教育王國
標題: 寶山幼兒園 [打印本頁]
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 11-9-19 17:06 標題: 寶山幼兒園
這間幼兒園，聽說亦係幼稚園。
直接詢問，好似唔想講比你知。其他家長，有沒有較好的經驗或一手資料，分享一下？
1. 全校有幾多班?
2. 全校有幾多個NET?
3. 上課用English
TH:Cantonese 的比重?
多謝各位！
作者: 夢B 時間: 11-9-19 17:37
佢地都唔憂做,大把富豪名人排住隊入啦
作者: 夢B 時間: 11-9-19 17:37
佢地都唔憂做,大把富豪名人排住隊入啦
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 11-9-19 18:35
原帖由 夢B 於 11-9-19 17:37 發表 
佢地都唔憂做,大把富豪名人排住隊入啦
你怎麼知道?
你有親身經驗?
作者: angeemama 時間: 11-9-19 19:01
Very true. They don't give any consideration to your kid even both parents are doctors. This kinder is not for general public.
作者: Gerard 時間: 11-9-19 20:20
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 11-9-19 21:01
原帖由 Gerard 於 11-9-19 20:20 發表
not 富豪, 是有社會地位+富豪, 例如唐唐家族, 董董家族, 只靠富有並不能擠入其中
如屬事實，佢哋收「街外」申請人$100交form費，完全唔真正考慮，然後音訊全無，與行騙有何分別?
作者: giantkid 時間: 11-9-19 21:28
其實大有大貪，細有細貪，去年我幫個仔報PN，個間啟X 都照過我報名費，之後話我係細仔，到5、6月有位先安排INTERVIEW，依家9月，個幾十蚊凍過水。
作者: login_mc 時間: 11-9-19 22:23
都唔可以咁講,我地唔係富豪,無顯赫社會地位,上年報左名都有得IN,校長親自見,好NICE,好有誠意,每個家庭有15-20分鐘interview,完全唔係外界所講嘅arrogant. 不過,事實真係有好多有好強connection嘅人報名,所以入唔到都無失望.
至於你嘅問題,我可以試下答
1. 全校有幾多班? 少過20人一班
2. 全校有幾多個NET? 唔肯定
3. 上課用EnglishTH:Cantonese 的比重? 中文教學,但有native english & mandarin teachers, 師資好好,環境極有美感,係我去過最有格調&個性嘅學校
原帖由 4eyesDad 於 11-9-19 21:01 發表
如屬事實，佢哋收「街外」申請人$100交form費，完全唔真正考慮，然後音訊全無，與行騙有何分別?
作者: irene_the_pooh 時間: 11-9-19 22:46
呢間真係唔係有$同有名就入得，仲要身家清白！
有個出名既有錢佬，佢有兩個「女朋友」 (之前結左婚，後來老婆c左)，兩個都為佢生左，但佢既小朋友都入唔到，因為佢地父母冇結婚！
呢個有錢佬，我唔敢講太揚呀！費事…
作者: ting-ma 時間: 11-9-19 23:02
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: hophopbunny 時間: 11-9-19 23:37
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 11-9-20 00:16
To login-mc: 多謝你的回答。
你話這間學校「完全唔係外界所講嘅arrogant」，但我看到的，以及多位家長的經驗，却是相反的訊息。
開門辦學，無須鬼鬼祟祟，將基本資料當軍事秘密。
如是沒有企圖真正考慮普通人申請，就應該堂堂正正通知人，唔收Application Form及$100，或發回$100申請費。
作者: login_mc 時間: 11-9-20 12:51
本人同呢間學校絕對無關係亦無必要同佢講好說話,不過你所提及嘅'多位家長的經驗',當中有無人親身接觸過寶山呀? 有乜野基本資料當軍事秘密? 坦白講,我覺得st paul day nursery都好神秘,我都完全唔知佢有乜收生標準,佢都唔係人人都IN, 蘇浙國際又係咁,佢個報名費仲要HK500(pls correct me if am wrong),又係唔保證有得 in.
事實上,我身邊真係有"普通人"讀緊寶山, 佢地唔係超級富豪,中產人士,個小朋友都幾醒目嗰種.
原帖由 4eyesDad 於 11-9-20 00:16 發表
To login-mc: 多謝你的回答。
你話這間學校「完全唔係外界所講嘅arrogant」，但我看到的，以及多位家長的經驗，却是相反的訊息。
開門辦學，無須鬼鬼祟祟，將基本資料當軍事秘密。
如是沒有企圖真正考慮普通人申請，就應該堂 ...
作者: ballfish 時間: 11-9-20 14:19
我朋友個囝正在讀K1, 全日班, 佢個最不方便是沒有校車, 每天去到門口就同D司機爭位最痛苦
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 11-9-20 22:17
寶山幼兒園稱他們的使命是「秉承基督教的信仰和價值觀，為幼兒…」
我都想我的幼兒可以接受基督教的信仰和價值觀，可是，經我四處打聽，接觸此校及見到 BK 多位家長留言，我對此校，感覺是negative的。
當然，有此校的家長會反對我的意見，但是，BK的家長大多心裏有數。
hophopbunny以經好subtle咁說話，每間學校，都要照顧好多人，上至富豪，下至員工親屬。
我相信，很多家長會多謝BK這裏的意見，令他們有更多訊息，作出適當的決定。
作者: LPN 時間: 11-9-21 00:10 標題: 回覆 15# ballfish 的文章
有舊同事個仔讀呢間, 佢話有同學學17項課外活動.. 同埋應該唔會好多人搭校車, 因為多數都有司機, 佢話有 D 搭校車既同學被其他同學取笑係 "孤兒仔", 因為冇人接放學 (純粹聽聞)
作者: hophopbunny 時間: 11-9-21 00:54
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: peter_pan 時間: 11-9-21 10:20
They used to have school bus, but since they moved to Jardin's Look-out it has to stop as it was not a viable operation (too few kids need school bus as most have their own chauffeur).
作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 11-9-21 10:28
我舊老闆既小朋友都係讀呢間, 我又俾少少資料
寶山講明係考家長的, 校長都話, 小朋友咁細, 無咩好IN, 要IN都係IN父母睇下大家係咪岩KEY, 係咪都係有心想培養仔女既家長(實際D講, 肯谷果D); 所以揀既父母, 除左所謂名門望族, 亦會揀父母都係名校出生事業有成果D(即有POTENTIAL會將小朋友培養成另一個社會棟樑果D)
我老闆個細佬, 本身唔係成材果種, 娶左個外國老婆, 去申請寶山, 校長根本唔想IN (電話上婉拒左, 話外國媽媽同香港人教育小朋友睇法唔係好同, 寶山應該唔岩佢), 之後老闆個細佬好唔甘心, 死都要NUR到一個INTERVIEW既機會, 結果一樣唔收
係咪囂張盛盛, 我唔知, 不過幾年黎我每次幫我老闆打電話去寶山, 個職員都好有禮貌的
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 11-9-21 10:33
原帖由 hophopbunny 於 11-9-21 00:54 發表
又不用咁大反應ge
其實很簡單，好像去Hermes 買Birkin bag 一樣，你要襯個brand profile才會賣個袋比你。其他人，比張紙仔你寫低個名咯。
學校也深明名牌知道，控制“產量”保持專貴。
只不過是物以類聚，預先filter了一班 ...
人哋賣商品，可算是有規有舉，盗亦有道，不用說什麼高尚使命，不用說什麼價值觀，明知你買唔到，又或者你唔係佢的客戶對象，佢都唔會賣個不存在的希望比你，叫你交$100「初步申請費」，然後白等。
反而….
作者: Ryan_baba 時間: 11-9-21 10:42
寶山啲咁尊貴嘅kg，一般家庭嘅小朋友入到都未必係好事，無論小朋友定家長，都較難溶入＂他們＂嘅圈子。
淨係參加小朋友生日會買禮物，都可以令你好頭痛。
作者: hophopbunny 時間: 11-9-21 11:04
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: pandabonita 時間: 11-9-21 11:37
恕直言,我相信邊一間kg收form都一定要做到公平公正,不可以比人有有歧視的感覺,其實佢收得$100,而大多kg都係$30,咁會5會已代表佢同其他kg好5同,點解5做多d research先報,再講,如校長見到張form已覺得5係佢地杯茶,不如5好晒大家時間,如樓主咁緊張o個$100,咁慳返d車費都未必是壞事.不喜勿插
[ 本帖最後由 pandabonita 於 11-9-21 11:40 編輯 ]
作者: kwansoyee 時間: 11-9-21 13:02
我遇見最過份的是woodland跑馬地,講明pg排waiting list,必要先交$1000報名費。幾時有位都唔知就要交$1000。講明報名費不可退回，同埋只係for報名，學費另計。
作者: DucklingYau 時間: 11-9-21 13:13
Agree with pandabonita. I also paid $100 but never got an interview, if principal/admin already decided my child/family is not their cup of tea, then I also don't want to waste time to travel to Jardine's Lookout for an interview just for the sake of "fairness". Just think of $100 as an assessment fee. You would waste more than $100 on transportation if they grant interviews to everyone like other popular KG (i.e. SKH) anyway.
作者: DucklingYau 時間: 11-9-21 13:37
On the flip side, I think it's also a big pain to attend KG interviews for some other popular schools, where you need to line up 3 hours in the street just to submit the application form, then line up again on various Saturdays to be "assessed" along with the other 1000+ applicants. On average the interviewer can only spend 1-2 mins on each child - apart from the fact that it's too short of a time to assess a child meaningfully, I also wonder if the interviewers will mix the children up post-interview! In these cases how does the application process differ from a random lottery?!? Both the schools and the parents waste time and resources in order to create the illusion of "fairness".
I've actually seen a popular pre-school in New York which has a lottery for its application form. All parents can submit their child's birth certificate number online to get a lottery number (no fee required to get a lottery number), then in a month they announce the "winners" and only those parents will receive an application form for the child's birth certificate number. At least the school can meaningfully assess the remaining children, as opposed to granting 1000+ interviews in one day like some famous KGs in HK!
作者: login_mc 時間: 11-9-21 18:23
其實真係唔止寶山,香港仲有大把幼稚園要你交左報名費而唔OFFER interview, even 有得interview, 又有幾多間學校真正由校長親自選人? SPN又要你親身排隊交,又只得幾個鐘頭可以交表,又要你特別比生活照以作"評審",之後只得十分一人有機會interview, 咁呢D又叫FAIR咩?
hophopbunny 講得岩,大家你情我願,學校從來沒有sell過你
原帖由 hophopbunny 於 11-9-21 11:04 發表
講來講去你都係唔憤氣他們打著基督教的信仰和價值觀同收你100蚊。。。
點解你對學校唔了解又要硬比人地100蚊？你情我願，間學校從來沒有sell過你。 ...
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 11-9-22 00:14
原帖由 hophopbunny 於 11-9-21 11:04 發表
講來講去你都係唔憤氣他們打著基督教的信仰和價值觀同收你100蚊。。。
點解你對學校唔了解又要硬比人地100蚊？你情我願，間學校從來沒有sell過你。 ...
約兩年前，港大醫學院的前院長吞捐款被囚。可以話 ，一個不誠實的人，就算如何專貴，類似港大醫學院院長，如果吞捐款，也是敗類一名。
所以，我希望我幼兒的學校，可以有能力去分辨及去教導，什麼是誠實，什麼是不誠實。
好多人話，明知唔會收人，明知唔係佢的客戶對象，但照派初步入學申請表，接受申請，屬於不誠實的行為。(你情我願? 忻福黨都話受害人係「自願」喎！)
教育不是一般商品或手袋的買賣，因為「賣方」對「買方」的影響太大，「賣方」任何不正確的觀念，會影響「買方」學童的一生。
作者: hophopbunny 時間: 11-9-22 00:58
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: hophopbunny 時間: 11-9-22 01:04
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 11-9-22 11:54
講真丫, 平心靜氣講一句, 考學校從來都無公平, 當校長有權去揀學生時, 自然會有BIAS, 無論邊一間學校都係
到間學校真係STRICT到"皇親國戚都無情講", "家姐讀緊細妹都照OUT", 咪一樣會有另一種聲音?
睇開D, 而家至搵幼稚園, 條路仲有好長.........
作者: cacanov06 時間: 11-9-22 12:21
好同意版主講, 宜家至開始搵幼稚園, 唔好咁緊張!
其實俾你入到寶山咁又點呀? 你個小朋友係咪又會讀得開心? 咁入到寶山係咪=入到spcc/dbs? 咁入到spcc/dbs係咪=入到hku? 入到hku係咪=成功人事.........
人生漫長, 不如意事/不公平事日日都會發生, 無謂咁執著!
如果我小朋友日日要同人比較有無司機? 住係邊? 有幾多工人? daddy係邊個? 生日會係邊個私人會所搞? 著邊個名牌衫/用品...........我會喜歡佢做一個平凡但開心有自信的小朋友呢!
作者: DucklingYau 時間: 11-9-22 14:23
原帖由 cacanov06 於 11-9-22 12:21 發表
好同意版主講, 宜家至開始搵幼稚園, 唔好咁緊張!
其實俾你入到寶山咁又點呀? 你個小朋友係咪又會讀得開心? 咁入到寶山係咪=入到spcc/dbs? 咁入到spcc/dbs係咪=入到hku? 入到hku係咪=成功人事.........
人生漫長, 不 ...
Agree with you - I am sure 寶山 is a good school academically but it might not be the best-fit for your child/family. Just like even if you get into Harvard it doesn't guarantee success in life. Just relax!
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 11-9-23 06:51
我已作出決定，以學校的誠信作為首要考慮因素，當中包括學校對使命追求的態度。在此，再次多謝各位寶貴的意見。
作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 11-9-23 10:14
以前, O係為小朋友搵學校過程中, 見到有一句"認同學校教學理念", 當時仲唔明, 心唸, 車, 你IN我, 我就咩都認同架啦
多年後既今日, 我明了, 道不同不相為謀, 有D野唔可以就係唔可以
所以, 你比我精靈得多喇~! 祝你小朋友早日搵到最適合既學校啦
原帖由 4eyesDad 於 11-9-23 06:51 AM 發表
我已作出決定，以學校的誠信作為首要考慮因素，當中包括學校對使命追求的態度。在此，再次多謝各位寶貴的意見。
作者: mister 時間: 11-10-12 00:18
Anyone know when would BHN usually release the details on admission interview？
Or any experience sharing from previous application？
Thank you！
作者: tamtamchan 時間: 11-10-12 17:23
I heard from a friend that one of the criteria is that the mother needs to be a full-time housewife to look after the kid. Working mom - sorry not their choice.
I got the application form from this KG last year ... but then I am a working mom, so I did not send in the application.
Also I know somebody's kid studying there. The father works in investment bank, very smart guy graduated from famous overseas university.... The mother is fulltime hourse wife (she also worked in bank before). They have a driver and most students in BHK have drivers ....
作者: MissMusic 時間: 11-10-12 19:11
聽埋聽埋, 我諗我有錢都唔想自己小朋友晌入面讀書..............
作者: Lilo 時間: 11-10-13 12:25
原帖由 tamtamchan 於 11-10-12 17:23 發表
I heard from a friend that one of the criteria is that the mother needs to be a full-time housewife to look after the kid. Working mom - sorry not their choice.
I got the application form from this ...
當然唔係啦！我舊同學個仔係到讀，佢自己係大律師，仲要係忙到嘔個隻，我覺得寶山係睇血統多d，我同學提過雖然佢地兩公婆都係大律師，不過係寶山家長中佢地係'中下階層"！
作者: 小冬姑 時間: 11-10-13 14:45
How about their pre-school program, i.e., headstart? Will the kids get higher chance to get in if they attended headstart?
作者: peter_pan 時間: 11-10-13 17:05 標題: 回復 41# 小冬姑 的帖子
Put it this way: the kids will have low (or even no) chance to get in if they don't attend headstart!
作者: mister 時間: 11-10-13 21:49
Have anyone attended their interviews before? How was it like?
作者: tumtum 時間: 11-10-18 11:32
Not all mommies at Braeman Hill are full time moms, about 30% are working mommies although almost all of them are professionals with senior titles.
For the interview, you and your kid will be led into a room where your child will play with a teacher on one side of the room and the teacher will ask your child questions. The pricipal and vice principal will be talking to the parents while observing the kid. It is quite a short interview, about 20 minutes or so.
作者: che 時間: 11-10-19 00:36
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: 小克 時間: 11-10-19 08:20 標題: 回覆 1# 4eyesDad 的文章
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: miffy 時間: 11-10-19 09:38
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: wootaitai 時間: 11-10-19 09:40
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: mister 時間: 11-10-19 09:56
原帖由 wootaitai 於 11-10-19 09:40 發表
唔一定，我都識幾個人是去repeat PN 班的（超大）。之前讀嶺南，victoria等
咁佢地係咪覺得學校好好呀？
作者: wootaitai 時間: 11-10-19 10:02
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: Bmwbobo 時間: 11-10-19 10:32
想問下呢度有無媽媽參加過佢地個headstart program???
好唔好？
作者: Bmwbobo 時間: 11-10-19 10:33
I have fd receiving the letter about the info session of the headstart program this month. Anyone got that too?
作者: tumtum 時間: 11-10-19 11:52
原帖由 peter_pan 於 11-10-13 17:05 發表
Put it this way: the kids will have low (or even no) chance to get in if they don't attend headstart!
This is true, so if you are aiming for PN, then definitely go for Headstart.
作者: che 時間: 11-10-19 15:06
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: janice007 時間: 11-12-5 23:14
So headstart is good or not in terms of content? i haven't deicded to apply for its PN or not at the moment, just the headstart programme as playgroup, is it good or not?? 
作者: 布希亞 時間: 11-12-6 00:03
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: difficultmom 時間: 11-12-6 09:47
Head start program is rather useless. Teachers are arrogant, unfriendly. It just forms part of their interview process for kindy.
But heard format will change this year and move to ap lei chau.
作者: bopui0607 時間: 11-12-6 09:57
真係係入面讀個D唔會公開身份架喇.
原帖由 布希亞 於 11-12-6 00:03 發表
個個都係朋友個朋友、朋友個老闆，舊同學，冇人有親身經驗，同日本個傳聞差不多
作者: fellow 時間: 11-12-20 11:27
Be fair, this is a good school. Kids there are very happy with a lot of different field trips and activities. But of course, $$$$! If you really want to get in, started from their pg. I have few friends with their kids in that school, they love it. And even I have friend who studied there when she was young (acutally she was there when the school opened in the first year). And she graduated in good university in USA. Now very good status. Just different people needs different type of schools. Even you force to get in, you wont be happy because you cannot communicate with the parents. They mainly use english because even the seminar for parents is conducted in English.
作者: drlyuen 時間: 12-3-19 16:31
Headstart 而家轉到鴨脷洲的新校舍Infant Toddler and Twos（ITT)，仲係Headstart之前加咗個First Step! First Step由一歲開始上，跟住先入Headstart.
我小朋友而家上緊First Step. 我係佢去年一出世就報名，而家上咗一個月多啲。個校舍設施係全港Playgroup最好的，有六個課室：Reading Room, Play room, Art Room, Music Room, Gym Room and Sensory Room. 全間地下都有heated floor. 每間課室有一至兩個老師，仲有物理治療師同職業治療師，超豪！
一個星期兩堂，啲BB玩得好開心，仲學到好多嘢：自己洗手，點名舉手，鞠躬，等等。好多同學都quit咗其他playgroup如gym, tutortime等，因為每一堂上六個classroom已經包含晒所有其他playgroup要學嘅嘢。
不過好多family都有司機，我見到有個仲誇張，司機、爺爺、嬤嬤、媽媽、2個工人、1個陪月。
如果岀世無報到ITT，都唔駛諗wait到啦。
作者: vc3231 時間: 12-4-13 14:23
drlyuen 發表於 12-3-19 16:31 
Headstart 而家轉到鴨脷洲的新校舍Infant Toddler and Twos（ITT)，仲係Headstart之前加咗個First Step! Fi ...
作者: 2-lala 時間: 12-4-13 17:09
想問下同寶馬山的寶山幼兒園有沒有關係? 我想應該沒有關係但同名, 請指教
作者: Icy_babe 時間: 12-4-14 03:34 標題: 引用：個個都係朋友個朋友、朋友個老闆，舊同學，
原帖由 布希亞 於 11-12-06 發表
個個都係朋友個朋友、朋友個老闆，舊同學，冇人有親身經驗，同日本個傳聞差不多 ...
作者: peter_pan 時間: 12-4-14 09:44
回復 2-lala 的帖子
寶山幼兒園
used to be in 寶馬山. They moved to Jardine's Lookout a few years ago. I think another kindergarten has taken over their old site, which is at the back of a supermarket. I'm afraid I don't know the name of that kindergarten but it is not related to 寶山幼兒園 at all.
作者: rainbowcov 時間: 12-4-14 10:01
本帖最後由 rainbowcov 於 12-4-14 10:03 編輯
至於你嘅問題,我可以試下答
1. 全校有幾多班? 少過20人一班
2. 全校有幾多個NET? 唔肯定
3. 上課用EnglishTH:Cantonese 的比重? 中文教學,但有native english & mandarin teachers, 師資好好,環境極有美感,係我去過最有格調&個性嘅學校
係?! 真係好想見識下.
作者: cherwowo 時間: 12-4-15 01:31
Having been through Headstart, I'd like to share a few thoughts so parents signing up for ITT can put into consideration:
1. Was Headstart part of the admission process? Content-wise I don't think Headstart was too different from other playgroups then available. However, at $6,000+ for 10 x 1 hour something sessions, Headstart is IMO very expensive (even by today's standard). The official line was that it was not part of the application process. But if it was not, why did the school hand out a second and different PN application form to Headstart participants? If an applicant did not participate in Handstart, I am not sure how this second application form could have been obtained. In fact, non-Headstart participants probably would not even know such form existed!
2. Only some applicants got invited to Headstart. If it was not part of the application process, why and how did the school select only some applicants to invite?
3. Not all Headstart participants were interviewed. And no interview meant no chance of getting admitted? Only the school would know but I don't know anyone who didn't attend an interview but got admitted. The question is how did the school select applicants for interview? Probably not based on performance of the kids during Headstart - in my year, what I gathered is that (1) there were 2 Headstart batches, (2) most of the participants in the 1st batch got interviewed, (3) only a few of the participants in the 2nd batch got interviewed. I can't see any logical reason why kids in the 1st batch could have out-performed those in the 2nd batch by such a wide margin that interviews were offered mostly to 1st batch participants. Would it be that the school had already decided upfront based on "credentials" who to interview (and who not to) when allocation to 1st/2nd batch were made? If the decisions were made upfront, poor 2nd batch participants - I am sure many would have joined and participated with every effort with the hope of advancing their applications!
As with the opaqueness of the application process, my thoughts on the above remains to date.
作者: vc3231 時間: 12-4-15 14:08
Does anyone know how many students do they take for nursery class （2yr old）？。for first steps， there are 8 students in one group x 6 groups， and there are two batches 。 that means there are 96 in total
作者: mummyJ 時間: 12-5-1 23:04
Cherwowo - thank you very much for sharing info re. Headstart. As those parents who are interested in getting their kids into BHNS would know, it is generally very hard to get any insight regarding the school's selection criteria for the PN. $6,000 for 10+ hours is expensive. But was it worth it? Did your child enjoy the program? It's not clear from your comment but I assume your child was one of those in the second batch who did not get an interview? Do you know anythign about their ELP? Thanks.
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 12-5-2 21:57
本帖最後由 4eyesDad 於 12-5-2 21:59 編輯
2012年4月中，香港專業教育出版社（www.hkpep.com）發佈2013/14香港最具教育競爭力中學/小學/幼稚園50強龍虎榜。此排行榜是根據聯合國教育、科學及文化組織1996年出版的統計年鑒有關國際通用的教育指標和參考香港教育局二零零一年報告有關香港學校教育成效的教育指標，具體包括：教師質素，師生比率，教學質素，學校資源及設施，學業成績，課外活動表現，學校支援措施，教師工作滿足感（用過去三年教師平均流失率來體現），教學語言，教學模式，學校歷史，.......共63項教育指標構建成的香港學校教育競爭力評比體系，排行榜結果，幼稚園50強中，不見寶山幼兒園。
何解？
作者: mummyJ 時間: 12-5-3 00:56
Thanks 4eyesdad - that's interesting. I wonder too. Of the 50, which ones were in the top 10? Thanks.
作者: cherwowo 時間: 12-5-3 18:22
本帖最後由 cherwowo 於 12-5-3 18:37 編輯
MummyJ: Not sure about now, but Headstart used to be held at BHNS. They had a nice venue but content-wise, it wasn't too different from other playgroups. They asked the parents + kids to do different tasks, some of which I think were difficult for 2 year old kids (training?). Naturally, I would have thought most parents treat Headstart as part of the application process, so they would have wanted the their kids to perform and not cry, etc. Well, but they are just kids. So you can imagine ....
I personally do not find the costs justifiable if it were just a playgroup. But if it were part of the application process then 1. the premium price tag should be considered the application fee (excessive?) and 2. why accept the application fee when the nursery was (from the start) not prepared to give the applicant a fair chance?
The one good thing was I bumped into a number of long lost friends there, old schoolmates and ex-colleagues alike. Good to have met them again and their kids too!
作者: mummyJ 時間: 12-5-3 18:47
Thanks Cherwowo. Based on your comment, it would seem that BHNS/Headstart failed to manage parents' expectation. They should have made it clear that joining Headstart does not necessarily mean you'd automatically get an interview opportunity for the PN. Sorry to learn of your bad experience. It is certainly helpful and kind of you to share with us. Thank you!
作者: cherwowo 時間: 12-5-3 19:01
Well, I'd rather think they are already very good at "managing" parents' expectations
作者: yuyubb47 時間: 12-5-4 09:54 標題: 回覆：寶山幼兒園
我自己3年前幫小孩交了申請表和$100 申請費 去寶山，他們只是寄了封信給我說己收了我的申請表，並在信上說明我的申請會進入該校申請程序，再等通知。
一直到現在我小朋友快4歲了也再沒收過寶山任何消息。
有試過打去問清楚，他們只叫我等消息。
不要說什麼Headstart, ITT了。
交了$100申請費，但他們沒有跟我交代清楚所謂的學校程序是什麼。
雖然已經是較久前的事，但看到這帖子，也想跟大家分享我的經歷。
作者: LPN 時間: 12-5-5 00:09 標題: 回覆：yuyubb47 的帖子
我同你既經歷一樣！其實佢冇心收，就咪叫人填表同交$100啦。
作者: yuyubb47 時間: 12-5-6 12:40 標題: 回覆：寶山幼兒園
LPN: 老實說我是被這所幼稚園名氣吸引，但不等於要白交$100給他們。
有心收錢,但連一封有交代的回信也沒有。
作者: tanglulu 時間: 12-5-8 16:27
i did applied this school before and did received their invitation to the headstart program.....but i did not attend it finally since their nursery admission is not guarantee, and i am just a ordinary citizens, i don't think i am their target group of students
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 12-5-8 17:22
回復 tanglulu 的帖子
I am sorry to hear so many parents have paid application fees and were disappointed.
作者: login_mc 時間: 12-5-8 18:34
ESF收HK$300 報名費, 都係唔guarantee 有interview, 什至連acknowledgment receipt 都無,莫講通知!!!
作者: rcool 時間: 12-5-8 22:44
CCKG is much better only $30 報名費 and everyone got a chance to interview
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 12-5-8 23:37
回復 login_mc 的帖子
Funny you mentioned ESF.
I also applied ESF kindergarten and primary school. I am not related to any ESF school. I phoned both schools and asked to speak to the Principal of each school.
No problem. So I spoke with them on the phone.
I asked if I could visit the schools.
No problem. So I visited both schools.
I can see for myself that they are nice schools and have nice people who will answer questions about the schools.
作者: CoffeeCake 時間: 12-9-14 19:34
我個女畫畫果度好多寶山人, 我本人見識過後比較滿意我個女而家既學校.
名牌大學高學歷我地有, 可能我唔夠佢地咁有錢所以大家style好唔同,
作者: login_mc 時間: 12-12-10 14:09
回復 CoffeeCake 的帖子
interested to know where yr girl learn drawing 
作者: zuzu888 時間: 12-12-10 14:19 標題: 引用：其實大有大貪，細有細貪，去年我幫個仔報PN
原帖由 giantkid 於 11-09-19 發表
其實大有大貪，細有細貪，去年我幫個仔報PN，個間啟X 都照過我報名費，之後話我係細仔，到5、6月有位先安排 ...
作者: drlyuen 時間: 13-3-4 10:53
Even worse. I have applied GSIS for my kid. $2600 application fee and not guarantee an interview chance. They said it need your kids to perform a native English speakin level compare to the same age of kids. And if they offer an interview chance, I have to pay $3800 before I can interview. And if being admitted, I have to buy debentures. That is crazy.
BTW, the application and $100 that you have pay to BHS for PN is only preliminerary application. I have done that when my child is birth. Then I got a final application form just two months ago. Now I am waiting for the interview in the coming Apr. For your information, my kid is studying ELP in ITT now. (First step then Headstart then ITT). I think most of the students in ITT got the final application form and interview chance.
作者: drlyuen 時間: 13-3-4 10:55
First step then Headstart then ELP
作者: mothercare100 時間: 13-3-5 10:54
寶山專收名人子女.如果你地唔係名門望族,唔係出名既明星.都好難有機會in,呢間學校係要用關係入架.........
作者: drlyuen 時間: 13-3-6 11:01
We are not any celebrity but we will have interview in Apr. I agree with you the chance of getting in is really low without relationship.
作者: 小克 時間: 13-3-7 13:10
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: 阿早! 時間: 13-3-7 21:46
tanglulu 發表於 12-5-8 16:27
i did applied this school before and did received their invitation to the headstart program.....but ...
作者: bigheadchiu 時間: 13-3-7 22:13 標題: 回覆：寶山幼兒園
My son is with ITT now and will have the PN interview in April. I think it is almost a must for your child to study in ITT in order to get the interview chance. However, I think competition is large for getting into PN since I know many of the children are siblings of current/ex students.... 
作者: drlyuen 時間: 13-3-11 15:15
Do u know what they will ask and do in interview?
Now ITT has over 150 students in ELP. How many will be able to get into PN?
作者: bigheadchiu 時間: 13-3-11 19:39 標題: 回覆：寶山幼兒園
I want to know also.
作者: LeeCC 時間: 13-3-14 02:50
我識人係某銀行集團後人,個BB5個月大時己經有Offer
作者: babieblue 時間: 13-3-14 12:11 標題: 引用：我識人係某銀行集團後人,個BB5個月大時己經
原帖由 LeeCC 於 13-03-14 發表
我識人係某銀行集團後人,個BB5個月大時己經有Offer
作者: 小冬姑 時間: 13-3-15 16:13
Believe it or not, the school has an internal list as to who to accept; who not to accept already. So if you are not blue blooded or have any sort of connections with this school, don't waste your money and time and effort.
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |