赤柱聖士提反

Babybaby2011

想問下呢間学校啲学生讀得開心嗎?  課程如何?  要学很多課外活動嗎?

viscattery

原帖由 CoffeeCake 於 12-12-19 發表
我相信學校絕對有權去決定候補既次序。
我無問當時人，之後有無去再面見，有我都唔知了。
DGJS 個論壇，都 ...

可能2nd in收唔哂(waitlist的人可能有Better offer走咗),咪再收無2nd果的waitlist for

LLaiWWong

回復 Octobergirls 的帖子


Absolutely agreed

CoffeeCake

我相信學校絕對有權去決定候補既次序。
我無問當時人，之後有無去再面見，有我都唔知了。
DGJS 個論壇，都有人響出結果呢刻，還收再面見通知啦!
我只是分享我所知，不是要人認同。

ic07

原帖由 CoffeeCake 於 12-12-18 發表
無2ND IN直接有OFFER我身邊未聽過，但無去2ND IN既WAITING，真係有人最後入到。

真唔真呀？唔係先輪到2nd in唔成功嘅先咩？

Octobergirls

It doesn't make sense that the school would spend valuable time to interview anyone in order to decide whether they are worthy to be put on the waiting list. I think the priority should be:

1st: those who got offer after 2nd interview;
2nd: those went for 2nd interview but no offer now, on wait list;
3rd: those without 2nd in but on wait list (to creat a bigger pool);
4th: those received rejection letter.

LLaiWWong

回復 GCCC1231 的帖子

It was stated in another thread " 討論區 › 聖士提反書院附屬小學 › second in 是電話通知或信？" that those who have got accepted have been second interviewed.

GCCC1231

回復 CoffeeCake 的帖子

咁即係曾有小朋友在未曾Second Interview的情況下入到SSCPS啦!

CoffeeCake

無2ND IN直接有OFFER我身邊未聽過，但無去2ND IN既WAITING，真係有人最後入到。

GCCC1231

All guess!

Otherwise it's hard to place a reason to those who have not attended second interview but receive a 'wait list' letter.

laylayman

GCCC1231 發表於 12-12-18 10:21
Perhaps the school wants to give them chance and see if they deserve a 'wait list' place lei.

All g ...

Possible. If this is true, the parents who got 2nd in were a little bit fooled by the school and the arrangement.

GCCC1231

Perhaps the school wants to give them chance and see if they deserve a 'wait list' place lei.

All guess from thought!

GCCC1231

Nothing more than agree with you!

Appreciated all parents want to allocate their kids to the BEST school but is this the BEST for their kids? Wonder!

The schools are looking for their target kids no matter how well the kids' performance in the interview are.

All we, parents, should do is apply for various school for them to choose.

The rest shall be left to HIM.

God Bless all kids and parents.

runme

I think the school just wished to keep the 'waiting pool list' bigger.  You know, there must be kids withdraw later and the school would call the waiting list (especially after the Luck Draw in next June).  Also, there must be kids in waiting list not accept the offer, so ...... if the school issued many rejection letters today, how can it offer them tomorrow....

I think it is a clever arrangement (for a private school).  But HK people always say 'unfair' if unlike it ....

laylayman

GCCC1231 發表於 12-12-18 00:36
Given:
1. There is NO offer given to those kids who have attended the second interview.
2. Wait list ...

You might be correct but just wondering if some kids are on waiting list without 2nd in then the school might as well issue wait list/ reject letters to all those who didnt get offer. Why waste time for 2nd in ?

viscattery

Any kids got offer without going thru second in? I though all kids got offer were chosen from second in,no?

Piglet_Baby

回復 GCCC1231 的帖子

Its good guess still, but may not be perfectly correct as school has its own thought. For those are under waiting list, should look forward and be positive. {:1_1:}  

GCCC1231

Given:
1. There is NO offer given to those kids who have attended the second interview.
2. Wait list letters are received by those kids who have NOT attended second interview.
3. There are reject letters issued.

Do u agree with me the following priority:
1st: Kids who were given Offers (no matter at what stage)
2nd: Kids with wait list letters WITHOUT attending second interview (because their kids are so great that no second interview is needed)
3rd: Kids with wait list letters after attending second interview (the purpose of the second interview is to secure their position in the wait list, the school ranks those kids behind those haven't attend second interview)
4th: Kids with reject letters.

If that be the case, would those parents who and whose kids have attended second interview and feeling "UNFAIR" feel better?

I don't believe SSCPS would act unfairly in whatever aspect.

I hope all kids on waitlist Good Luck!

laylayman

True. I believe some of the accepted kids may withdraw at later point so they want to make allowance for a big pool of waiting list.. The school wont know yet how many kids will withdraw

avaya

No second in but got waited list letter yesterday.  I think that mean "rejected" but the school just don't send out reject letters.