St. Mary's, MCS, GH, Marymount, DGJS, HYS, St. Paul's Convent, SPCC

myac

How would u rank them?

lugano

不喜勿插

AAAA: DGJS, SPCC
AAA: MCS, Marymount, St. Paul's Convent
AA: St. Mary's, HYS, GH

[ 本帖最後由 lugano 於 11-11-27 23:35 編輯 ]

onsyan

same as you

season_sincere

Personally (I've got two girls in DGJS so I'm a bit bias on that)

1. DGJS, SPCC, Marymount
2. St. Paul's Convent, Maryknoll
3. Gode Hope, Heep Yunn

myac

原帖由 season_sincere 於 11-11-28 00:43 發表
Personally (I've got two girls in DGJS so I'm a bit bias on that)

1. DGJS, SPCC, Marymount
2. St. Paul's Convent, Maryknoll
3. Gode Hope, Heep Yunn

How about APSKT?

share123

甘如果同一個level又如何? 例如SPCC vs DGJS?

c1234

Hi myac,
what is APSKT?

share123

代答:九龍塘宣道囉

truthmr99

How about Sacred Heart in the ranking list please?

Sevendwarfs

Same as yours!

Within group AAA, I would rank St. Pauls' Convent a bit higher than MCS and Marymount.

原帖由 lugano 於 11-11-27 23:34 發表
不喜勿插

AAAA: DGJS, SPCC
AAA: MCS, Marymount, St. Paul's Convent
AA: St. Mary's, HYS, GH

mmnn

It doesn't make sense to compare those schools by ranking.
Are you used to compare your children with others ?
Or do you like to compare you with others ?

lugano

原帖由 Sevendwarfs 於 11-11-28 10:53 發表
Same as yours!

Within group AAA, I would rank St. Pauls' Convent a bit higher than MCS and Marymount.

Within each group, 我都沒有再細化再分 Rank

我的 Ranking 從不同角度去分析, 並不只參考"現今成績"

(1) 學校歷史
(2) 過往成績
(3) 現今成績  
(4) 校風
(5) 校譽
(6) 舊生社會成就
(7) 舊生 Network
(8) 辦學團體理念
(9) 對現校學生觀感
(10) 個人認識的舊生



[ 本帖最後由 lugano 於 11-11-28 13:36 編輯 ]

season_sincere

Personally (I've got two girls in DGJS so I'm a bit bias on that)

1. DGJS, SPCC, Marymount
2. St. Paul's Convent, Maryknoll, Sacred Heart
3. Good Hope, Heep Yunn
4. APSKT

Ewongmum

2010 results , No scared Heart on list :

1	拔萃女書院		1A	94.50
4	聖保祿學校		1A	86.10
5	德望學校		1A	85.00

4	瑪利諾修院學校（中學部）			1A		85.70*
5	庇理羅士女子中學			1A		82.30
7	嘉諾撒聖瑪利書院			1A		86.00
8	瑪利曼中學			1A		87.40
11	嘉諾撒聖心書院			1A		85.10*
12	英華女學校			1A		80.40
13	聖士提反女子中學			1A		79.90
16	協恩中學			1A		75.70
24	真光女書院			1A		72.70
27	聖傑靈女子中學			1A		--
31	寶血會上智英文書院			1A		77.50
34	聖保祿中學			1A		74.00
42	嘉諾撒聖方濟各書院			1A		70.00*
45	聖母玫瑰書院			1B		68.80
46	藍田聖保祿中學			1B		68.50*
60	香港真光中學			1B		68.00
63	聖羅撒書院			1B		66.00*
69	嘉諾撒書院			1B		64.70

Ewongmum

DGS is always on the top.

easyman

Can you share the feeling about DGJS? I got second interview but I am afraid my daughter cannot stand for the pressure as all the girls are great smart in the school!

Ewongmum

I think the ones got in most of the 1st tiers 'DSS , private schools are smart and competitive students.  

But as some of the top school, I think every students in DGJS either very good in acadamic or they have one or two outstanding talents.  ( And confidence).

Parents paid lots of efforts in bringing them up.

myac

原帖由 Ewongmum 於 11-11-29 08:50 發表
2010 results , No scared Heart on list :

1拔萃女書院

1A
94.50 4聖保祿學校

1A
86.10 5德望學校

1A
85.00


4瑪利諾修院學校（中學部）


1A
85.70*5庇理羅士女子中學


1A
82.30 7嘉諾撒聖瑪利書 ...

Thank you. However, we are talking about PRIMARY SCHOOL.