無。佢係大仔，自問IN得都OK，上午班就難D，下午班都應該有機，點知WAITING信都無呀。佢當日做足俾公仔食奶又飲湯，玩SHAPE仲識叫係STAR，生果都講倒有BANANA同ORANGE，係LEMON唔識，又有講自己名，但最衰係無望老師好似無禮貌，不過連後備信都無，看來都係無得入圍。會唔會佢哋又攪亂咗亞仔封信
，估吓啫，因亞仔IN咗咁耐一封收錄信都未收過!
作者: 02040314 時間: 10-11-14 23:34
我同事話早三、四年呢個學校冇乜人讀, 佢阿女返下午班, 少一個又少一個, 爭d執笠, 係因為派位好先忽然咁多人爭!
作者: 08BB 時間: 10-11-14 23:44
我都諗到時收我個女都未必讀!
佢地出封"信" 只不過係人手"fill in the blank"...只填個學生name etc. 响張好simple既standard letter 上面...收第一封時都有種好唔professional既感覺. 收到佢地個電話+第二封信時都真係難以相信咁都錯得, 佢响電話度仲話"你地個個都choose上午班..." =p 好似係我既問題咁.
作者: chloema622 時間: 10-11-15 00:00 標題: 回復 1# 02040314 的帖子
基本上而家派位派得好少少嘅學校，都大把人爭！早3，4年前少好多b，依1，2年多返好多啦！間間都排哂隊！真係好大競爭，in得差d都無行！不過，我又覺得d老師好有愛心同心機，阿女in完返到屋企都仲講緊，話老師好好人，玩得好開心！
收咗阿女下午班，都有少少失望！自問in得唔錯！反而，有個朋友個仔唔太講嘢，居然收咗上午（不過唔知有無出錯信)，我聽完無言以對，啞哂！！
最後，希望各位媽媽有更好offer^_^
作者: chloema622 時間: 10-11-15 00:06
原帖由 08BB 於 10-11-14 23:44 發表 
我都諗到時收我個女都未必讀!
佢地出封"信" 只不過係人手"fill in the blank"...只填個學生name etc. 响張好simple既standard letter 上面...收第一封時都有種好唔professional既感覺. 收到佢地個電話+第二封信 ...
作者: 02040314 時間: 10-11-15 00:53 標題: 回覆 26# chloema622 的文章
我咪仲失望, 我阿女問乜答乜, 快而準, 連老師都話快, 佢只係 waiting, 連下午班都無!
所以我開頭從來冇懷疑佢哋攪錯!
比佢攪一攪, 我開始有d擔心, 阿女 so far in 咗三間, 全部識答, 但原來d學校收生標準唔係睇小朋友表現, 我哋呢d冇宗教、冇家底嘅人, 想入間好嘅學校好難!!
作者: chloema622 時間: 10-11-15 01:24 標題: 回覆 1# 02040314 的文章
其實我都無宗教同家底，又唔係專業人事，只不過普通打工仔！不過，老師問咗樣嘢，就係問平時係唔係自己湊佢，我話係，老師話咁好！唔知d學校係唔係要多d親子？？
作者: poohwong 時間: 10-11-15 22:53
am offer but 無宗教信仰，也沒有兄妹讀緊或讀過，父母不是職員也不是舊生，所以大家不要放棄繼讀努力
作者: bbAvalon 時間: 10-11-15 23:42
For those got offer from 禮賢會, please advise where you live?
I think they would offer those first who live nearby. Otherwise, if living far away, they would put those on waiting list despite the performance of the kid is good.
[ 本帖最後由 bbAvalon 於 10-11-15 23:46 編輯 ]
作者: SingMom 時間: 10-11-15 23:42
原帖由 02040314 於 10-11-13 22:52 發表
cheukkiki, 我都好希望阿女有其他學校收, 等佢叫我比留位時閙爆佢!!
其實, 我心目中嘅學校係一條龍女校, 只不過禮賢會收咗會安心d, 但睇嚟呢間學校收生準則好有問題, 我相信如果有返佢哋教就會入硬, 因為我之前聽過有父母特登扮基督徒返禮賢會。
究竟有冇學校唔睇家庭背景、宗教, 而係睇小朋友嘅表現收生呢???
靈糧堂幼稚園唔錯架! 除左宗教有分外, 主要睇面試表現. 阿女舊年果界派得好好, 大部份派去軒官、高主教同瑪利曼. 不過一樣超多人報.
作者: hocheuk0810 時間: 10-11-16 00:59
我都未收到信喎！開頭都好期待~宜家唔考慮佢啦。因為對呢間好失望啦....
作者: bapesimon 時間: 10-11-16 11:28
請問係唔係大B?
原帖由 poohwong 於 10-11-15 22:53 發表
am offer but 無宗教信仰，也沒有兄妹讀緊或讀過，父母不是職員也不是舊生，所以大家不要放棄繼讀努力
作者: domusren 時間: 10-11-16 12:08
都有可能喎~
我媽公司有2個同事嘅女都係大B呢呢喎。都係上個星期五收到信話收咗佢讀下午班。
原帖由 bapesimon 於 10-11-16 11:28 發表
請問係唔係大B?
作者: w_y 時間: 10-11-16 12:20
我識至少3 人, 大B, 唔係基督徒, 收上午, 不過都係住附近. 所以, 宗教相信唔係主要收生準則. 不過我相信 interview 表現都佔幾多下....我果組D老師好好笑容, 雖然一人IN兩個, 但都傾左好耐, 問左好多. 或者佢對初步印象好, 又會收的學生就會傾多兩句都未定. 1 人IN 兩個, 唔係單單呢間係咁, 需知有幾多人報名, 多人到真係做唔切. 之前報名排隊時見到有人無郵票, 工作人員都好NICE 即場賣俾佢, 仲好有耐性添. IN 完對間學校加晒分.
祝大家有好 OFFER, 唔好嬲啦. 有時搵學校都要講緣份.
作者: bapesimon 時間: 10-11-17 15:02
其實今年間間都嚇人, 都唔知點解間間都有成幾千人報, 心諗邊有咁多BB...
作者: 02040314 時間: 10-11-17 23:03 標題: 回覆 36# w_y 的文章
我哋講緊嘅係佢哋出爾反爾, 咁重要嘅正取同 waiting都可以攪錯, 並唔係老師 nice or 有冇耐性, 定係另有內情! 假如發生係你身上, 你有乜感覺?
Anyway, u r right, 同佢有緣無份!
作者: w_y 時間: 10-11-18 09:40
作者: hocheuk0810 時間: 10-11-21 03:49
諗起嗰日禮賢會interview就真係火都黎~
嗰日面試
真係覺得佢地超求其~記得我地係in12:20，因為剛in完凌月仙11:35就到，就係操場度玩咗5分鐘度。就有老師
走黎問我地in幾點。我地話12:20，跟著佢同我地講"唔使咁早黎到架，你地轉頭再黎過啦~"大家都記得當日面試係落緊雨。爸爸當時已經好唔高興，覺得好似比人趕，而當日阿女又著條白色裙仔。好驚佢係操場度玩到條裙污晒，就啦啦聲出去行返轉先。
返到黎跟著in時，老師好似好忙，問咗幾條問題，阿女都好快答晒，跟著老師又叫阿女穿珠仔，而老師又走咗去問其它小朋友。其後又走過來叫油顏色。又問多兩條問題，老師又走咗去。等佢返咗黎就問如果無上午，下午好唔好？我思考緊時佢已經好急想走。我就答咗"最好上午啦~我未講完佢就話面試完啦~
真係覺得佢地啲老師都冇認真去in。連我個朋友佢個女3月出世既大B，但佢唔識講嘢又唔識答題目都收！真係服咗佢地~
好想知佢地收生標準係乜~
作者: chloema622 時間: 10-11-21 11:51
原帖由 hocheuk0810 於 10-11-21 03:49 發表
諗起嗰日禮賢會interview就真係火都黎~
嗰日面試http://adex.baby-kingdom.com/www/delivery/avw.php?bannerid=609&cb=1124真係覺得佢地超求其~記得我地係in12:20，因為剛in完凌月仙11:35就到，就係操場度玩咗5分鐘度。 ...
個日見in救恩
作者: chloema622 時間: 10-11-21 12:14
原帖由 hocheuk0810 於 10-11-21 03:49 發表
諗起嗰日禮賢會interview就真係火都黎~
嗰日面試http://adex.baby-kingdom.com/www/delivery/avw.php?bannerid=609&cb=1124真係覺得佢地超求其~記得我地係in12:20，因為剛in完凌月仙11:35就到，就係操場度玩咗5分鐘度。 ...
個日in救恩就無咁好彩啦！有個阿sir同阿女in，嘩.....阿女見親d老師都係女人，嚇到阿女唔敢出聲，但都有跟住答哂d題目，之後阿女仲同返阿sir介紹自己，不過阿sir俾我感覺無咩耐性，好求其，反而對面個女老師就好有耐性引導小朋友！阿女in完都覺得無行，出到課室我老公問我做咩見到有個阿sir座低同阿女in？我只有同佢講，我地唔好彩囉，如果係個女老師in，表現一定好好多！
最終阿女被reject！所以我覺得都好睇自己撞唔撞到個好老師！
到最後希望你有間最喜歡嘅offer！同埋你認為你個小朋友最適合，會讀得愉快嘅學校！
唔好咁勞氣啦！如果俾小朋友見到佢地會有壓力同唔開心架！
作者: ftcl 時間: 10-11-21 15:32
Me too. Just received their reject letter. My son is Jan boy and live here to the school too, still he is rejectedeven he answered most of the questions! We had the interview in the afternoon session, teachers seemed hurry to off duty and our session lasted for only 15mins with only a few Qs, then the teacher asked whether we will accept PM offer, then told us that's the end. My in-law has a friend whose son answered nothing (but he was in AM session for intw)living hereby and big son, he got AM offer, don't really know their selection critereia!
原帖由 hocheuk0810 於 10-11-21 03:49 發表
諗起嗰日禮賢會interview就真係火都黎~
嗰日面試http://adex.baby-kingdom.com/www/delivery/avw.php?bannerid=609&cb=1124真係覺得佢地超求其~記得我地係in12:20，因為剛in完凌月仙11:35就到，就係操場度玩咗5分鐘度。 ...
作者: 02040314 時間: 10-11-21 23:29
我發現部份網友回應, 似乎禮賢會收嘅學生係比較平穩, 唔知係因為佢哋嘅背景, 定係佢哋怕較好嘅小朋友會有更好嘅 offer, 而 turn out 唔讀, 咁佢哋又要做一輪功夫去 call d waiting 學生!
以上係個人推測!!
作者: petit_etoile 時間: 10-11-22 10:06
my boy is big boy (feb) and he answered most of the questions correctly, except two (what are inside the closet: clothes and shoes) that he didn't know in chinese.......(because most of the time we speak to him in english) and he finished sorting the shapes fast (according to the teacher) but we didn't get any letters yet!
but we live on kowloon side....
maybe they really want to find kids that live nearby....
coz when i wanted to know how to reach their school on the phone,
the lady asked me if i'm willing to move to hong kong side later on.....?
i said from where i'm living, travelling to their school is very convenient!
so you could tell they prefer people who live closeby.....
作者: ftcl 時間: 10-11-22 10:41
Not really! I live in Pok Fu Lam Road, very close to the school already, but still not accepted la, and my boy is big boy too! I am losing confidence whether my son can have any offer, as the competition is very intense and we have NO offer yet for the time being! Now i have to wait for Kau Yan which will announce results this week, if we have NO offer again, i really don't know what to do next!!
原帖由 petit_etoile 於 10-11-22 10:06 發表
my boy is big boy (feb) and he answered most of the questions correctly, except two (what are inside the closet: clothes and shoes) that he didn't know in chinese.......(because most of the time we sp ...
作者: mayinhk 時間: 10-11-22 10:53
原帖由 ftcl 於 10-11-22 10:41 發表
Not really! I live in Pok Fu Lam Road, very close to the school already, but still not accepted la, and my boy is big boy too! I am losing confidence whether my son can have any offer, as the competit ...
ftcl, 我同你一樣,住好近, 大女, 果日我女全部問題答岩晒 (唔係我偏見覺得個女岩晒, 而係佢地d問題同考既野好似是非題, 岩就岩, 錯就錯的), 但無上午/下午班都算, 可能好多人in得好好, 但連 waiting 都無就真怪。
果日我interview時好混亂, 老師好後生, 面無表情仲黑黑地面, 又好似好趕時間咁, 所以我覺得係咪d後生老師亂寫評分, 如果遇到d經驗好d既老師, 結果可能唔同。
[ 本帖最後由 mayinhk 於 10-11-22 22:51 編輯 ]
作者: ellako99 時間: 10-11-22 13:33
所以我都話佢地唔認真 interview, 我住中西區, 偉思, 聖保羅堂, 靈恩都係1個老師對1個學生, 多小朋友in 唔係借口, 我相信聖保羅堂仲多人報名, 但佢地都是1對3, 即是1個老師對1個小朋友同2位家長, 但你唔會感覺到佢地趕收工, 反而好有耐性in, 態度好認真, 真的坐定定睇小朋友能力, 又會問家長一些問題, 我覺得咁至係公道. 至於偉思同靈恩, 老師一樣是有耐性同認真.
至於般含道禮賢會, interview形式真的不知所謂, 我懷疑d老師根本就冇認真睇小朋友表現, 求其 in 完就算, 老師好極有限, 所以一定唔會推薦呢間叫小朋友讀.
作者: happy0405 時間: 10-11-22 14:43 標題: 回覆 1# ellako99 的文章
十分贊同！佢哋實在太古怪。
作者: bbAvalon 時間: 10-11-22 20:08
I got rejected letter today.
2 weeks ago, they sent me offer letter. The next day, a school lady called me that they made a mistake but explained on the phone that my daugther's performance is good but put on the 2nd batch of offer, which should be sent out in December.
I asked why performance is good, but put on 2nd batch of offer. She explained that as we don't live nearby, they prefer to give those first who live nearby. If there is vacancy, will send me offer in next batch.
Today suddently sent me rejected letter. Very shocked. Really don't know what they are doing.
作者: vicjo 時間: 10-11-22 21:31
i was a bit disappointed when i just got the reject letter becuase my boy did a good job in the interview.
however, after read this post, i wonder if they mess up the applications. luckily, we got an acceptance letter from another good school before this reject letter. i feel better now lu
作者: 08BB 時間: 10-11-22 22:16
i got reject letter too lu. also from accept to wait list then reject. I think my girl also did a good job.
作者: 02040314 時間: 10-11-22 22:40
各位, 我都係由正取生變做後備, 到今日收到 reject letter, 我對呢間學校完完全全失望加死心。
睇下大家嘅回應, 就知佢哋好有問題, 第一, interview求求其其趕收工, 第二, 正取生都可以攪錯, 第三, 收生標準有問題!!
唔係得我個女答岩哂問題唔收, 仲有其他家長回應都一樣, 專收一d表現一般嘅學生!!
大家唔好因為呢間垃圾學校而對自己小朋友有所懷疑, 雖然阿女到今日仲等緊其他學校 result, 但以阿女問乜就答乜, 快而準, 我唔信冇學校收!!
大家加油加油!!
作者: samsheep 時間: 10-11-23 17:19
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: spw 時間: 12-2-9 11:48
其實我會覺得女仔係中西區入幼稚園都好多選擇啦,男仔又未必一定要棟禮賢會.
聽到你們講這間幼稚園總結有1,收生標準唔一致,要看個別老師而定,2.面試混亂靠好運,3.最重要係老師有沒有耐心和愛心...
我一定叫其他媽媽唔好棟這間幼稚園
作者: sirotansiu 時間: 12-9-23 23:04 標題: 回覆：禮賢會出錯信
時間過得真快，這件事快兩年了。我大女也是10年參加面試的一群，由於我當時剛生完第二個，便由先生一人帶大女出席，但卻引來不太友善的目光，因大部份小朋友都有母親陪同，最終當然落選。亦有朋友是出錯信的受害者。現細的兩歲開始報幼稚園。
望他們可以汲取教訓，好好改善。
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |