教育王國
標題: esf kinder 升year 1 [打印本頁]
作者: littlebb2015 時間: 19-1-8 01:22 標題: esf kinder 升year 1
請問如果讀esf Kindergarten, Year 1 如果number 唔靚,揀既學校都冇位入唔到既話最後會點安排架?會唔會最後都可能會冇esf 既學校收?定係esf 最後點都會安排一間(可能係out-of-zone school) 俾你架?
Many thanks

作者: Valerie_bb 時間: 19-1-8 18:48
littlebb2015 發表於 19-1-8 01:22 
請問如果讀esf Kindergarten, Year 1 如果number 唔靚,揀既學校都冇位入唔到既話最後會點安排架?會唔會最 ...
如pass會俾間港島你

作者: sonjakc 時間: 19-1-9 00:04
回覆 Valerie_bb 的帖子
港島應該唔會有位。因為就算分配完比自己catchment area 既esf kinder 後有餘位的,之後會分左比其他唔係讀esf kinder but 揀果間係1st priority 而又喺catchment area 既applicants! 而且hk island 又多鬼佬,佢地機會又大過local ,所以唔係d人以為港島區咁容易囉!
作者: 貝珠 時間: 19-1-9 00:26
sonjakc 發表於 19-1-9 00:04 
回覆 Valerie_bb 的帖子
港島應該唔會有位。因為就算分配完比自己catchment area 既esf kinder 後有餘位的 ...
以現時的理解,Esf kinder priority 係高過其他冇priority 的人,choice 也不會override priority 的重要性。

作者: 貝珠 時間: 19-1-9 00:37 標題: 回覆樓主
以現時綜合各方資料,大家在9月central application 時,可以填自己的preference. 當刻各人也未有random number .
但當刻已經要填preference. 假若你只填一間學校,非君不嫁,咁理論上,你黑仔,random number 差,Esf 係冇責任幫你安排另一間學校。
但如果你填preference ,填超過一間,冇論pis 或out of zone 也好,咁random number 差,就會去左不是你first choice 果間,而你係一定要accept or reject 呢個offer , 冇得wait 你first choice.
呢個係我的理解,有錯請指正

作者: sonjakc 時間: 19-1-9 00:41
回覆 貝珠 的帖子
在字面上你可以根據esf website 這樣推論。但事實上,據我所知有些港島區esf學校已經一早send 左offers 比non-kinder 既applicants.那麼怎樣解釋為何不等所以esf kinders 都有offer 後才allocate 位比其他non-kinder 考生? :P
作者: 貝珠 時間: 19-1-9 00:48
sonjakc 發表於 19-1-9 00:41 
回覆 貝珠 的帖子
在字面上你可以根據esf website 這樣推論。但事實上,據我所知有些港島區esf學校已經一 ...
因為果d Esf kinder 學生,在central application 時,從來冇填過呢d 港島學校。如果呢d Esf kinder (random number 差), 有填過的話,Esf kinder 學生always 優先過冇priority 的人。
Central application 係9月,所以中央一早有哂數。

作者: FattyDaddy 時間: 19-1-9 02:17
sonjakc 發表於 19-1-9 00:41 
有些港島區esf學校已經一早send 左offers 比non-kinder 既applicants.那麼怎樣解釋為何不等所以esf kinders 都有offer 後才allocate 位比其他non-kinder 考生?
Because those non-ESF kindergarten children could be younger siblings of existing students, or their parents are alumni or ESF staff.
作者: heihei33 時間: 19-1-9 07:24
littlebb2015 發表於 19-1-8 01:22 
請問如果讀esf Kindergarten, Year 1 如果number 唔靚,揀既學校都冇位入唔到既話最後會點安排架?會唔會最 ...
random number 差,esf kinder 多數都可以allocated 去second choice
除非唔pass interview

作者: heihei33 時間: 19-1-9 07:31
heihei33 發表於 19-1-9 07:24 
random number 差,esf kinder 多數都可以allocated 去second choice
除非唔pass interview
i mean observation assessment

作者: sonjakc 時間: 19-1-9 10:07
回覆 FattyDaddy 的帖子
Those you are referring to of course hold higher priority than the Esf kinder students. 不過我所講的有offer non-kinder applicants 包括n無人士。所以話如果Esf kinder students 揀既1St priority 同次選都係好popular school 的話,而random number 又差,真係有機會無offer。而可以pass到去 間無揀既其他Esf campus 好微,除非有人decline d offers 。所以其實應該揾定其他IS 做backup 穩陣d!
作者: mandy_ng207 時間: 19-1-9 11:06
回覆 sonjakc 的帖子
Yes, there are ESF kinder students on SJS reserve list only, while others who chose PIS / out of zone schools already received offers at the end of November last year.
作者: littlebb2015 時間: 19-1-9 11:40 標題: 回覆樓主
如果心儀SJS & RC, 會唔會再填多個3rd choice 穩陣啲..?
但跌左落3rd choice 就冇得wait SJS / RC,係咪咁呀?(如果我理解錯左請更正)

作者: 貝珠 時間: 19-1-9 11:47
littlebb2015 發表於 19-1-9 11:40 
如果心儀SJS & RC, 會唔會再填多個3rd choice 穩陣啲..?
但跌左落3rd choice 就冇得wait SJS / RC,係咪咁呀 ...
其實有priority 的人,填兩間已經好安全

作者: 貝珠 時間: 19-1-9 12:29
貝珠 發表於 19-1-9 11:47 
其實有priority 的人,填兩間已經好安全
Sorry, 若你填一間sjs 再搭一間out of zone kjs 都係冇用。
若一間popular foundation school 加一間PIS 或冇咁oversubscribed 的foundation school ,應該都安全

作者: littlebb2015 時間: 19-1-9 14:28
貝珠 發表於 19-1-9 12:29 
Sorry, 若你填一間sjs 再搭一間out of zone kjs 都係冇用。
若一間popular foundation school 加一間PIS ...
明白
Thanks

作者: heihei33 時間: 19-1-9 21:15
貝珠 發表於 19-1-9 12:29 
Sorry, 若你填一間sjs 再搭一間out of zone kjs 都係冇用。
若一間popular foundation school 加一間PIS ...
應該唔可以咁填。 因為頭三位只可以揀一間in zone嘅foundation school ,其餘兩間一定要揀pis, 到第四位先可以揀區out of zone 嘅foundation school

作者: ddbb0099 時間: 19-1-9 22:04
littlebb2015 發表於 19-1-8 01:22 
請問如果讀esf Kindergarten, Year 1 如果number 唔靚,揀既學校都冇位入唔到既話最後會點安排架?會唔會最 ...
簡單d,無填第4,5,機會微

作者: 貝珠 時間: 19-1-9 23:03
heihei33 發表於 19-1-9 21:15 
應該唔可以咁填。 因為頭三位只可以揀一間in zone嘅foundation school ,其餘兩間一定要揀pis, 到第四位先 ...
我意思係1st preference in zone Esf foundation school , 2及3唔填,4 out of zone Esf school

作者: FattyDaddy 時間: 19-1-10 03:06
sonjakc 發表於 19-1-9 10:07 
回覆 FattyDaddy 的帖子
不過我所講的有offer non-kinder applicants 包括n無人士 ...
I take it you know of such cases through personal contacts? But unless you are an ESF staff responsible for admissions, you wouldn't know if those non-ESF kindergarten children accepted are really "n無". Their parents might have bought NR and not told you about it.
This year is the very first year which ESF implements the "one form" system so no one has any experience of it, there is no need to speculate too much.
作者: sonjakc 時間: 19-1-10 16:11
回覆 FattyDaddy 的帖子
No speculation but don’t need to convince you why. Anyway, the only point I want to make is that if one (no matter Esf or non-Esf kinder applicants) is not sucessful in getting an offers for the schools they have chosen on the application form, it’s very highly unlikely that they will be offered a place at another Esf school campus that they had never applied for. ( this is really what the 樓主 is asking for in the 1st place )
In case anybody does get an offer for the school that they haven’t chosen on application, please do share here!! Would be nice to know !
作者: FattyDaddy 時間: 19-1-10 16:43
本帖最後由 FattyDaddy 於 19-1-10 16:44 編輯
sonjakc 發表於 19-1-10 16:11 
回覆 FattyDaddy 的帖子
it’s very highly unlikely that they will be offered a place at another Esf school campus that they had never applied for
I have no idea what is going to happen with this new "one form" system, but in the past there had been cases of ESF kindergarten pupil being accepted by an out-of-catchment school, a school that was not applied for, because the catchment school was full. These cases were rare, but they did occur.
In a nutshell, ESF do try to accommodate their own kindergarten pupils before the so called "n無" applicants, if it appears some "n無" applicants have jumped the queue, it is probably because they have priorities which are not obvious, e.g. NR, alumni etc.
作者: ddbb0099 時間: 19-1-10 17:54 標題: 回覆樓主:
其實我諗,如港島山頂等無咁熱門的esf小學,自己又有辦法可返學,可以放係5,6位,咁random唔靚都仲有機會。如留空唔填就自求多福

作者: pinkmania 時間: 19-1-11 14:28
littlebb2015 發表於 19-1-9 11:40 
如果心儀SJS & RC, 會唔會再填多個3rd choice 穩陣啲..?
但跌左落3rd choice 就冇得wait SJS / RC,係咪咁呀 ...
本帖最後由 pinkmania 於 19-1-11 14:31 編輯
無錯
但其實今年有擺RC 嘅都有offer.
有人淨係擺SJS, 得waiting.

作者: FattyDaddy 時間: 19-1-11 23:55
pinkmania 發表於 19-1-11 14:28 
本帖最後由 pinkmania 於 19-1-11 14:31 編輯
但其實今年有擺RC 嘅都有offer
If "今年" is referring to this current application year (application started in Sept 2018), it is the first time the "one form" system is implemented and no offers from any ESF school have been made yet.
作者: dem0cracy 時間: 19-1-12 09:18
FattyDaddy 發表於 19-1-11 23:55 
If "今年" is referring to this current application year (application started in Sept 2018), it is th ...
ESF kindy applicants have already received results for y1 application in Nov/Dec.

作者: pinkmania 時間: 19-1-12 16:16
FattyDaddy 發表於 19-1-11 23:55 
If "今年" is referring to this current application year (application started in Sept 2018), it is th ...
本帖最後由 pinkmania 於 19-1-12 16:17 編輯
sibling + KG 都出晒offer 啦

作者: FattyDaddy 時間: 19-1-13 02:27
dem0cracy 發表於 19-1-12 09:18 
ESF kindy applicants have already received results for y1 application in Nov/Dec.
In that case this new "one form" system proves to be very different. Previously ESF schools (including the 2 PIS) coordinated with each other and announced their Y1 offers on the same day, which was in mid-February.
作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 19-1-13 21:53
貝珠 發表於 19-1-9 00:37 
以現時綜合各方資料,大家在9月central application 時,可以填自己的preference. 當刻各人也未有random nu ...
怎樣知道自己係咩no

作者: kevinlam0708 時間: 19-1-14 00:03
pinkmania 發表於 19-1-12 16:16 
本帖最後由 pinkmania 於 19-1-12 16:17 編輯
sibling + KG 都出晒offer 啦
係咪大部分KG 都有offer?
作者: mandy_ng207 時間: 19-1-14 07:49
回覆 kevinlam0708 的帖子
似乎全部KG學生都pass assessment, 有無offer視乎你點填,如果填左PIS / 不熱門out of zone 做other choices的話,多數有offer. 如果只填一兩間熱門,number又唔靚,就有機會waiting list.
作者: jackychun77 時間: 19-1-15 00:55
mandy_ng207 發表於 19-1-14 07:49 
回覆 kevinlam0708 的帖子
似乎全部KG學生都pass assessment, 有無offer視乎你點填,如果填左PIS / 不熱門 ...
邊幾間係冇咁熱門既outzone school

作者: ddbb0099 時間: 19-1-16 07:06 標題: 回覆樓主:
maybe Bradbury, Peak? 因為位置都幾唔方便

作者: kevinlam0708 時間: 19-1-16 15:47
ddbb0099 發表於 19-1-16 07:06 
maybe Bradbury, Peak? 因為位置都幾唔方便
真係幾唔方便哈哈。上山轉到暈
作者: ddbb0099 時間: 19-1-16 18:09
kevinlam0708 發表於 19-1-16 15:47 
真係幾唔方便哈哈。上山轉到暈
如果一定要入到ESF Y1後備選,就有d機會。
無理由後備放熱門,等於無搷。
純個人覺得

作者: BabyChan66 時間: 19-1-18 10:44
mandy_ng207 發表於 19-1-14 07:49 
回覆 kevinlam0708 的帖子
似乎全部KG學生都pass assessment, 有無offer視乎你點填,如果填左PIS / 不熱門 ...
以我所知,並唔係所有esf kinder 都有offer

作者: littlebb2015 時間: 19-1-18 12:24
BabyChan66 發表於 19-1-18 10:44 
以我所知,並唔係所有esf kinder 都有offer
多唔多人冇offer要轉出去其他IS讀呀?

作者: mandy_ng207 時間: 19-1-18 13:37
回覆 BabyChan66 的帖子
Do u mean passing the assessment but put on waitlist? or not passing the assessment and rejected from entering ESF schools?
作者: elainL 時間: 19-1-18 14:15
BabyChan66 發表於 19-1-18 10:44 
以我所知,並唔係所有esf kinder 都有offer
下.....吾係掛
作者: ddbb0099 時間: 19-1-19 08:04
littlebb2015 發表於 19-1-18 12:24 
多唔多人冇offer要轉出去其他IS讀呀?
本帖最後由 ddbb0099 於 19-1-19 08:37 編輯
https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3715278
#50

作者: happy_schools 時間: 19-1-25 18:20
唔好意思,想請教下現在ESF k2上year 1 的程序,是否:-
1。幼稚園9-10月抽出random number 給每一個學生(會通知家長?)
2。10-11月所選的小學老師來幼稚園觀察
3。小學11月底確定收/不收/on waitlist?
另外,關於random number, 是全港所有英基幼稚園的學生每人一個號碼,定係每一間幼稚園各自配號碼比自己的學生?
謝謝。

作者: Avocadosushu 時間: 19-2-3 01:05
happy_schools 發表於 19-1-25 18:20 
唔好意思,想請教下現在ESF k2上year 1 的程序,是否:-
1。幼稚園9-10月抽出random number 給每一個學生( ...
每人有一個random no. 全部係esf 中央處理申請所以唔係kindies 自己assign. 個random no 家長唔知的。
今年經驗: 十月底收到first pref 嘅學校email 話考慮緊offer 俾我個女,如果老師去kindies 做observation 無問題的話30/11 就會出offer letter.
希望幫到你明多少少。

作者: SRmama 時間: 19-2-3 06:40 標題: 回覆樓主
如果有sibling係小學,會唔會派返相同學校?

作者: happy_schools 時間: 19-2-21 16:02
happy_schools 發表於 19-1-25 18:20 
唔好意思,想請教下現在ESF k2上year 1 的程序,是否:-
1。幼稚園9-10月抽出random number 給每一個學生( ...
謝謝

作者: happy_schools 時間: 19-2-21 16:02
Avocadosushu 發表於 19-2-3 01:05 
每人有一個random no. 全部係esf 中央處理申請所以唔係kindies 自己assign. 個random no 家長唔知的。
今 ...
本帖最後由 happy_schools 於 19-2-21 16:02 編輯
謝謝

作者: Mrspan 時間: 19-3-6 01:53
貝珠 發表於 19-1-9 23:03 
我意思係1st preference in zone Esf foundation school , 2及3唔填,4 out of zone Esf school
...
如果我填
1. KJS (in-zone)
2,3唔填
4. CWBS
5. RC
咁算安全嗎?
如果KJS冇位, 派左CWBS, 將來仲可以申請transfer嗎

作者: 貝珠 時間: 19-3-6 07:42
Mrspan 發表於 19-3-6 01:53 
如果我填
1. KJS (in-zone)
2,3唔填
本帖最後由 貝珠 於 19-3-6 07:43 編輯
不可以放rc 最後

作者: mandy_ng207 時間: 19-3-6 08:27
本帖最後由 mandy_ng207 於 19-3-6 08:30 編輯
回覆 Mrspan 的帖子
Suggest you to go to ESF admission seminar to learn about the details and the admission figures for the coming year 1 (which is the first year of the one-form policy)To put it short, if your consideration is KJS > CWBS > RC, then you have to give up RC (KJS 1st choice, out of zone CWBS, other choices left blank)
If you put 1. KJS 2. RC 3.(blank) 4.CWBS (out of zone), then very likely you will be allocated to RC if there is no space for KJS.
If you succeed in the exercise, u are allowed to transfer only after 2 years of study in your allocated school.
作者: 貝珠 時間: 19-3-6 08:38
mandy_ng207 發表於 19-3-6 08:27 
回覆 Mrspan 的帖子
Suggest you to go to ESF admission seminar to learn about the details and the ad ...
Transfer between schools 係兩年後先可以開始排,有人走條隊先會郁,但priority 比其他人高

作者: Mrspan 時間: 19-3-6 09:27 標題: 回覆樓主
明白了 謝謝!

作者: iamworkingmama 時間: 19-3-14 15:34 標題: 回覆樓主
想請問大家知唔知有siblings priority 的小朋友apply year 1, interview 會大約在幾月?

作者: Avocadosushu 時間: 19-4-2 17:50 標題: 回覆樓主
有少少update: 有兩個WKS K2 學生 舊年出offer 咩都無, out.zone 個backup 都無offer. 最後都收到KJS offer. 睇嚟舊年校長話PASS 到"observation" 一定有位讀係真嘅。 ~ 報告完畢

作者: littlebb2015 時間: 19-4-2 18:31
Avocadosushu 發表於 19-4-2 17:50 
有少少update: 有兩個WKS K2 學生 舊年出offer 咩都無, out.zone 個backup 都無offer. 最後都收到KJS offe ...
本帖最後由 littlebb2015 於 19-4-2 18:31 編輯
好多謝你既資料呀!以後有咩消息歡迎隨時再上黎同我地分享呀

作者: 貝珠 時間: 19-4-3 00:05
Avocadosushu 發表於 19-4-2 17:50 
有少少update: 有兩個WKS K2 學生 舊年出offer 咩都無, out.zone 個backup 都無offer. 最後都收到KJS offe ...
本帖最後由 貝珠 於 19-4-3 00:06 編輯
舊年?舊年未係one form,都冇得填out of zone back up
我估意思係pass 左assessment, 你個zone 冇位,學校盡力安排個位俾你。其實一直都係咁,只係one form 開始做得systematic 一d

作者: Avocadosushu 時間: 19-4-3 07:00
貝珠 發表於 19-4-3 00:05 
本帖最後由 貝珠 於 19-4-3 00:06 編輯
舊年?舊年未係one form,都冇得填out of zone back up
我嘅意思係2018 年尾。講緊嚟緊2019/20 入Y1. 睇嚟行咗one form 啲coordination 好咗好多。

作者: 貝珠 時間: 19-4-3 07:13
Avocadosushu 發表於 19-4-3 07:00 
我嘅意思係2018 年尾。講緊嚟緊2019/20 入Y1. 睇嚟行咗one form 啲coordination 好咗好多。
...
Icic , 咁快有offer ,one form 都幾有成效

作者: picamama 時間: 19-4-3 07:30
Avocadosushu 發表於 19-4-3 07:00 
我嘅意思係2018 年尾。講緊嚟緊2019/20 入Y1. 睇嚟行咗one form 啲coordination 好咗好多。
...
嘩咁真係好好多,以前聽聞D waiting等到差不多開學

作者: Avocadosushu 時間: 19-4-3 07:46
picamama 發表於 19-4-3 07:30 
嘩咁真係好好多,以前聽聞D waiting等到差不多開學
係呀,我知嗰兩位二月尾已經有offer. 家長可以放下心頭大石。 其實舊年(2018 年尾) 喺info session 有人問校長駛唔駛報出面學校做backup, 當時校長話pass 到observation 就唔駛太擔心。憑佢呢句我真係無報出面學校。

作者: picamama 時間: 19-4-3 07:49
Avocadosushu 發表於 19-4-3 07:46 
係呀,我知嗰兩位二月尾已經有offer. 家長可以放下心頭大石。 其實舊年(2018 年尾) 喺info session 有人問 ...
咁出面D學校尤其新校真係賺少好多留位費

作者: littlebb2015 時間: 19-4-3 09:36
Avocadosushu 發表於 19-4-3 07:46 
係呀,我知嗰兩位二月尾已經有offer. 家長可以放下心頭大石。 其實舊年(2018 年尾) 喺info session 有人問 ...
咁就好喇!
請問學校係咪會好快通知你pass 唔pass 架?thanks

作者: Avocadosushu 時間: 19-4-3 11:48
littlebb2015 發表於 19-4-3 09:36 
咁就好喇!
請問學校係咪會好快通知你pass 唔pass 架?thanks
我哋好好彩random no. okay, 所以10 月尾就收到email 話"being considered for a Year 1 place", 如果observation okay 30/11 就會收到offer letter. 所以等待嘅時間比起以前短咗好多。

作者: littlebb2015 時間: 19-4-3 13:56
Avocadosushu 發表於 19-4-3 11:48 
我哋好好彩random no. okay, 所以10 月尾就收到email 話"being considered for a Year 1 place", 如果obse ...
Thanks :) 好多謝你解答呀,我仲想問埋咁係咪即係10月頭就已經有小學黎做observation架?

作者: littlebb2015 時間: 19-4-3 14:08
picamama 發表於 19-4-3 07:49 
咁出面D學校尤其新校真係賺少好多留位費
係...
不過依家國際學校需求大左...多左人想入國際學校,可能又會多返啲留位費...

作者: Avocadosushu 時間: 19-4-3 14:49
littlebb2015 發表於 19-4-3 13:56 
Thanks :) 好多謝你解答呀,我仲想問埋咁係咪即係10月頭就已經有小學黎做observation架?
...
應該係11 月,其實唔知exactly幾時,據講會嚟好幾日做observation. 另外自己k2老師comment 都緊要,observe 咁短時間其實佢哋都要rely on K2 老師意見。

作者: littlebb2015 時間: 19-4-3 15:22
Avocadosushu 發表於 19-4-3 14:49 
應該係11 月,其實唔知exactly幾時,據講會嚟好幾日做observation. 另外自己k2老師comment 都緊要,observ ...
明白,都係既,我都覺得會睇老師既comment..
升K2 係咪會轉班主任架?
唔好意思,我好多問題...
真係好多謝你既回答呀

作者: Avocadosushu 時間: 19-4-3 16:21
littlebb2015 發表於 19-4-3 15:22 
明白,都係既,我都覺得會睇老師既comment..
升K2 係咪會轉班主任架?
唔好意思,我好多問題...
應該係轉老師但同學就一樣。

作者: littlebb2015 時間: 19-4-3 16:29
Avocadosushu 發表於 19-4-3 16:21 
應該係轉老師但同學就一樣。
明白 Thanks

作者: koala_ys 時間: 19-5-25 01:03
想請問一下observation係咪大機會pass?有無家長可以分享班上有幾多pass唔到observation?謝謝!

作者: ddbb0099 時間: 19-5-25 14:44
koala_ys 發表於 19-5-25 01:03 
想請問一下observation係咪大機會pass?有無家長可以分享班上有幾多pass唔到observation?謝謝!
...
我班無人唔pass

作者: koala_ys 時間: 19-5-26 00:37
ddbb0099 發表於 19-5-25 14:44 
我班無人唔pass
Thanks for sharing!!

作者: florencewong89 時間: 19-5-30 14:01
回覆 ddbb0099 的帖子
would like to know which ESF kinder your child goes to?
作者: 3piggys 時間: 19-5-31 09:17
Avocadosushu 發表於 19-4-3 16:21 
應該係轉老師但同學就一樣。
According to my child's K1 teacher, kids will be shuffled and assigned to different classes in K2, based on their circle of friends in K1, plus their catchment zone for P1. That means, in K2, kids will meet new friends but still have a few of old friends. This is to provide a balance of comfort & challenge during the transition. And also a (very likely) different teacher for K2.
作者: littlebb2015 時間: 19-5-31 12:37
Thanks for the info 3piggys mama :)
歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |