教育王國

標題: Victoria k1 vs ESF k1 [打印本頁]

作者: Greenteacafe123 時間: 20-2-7 00:14 標題: Victoria k1 vs ESF k1

細仔收到兩間offer, 自己心儀 Victoria 因為覺得中文緊要，但係又好擔心小朋友唔可以直升小一

其實Victoria 直升小一機會真係好微？

如果 decline Esf, 係咪入唔返esf小學？只係擔心如果揀咗 Victoria 但又升唔番 Victoria小一嘅話，就會變咗連入 esf 機會都無左.. 大嗰個小朋友啱啱accept 左 esf grade 1 offer, 如果細仔而家 decline 左esf, 兩年後仲可唔可以有sibling priority 收番入Esf 小學？

作者: 964000 時間: 20-2-7 06:36

If your elder son will be in ESF , your younger kid will have sibling priority too.

作者: Greenteacafe123 時間: 20-2-7 08:11

964000 發表於 20-2-7 06:36
If your elder son will be in ESF , your younger kid will have sibling priority too.

Even if we declined offer this time? We can still have sibling priority for Y1 two years later?

作者: gfkwong 時間: 20-2-7 08:52

你大仔點考入year 1?無priority基本上係冇得interview

作者: Greenteacafe123 時間: 20-2-7 09:12

gfkwong 發表於 20-2-7 08:52
你大仔點考入year 1?無priority基本上係冇得interview

我哋本來係interview for reserve list, 但有位，校長話基本都係睇吓小朋友嘅英文水平為主，我哋冇 priority 但有 foreign passport.

作者: traybee61 時間: 20-2-7 09:58 標題: 回覆樓主:

想問你大仔幾時call interview 架

作者: Jane1983 時間: 20-2-7 11:10

有sibling priority，Victoria亦可以一試。

作者: gfkwong 時間: 20-2-7 11:46

如果咁樣讀維多利亞囉。

作者: yohan 時間: 20-2-7 12:15

回覆 Greenteacafe123 的帖子

I have friend who has done the same, declined the ESF K1 offer for another kindy, while older sibling is already studying in ESF primary. The younger sibling will still be in the priority list theoretically, but the younger sibling is in K1 now, not yet time to apply for ESF primary. There is no known blacklist as far as I hear.

作者: 964000 時間: 20-2-7 13:25

Greenteacafe123 發表於 20-2-7 08:11
Even if we declined offer this time? We can still have sibling priority for Y1 two years later?

Yes of course. But your younger son still needs to pass the entrance assessment of ESF Y1.

作者: yohan 時間: 20-2-7 13:32

964000 發表於 20-2-7 13:25
Yes of course. But your younger son still needs to pass the entrance assessment of ESF Y1.

yes, that's much more important as they have more expectation for Y1 applications than K1.

作者: tamwong 時間: 20-2-7 14:11

964000 發表於 20-2-7 13:25
Yes of course. But your younger son still needs to pass the entrance assessment of ESF Y1.

besides.. need to take into consideration if there is actually any vacancy in ESF Y1.. as there is a through train system.. basically all kindy will be guaranteed Y1.. the number of vacancy will be very limited.. even though you will have a sibling priority .. it's really hard to say

作者: Greenteacafe123 時間: 20-2-7 14:47

yohan 發表於 20-2-7 12:15
回覆 Greenteacafe123 的帖子

I have friend who has done the same, declined the ESF K1 offer for anot ...

Thank you for the info

作者: Greenteacafe123 時間: 20-2-7 14:48

964000 發表於 20-2-7 13:25
Yes of course. But your younger son still needs to pass the entrance assessment of ESF Y1.

Good to know, thank you very much

作者: Greenteacafe123 時間: 20-2-7 14:49

tamwong 發表於 20-2-7 14:11
besides.. need to take into consideration if there is actually any vacancy in ESF Y1.. as there is ...

True.. this is why we are struggling between the two as VSA doesn’t guarantee anything

作者: yohan 時間: 20-2-7 14:53 標題: 回覆樓主:

Esf is definitely a safer bet especially the competition is even larger nowadays.

作者: Greenteacafe123 時間: 20-2-7 14:56

traybee61 發表於 20-2-7 09:58
想問你大仔幾時call interview 架

一月中

作者: 964000 時間: 20-2-7 15:05

Greenteacafe123 發表於 20-2-7 14:49
True.. this is why we are struggling between the two as VSA doesn’t guarantee anything
...

Where is your ESF catchment zone? If HKI probably still high chance because there is only 1/2 ( supposed some from Tung Chung) kinders feeding into 5 primaries.

作者: Greenteacafe123 時間: 20-2-7 15:23

964000 發表於 20-2-7 15:05
Where is your ESF catchment zone? If HKI probably still high chance because there is only 1/2 ( sup ...

HK Island

作者: 964000 時間: 20-2-7 18:04

Greenteacafe123 發表於 20-2-7 15:23
HK Island

HKI + foreign passport + sibling priority = 除非你小朋友interview時非常不合作一句野都唔肯講，否則如果佢一般學校評語和表現正常就應該冇理由入唔到。

作者: Saboc 時間: 20-2-7 19:06

本帖最後由 Saboc 於 20-2-7 19:08 編輯

最終如果都係揀英基, 咁為咗維多利亞幼稚園嗰幾年嘅中文程度其實冇乜大意義!

作者: Greenteacafe123 時間: 20-2-7 19:20

Saboc 發表於 20-2-7 19:06
最終如果都係揀英基, 咁為咗維多利亞幼稚園嗰幾年嘅中文程度其實冇乜大意義! ...

絕對同意，其實本意係想直升維記小一，但係問題係佢唔包一定升到，我哋唔想行local, 擔心到時候再轉返去 esf 時人哋已經唔會收

作者: Greenteacafe123 時間: 20-2-7 19:22

964000 發表於 20-2-7 18:04
HKI + foreign passport + sibling priority = 除非你小朋友interview時非常不合作一句野都唔肯講，否則如 ...

明白，多謝你

作者: mindfulmom 時間: 20-2-7 22:16 標題: 回覆樓主:

VSA 在 K2 後就知第一round收生結果，如果你第一round成功，咁你就可以如願揀 VSA。但如果你係 waiting list，就要等到 K3 時才會知道 wait 唔wait 到，到時你又要抉擇，要 ESF Y1定係繼續 wait VSA Y1。Waiting的機會其實係有架，因為好多人貪VSA早出結果，會HOLD位直到佢地考到其他國際學校或本地神校就會放位。但你能否承擔風險就你自己考慮下啦。

除左考慮升小的問題，個人認為你都可以諗下究竟你想小朋友幼稚園階段想點樣成長、點樣學習，唔駛淨係集中升學問題。

作者: Greenteacafe123 時間: 20-2-8 19:04

mindfulmom 發表於 20-2-7 22:16
VSA 在 K2 後就知第一round收生結果，如果你第一round成功，咁你就可以如願揀 VSA。但如果你係 waiting lis ...

Thank you

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)