教育王國

標題: 香港華仁和聖若瑟書院, 邊間比較全面? [打印本頁]

作者: acedemy 時間: 10-1-6 13:18 標題: 香港華仁和聖若瑟書院, 邊間比較全面?

香港華仁和聖若瑟書院, 邊間好?

作者: leoncf 時間: 10-1-8 00:31

聖若瑟好過華仁。

原帖由 acedemy 於 10-1-6 13:18 發表
香港華仁和聖若瑟書院, 邊間好?

作者: samuellor 時間: 10-1-8 14:38 標題: 回覆 1# leoncf 的文章

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: 咪貓貓 時間: 10-1-8 18:22

Of course, St. Joe is better. Their students are all-round.

作者: tweetyho 時間: 10-1-8 23:00

of course st jo ... in terms of academic performance ... and the number of all-rounded students

作者: acedemy 時間: 10-1-9 00:35

Thx everyone.

作者: happypiano 時間: 10-1-9 21:10

好奇怪, 我之前都問過幾個人關於呢個問題, 一個係小學老師, 一個係補習社老師, 一個係讀st paul co-ed出身既總經理, 一個係讀九華出身既財務總監. 佢地全部都話華仁好過st jo的. 真係全部都係咁講喎, 我初頭都覺得係st jo 勁d, 但聽完佢地講, 我又15/16都唔知邊個係答案.

作者: tweetyho 時間: 10-1-9 22:48

原帖由 happypiano 於 10-1-9 21:10 發表
好奇怪, 我之前都問過幾個人關於呢個問題, 一個係小學老師, 一個係補習社老師, 一個係讀st paul co-ed出身既總經理, 一個係讀九華出身既財務總監. 佢地全部都話華仁好過st jo的. 真係全部都係咁講喎, 我初頭都覺得 ...

以前可能係

however, the academic performance of Wah Yan is just so so ... when compared with St Jo and other traditional famous schools in recently years (5 to 10 yrs)
in terms of the % of 14 pts students and % of A-C

[ 本帖最後由 tweetyho 於 10-1-9 22:50 編輯 ]

作者: elbar 時間: 10-1-10 21:19

原帖由 tweetyho 於 10-1-9 22:48 發表

以前可能係

however, the academic performance of Wah Yan is just so so ... when compared with St Jo and other traditional famous schools in recently years (5 to 10 yrs)
in terms of the % of 14 pts s ...

Agree. Compare the HKCEE Results

2008 HKCEE

ST Joseph’s

Wah Yan HK

Distinct in English

16.2%

9.4%

( Distinct + Credit ) / Candidate

4.96

4.68

14 points or more from best 6 subjects

75.9%

66.4%

作者: Cheerglory 時間: 10-1-10 23:36

I think in most people mind, in terms of academic, reputation and student quality, St Joseph is much better than HK Wah Yan.

作者: b-7 時間: 10-1-14 17:40

同意！

:idea: :idea: :idea:

原帖由 Cheerglory 於 10-1-10 23:36 發表
I think in most people mind, in terms of academic, reputation and student quality, St Joseph is much better than HK Wah Yan.

作者: csonliuson2000 時間: 10-1-15 10:10

Sorry that to add some points different.

If I add DBS then what is the best if compare amongst

DBS
HK Wah Yan
St Joseph.

Please help !

Thanks !

原帖由 b-7 於 10-1-14 17:40 發表
同意！

:idea: :idea: :idea:

作者: elbar 時間: 10-1-16 19:59

原帖由 csonliuson2000 於 10-1-15 10:10 發表
Sorry that to add some points different.

If I add DBS then what is the best if compare amongst

DBS
HK Wah Yan
St Joseph.

Please help !

Thanks !

Top Boys in HK Island do not choose DBS
because of Super Excellent Schools.

2009 HKCEE	( Distinct + Credit ) / Candidate	14 points or more from best 6 subjects
ST Paul's Co-ed	6.78	88.0%
Queen's	6.40	89.2%
Diocesan Boys'	5.80	81.0%

[ 本帖最後由 elbar 於 10-1-16 20:00 編輯 ]

作者: mky9842 時間: 10-1-17 19:56

My friend who graduated from HK Wah Yan commented that Art stream was a disaster, only those studying Science may survive because the feeder school is really awful in terms of academics and very stubbornly old-fashioned.

He is now facing the problem should his son study Wah Yan Primary or not. He even said you outsider cannot imagine how terrible the situation is. The school arranges the seat by class number, not by the height of the student and they insist not changing even though the student cannot see the blackboard, the sch simply replied they have run the sch for century, they cannot see any problem....

He further reminded me of the 2 little theives who robbed a Chinese doctor some yrs ago, he said you just don't know and reluctant to said more.

作者: kenfu 時間: 10-1-17 22:49 標題: 回覆 14# mky9842 的文章

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: 麟媽媽 時間: 10-1-18 00:26

你朋友係華仁定皇仁畢業架？
打劫中醫師既係皇仁學生黎架喎。

原帖由 mky9842 於 10-1-17 19:56 發表
My friend who graduated from HK Wah Yan commented that Art stream was a disaster, only those studying Science may survive because the feeder school is really awful in terms of academics and very stub ...

作者: mky9842 時間: 10-1-19 21:52

Sorry I don't express myself clearly,
the day when we chatted just happened the Chinese doctor robbery case, he said there was case similar in Wah Yan in his days, but the parents were very co-operate and agreed to send their children abroad in a short time to exchange to keep a good record and reputation.

作者: johnmon 時間: 10-1-19 23:59

原帖由 mky9842 於 10-1-19 21:52 發表
Sorry I don't express myself clearly,
the day when we chatted just happened the Chinese doctor robbery case, he said there was case similar in Wah Yan in his days, but the parents were very co-operat ...

樹大有枯枝，族大有乞兒。每間學校會都發生大大小小的偷竊案，雖則打和偷竊不同，也不能根據一兩個個案而評價該校的校風。
我兒就讀於九龍塘一老牌名校，也在校內被人偷了數十元，但是你不能說他不是好學校。

作者: csk家長jj 時間: 10-1-20 03:08

原帖由 johnmon 於 10-1-19 23:59 發表

樹大有枯枝，族大有乞兒。每間學校會都發生大大小小的偷竊案，雖則打和偷竊不同，也不能根據一兩個個案而評價該校的校風。
我兒就讀於九龍塘一老牌名校，也在校內被人偷了數十元，但是你不能說他不是好學校。 ...

johnmon
有些問題想向你請教,請查閱私人訊息,謝謝解答。

作者: Auntie山渣 時間: 10-1-27 12:25

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: ohpama 時間: 10-2-22 02:26 標題: 回覆 20# acedemy 的文章

當然係華仁啦！

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)