教育王國

標題: 今年有冇人申請左RC但冇得interview架？ [打印本頁]

---

作者: swarovski2011    時間: 18-11-12 10:02     標題: 今年有冇人申請左RC但冇得interview架？



我指year 1...thanks

---

作者: pollym.219    時間: 18-11-12 12:58

回覆 swarovski2011 的帖子

You have received interview invitation already?

---

作者: Nemo_baby    時間: 18-11-12 12:58     標題: 回覆樓主:

haven't received any notice yet. anyone received interview invitation?

---

作者: swarovski2011    時間: 18-11-12 12:59

pollym.219 發表於 18-11-12 12:58
回覆 swarovski2011 的帖子

You have received interview invitation already?

No no...我只是想知，睇下要唔要買NR先有得面試

---

作者: royckl    時間: 18-11-13 08:29

Nemo_baby 發表於 18-11-12 12:58
haven't received any notice yet. anyone received interview invitation?

I know ESF schools applicants received interview dates already.....but my son applying RC has yet to receive the email.

---

作者: 貝珠    時間: 18-11-13 11:12

royckl 發表於 18-11-13 08:29
I know ESF schools applicants received interview dates already.....but my son applying RC has yet  ...

I remember that u have sibling priority , right ?

---

作者: royckl    時間: 18-11-13 11:12

貝珠 發表於 18-11-13 11:12
I remember that u have sibling priority , right ?

Yes... so it’s a guaranteed?
I’m just too panic....

---

作者: elainL    時間: 18-11-13 14:33

有無人係人「n無」但有得interview 呢？

---

作者: swarovski2011    時間: 18-11-13 14:54

elainL 發表於 18-11-13 14:33
有無人係人「n無」但有得interview 呢？

我都想知N無人數有interview 多唔多

---

作者: 抺茶雪糕    時間: 18-11-13 14:58

swarovski2011 發表於 18-11-13 14:54
本帖最後由 swarovski2011 於 18-11-13 14:55 編輯

我都想知N無人數有interview 多唔多

多，但都有一批人冇得in

---

作者: swarovski2011    時間: 18-11-13 15:15

抺茶雪糕 發表於 18-11-13 14:58
多，但都有一批人冇得in

知道幾多%嗎？

---

作者: ken_mama    時間: 18-11-13 16:06     標題: 回覆樓主

未收到通知。算唔算好消息？係咪仲有機？

---

作者: merci2046    時間: 18-11-13 19:50

明白大家都交了申請表, 都好期待可以獲得面試機會, 不過現在只能等待, 我們無法控制, 因此大家都想開一點, 不要太緊張, 按照時間表, 非英基學生家長要19/11 才收到面試通知電郵

https://www.rchk.edu.hk/year-1-admissions/

---

作者: Mangobma    時間: 18-11-14 15:16     標題: 回覆樓主:

剛收到了，N無，無得in

---

作者: rafsimons    時間: 18-11-14 15:16     標題: 回覆樓主

剛收到email, 通知無得in了

---

作者: mandy_ng207    時間: 18-11-14 15:42

Me too. 我地d同學都無

---

作者: pollym.219    時間: 18-11-14 15:44

Me too. No interview

---

作者: jjtm    時間: 18-11-14 15:46     標題: 回覆樓主

Received email, no interview chance (emoji)(emoji)

---

作者: columbae    時間: 18-11-14 16:10

mandy_ng207 發表於 18-11-14 15:42
Me too. 我地d同學都無

ESF Kindergarten 同學？

---

作者: mandy_ng207    時間: 18-11-14 16:30



回覆 columbae 的帖子

No, but our school’s kids go to SJS and RC in previous years.

---

作者: merci2046    時間: 18-11-14 16:44

提早了5天出interview通知, 好像整過面試程序都推前了進行

---

作者: kriskris55    時間: 18-11-14 22:00     標題: 回覆樓主：



轉左one form , 仲以為”n冇”會多左interview chance。今年仲有冇in800人？

---

作者: ken_mama    時間: 18-11-14 22:05     標題: 回覆樓主

想问 如果無得int RC，係咪等於其他ESF學校都唔會再搵你？即所有ESF學校都無望？

---

作者: ken_mama    時間: 18-11-14 22:05     標題: 回覆樓主

想问 如果無得int RC，係咪等於其他ESF學校都唔會再搵你？即所有ESF學校都無望？

---

作者: mandy_ng207    時間: 18-11-14 23:43

回覆 ken_mama 的帖子

My understanding is “yes”

---

作者: 貝珠    時間: 18-11-15 00:29

mandy_ng207 發表於 18-11-14 23:43
回覆 ken_mama 的帖子

My understanding is “yes”

又未必，人家又冇講佢apply 邊間esf，priority 點擺

---

作者: mandy_ng207    時間: 18-11-15 07:33

回覆 貝珠 的帖子

From ESF website:

• All Year 1 and Year 7 applications received within the ‘Central Application Period’ (1 September to 30 September) will receive a computer generated random number. Applications will be ranked by priority category and assigned a random number for central processing. The interview list for each ESF/PIS school is compiled, taking into account the priority criteria, the parent’s preferences, placement availability and requirements in line with the EDB. Transport restrictions into Discovery Bay will also be taken to account for DC processing. Applicants who are not able to gain a first-round interview are waitlisted for their first preference school. Each year, our schools are oversubscribed with applications, and so unfortunately, we are not able to interview all applicants who apply on-time. Year 1 and Year 7 applications received after the Central Application period will be placed on a waiting list in date order of receipt.
  

So my understanding is they are only waitlisted for one school, I.e. their first preference

---

作者: kittykuma    時間: 18-11-15 08:21

mandy_ng207 發表於 18-11-14 15:42
Me too. 我地d同學都無

不用灰心。以我上年個N 無case, RC 通知1st round 無得in。但在1月interview 前約1星期，收email 話有人唔去in, 問我會不會來in. 要一兩曰內覆，因我若唔去，RC 會立即call 下一個。

In完收到waiting offer, 到4月收正式offer.

我是十分好彩，今年行one-form情況又可能不一様。若無backup, 真的可以咩到無。當然，有人會在這情況下買NR, 值唔值就見人見志。

---

作者: 貝珠    時間: 18-11-15 08:39

mandy_ng207 發表於 18-11-15 07:33
回覆 貝珠 的帖子

From ESF website:

有媽媽WhatsApp group 分享。applicant A , without any priority, apply sjs as first choice, RC as second choice,  and the 3rd and 4th choice are also filled. Applicant A got interview invitation yesterday.

While quite a lot of applicants applied RC as first choice or applied RC as the only choice failed to get any interview.

究竟個system 係點玩法？即係random number 大哂？點擺priority 完全唔重要？

---

作者: mandy_ng207    時間: 18-11-15 09:05



回覆 貝珠 的帖子

Priority comes before Random number. Random number comes before your preference.That’s what I was told at RC school tour: Applicants are sorted by their random number into a master list. Then the office goes though the list and moves up those who have priorities (with respect to each school), and interview places are given to those with priorities. For the rest, they come back to the master list and give out the remaining interviews by random number. For no.1 on the list, if his first preference is full (e.g. SJS), then he can be allocated to his second preference (e.g. RC). If there are only 10 places for RC, and no.1 to 10 all put RC as their first or second choice, then the interview places will very likely be given to them and no.11 and the rest get no interview.

---

作者: 貝珠    時間: 18-11-15 09:30

mandy_ng207 發表於 18-11-15 09:05
回覆 貝珠 的帖子

Priority comes before Random number. Random number comes before your preference.Th ...

Thank you for your clarification. I just thought it is similar to local school p1 lucky draw

---

作者: Fre12    時間: 18-11-15 11:40

mandy_ng207 發表於 18-11-15 09:05
回覆 貝珠 的帖子

Priority comes before Random number. Random number comes before your preference.Th ...

Thanks a lot for the clear explanation.

Do u know (just for example) if the kid get a good random number, n his 1st choice is sjs, 2nd is RC, n he got interview with sjs....
will RC still interview him?? Or only one interview for him?

---

作者: mandy_ng207    時間: 18-11-15 11:45

回覆 Fre12 的帖子

Only one interview. If failed SJS, no second chance with other ESF schools.

---

作者: Fre12    時間: 18-11-15 15:52

mandy_ng207 發表於 18-11-15 11:45
回覆 Fre12 的帖子

Only one interview. If failed SJS, no second chance with other ESF schools.

Omg...in the past, some students got 2 offers...now it seems they only hv one chance... all or nth ....

---

作者: ken_mama    時間: 18-11-15 16:04

Fre12 發表於 18-11-15 11:40
Thanks a lot for the clear explanation.

Do u know (just for example) if the kid get a good random ...

What is considered a good random number?

---

作者: Fre12    時間: 18-11-15 16:17

ken_mama 發表於 18-11-15 16:04
What is considered a good random number?

Just like lucky draw...
all applicants with no priority (eg. 300 applicants ) will go into one pool, have lucky draw... they will be assigned a random number... eg. #1, #2...to #300.
If all the applicants pass the play visit, the child who hv #1 random number will get offer first...
If the school only hv 100 vacancies， the one who is #101 and so on...will be put in waitlist...

Then I assume the good random numbers are whose on the top of list... n it is just a lucky draw...

For those who hv priority (eg sibling) will get a higher ranking random number

---

作者: karenbabe    時間: 18-11-17 19:51     標題: 回覆樓主

幸運地，星期三收到面試通知
我地係N無人仕
RC 1 st choice

---

作者: littlesun    時間: 18-11-20 06:26

貝珠 發表於 18-11-15 08:39
有媽媽WhatsApp group 分享。applicant A , without any priority, apply sjs as first choice, RC as sec ...

呢個都係我對ONE FORM APPLICATION最懷疑既地方...

係同一個 preference 就話可以用random number 分次序

但如果applicant A random number 差去左2nd preference, 同applicant B 去左3rd preference, 咁2nd preference 既A 係咪比3rd preference 既B有priority?

---

作者: mandy_ng207    時間: 18-11-20 11:07

回覆 littlesun 的帖子

Given they are of the same priority group, if applicant B has a better random number than applicant A, the place should go to applicant B

---

作者: Karen2009    時間: 18-11-20 12:29

mandy_ng207 發表於 18-11-20 11:07
回覆 littlesun 的帖子

Given they are of the same priority group, if applicant B has a better random ...

其實B 已經由第一志願跌落第二志願，咁正常係咪 random# 應該會比 A 在第一志願差呢？

---

作者: cole_chan    時間: 18-11-20 12:32

Karen2009 發表於 18-11-20 12:29
本帖最後由 Karen2009 於 18-11-20 12:29 編輯

其實B 已經由第一志願跌落第二志願，咁正常係咪 random# ...

No I think you misunderstood how the system works

---

作者: Karen2009    時間: 18-11-20 12:34

cole_chan 發表於 18-11-20 12:32
No I think you misunderstood how the system works

完全唔明   

---

作者: cole_chan    時間: 18-11-20 12:42

cole_chan 發表於 18-11-20 12:32
No I think you misunderstood how the system works

Every applicant just got one computer generated random number
Just imagine all applicants fall in ONE line to get the interview , those with priority will be put in the front of the line ( staff kids - siblings - NR - kindergarten ..) then the system will go along the line and put each applicant to the school according to his own preference when place available
If your first choice place is available , then u got the interview chance , if not , the system will go to your second choice
After going through all the preference for one applicant then the system will go to the following applicant according to the random number

---

作者: cole_chan    時間: 18-11-20 12:45

cole_chan 發表於 18-11-20 12:42
Every applicant just got one computer generated random number
Just imagine all applicants fall in  ...

That was explained in the RC school tour by the admission team

---

作者: mandy_ng207    時間: 18-11-20 13:09

回覆 Karen2009 的帖子

再舉個例子：A同B都有kindergarten priority, A排500（out of 2000), B排1000（out of 2000).
A的catchment 在SJS, first choice SJS, second choice RC. B的catchment在Bradbury, first choice Bradbury, 無second choice.
電腦會由1到2000咁去睇有無interview俾，會先睇左A（#500）才到B（#1000）.
A嘅first choice SJS已滿，就睇second choice RC, 有位，所以派了second choice.
隔左一堆人之後到B, 佢first choice Bradbury, 無乜人揀所以有位，就派了first choice.

假設有個C，係N無，排200，但佢都要等睇左A、B、同所有有priority嘅人嘅preference 之後先會到佢，假設佢同A一樣選SJS then RC，但如RC都剩返不夠200個interview 位，佢就冇interview啦。

---

作者: namyatyat    時間: 18-11-20 15:49

cole_chan 發表於 18-11-20 12:42
Every applicant just got one computer generated random number
Just imagine all applicants fall in  ...

does this mean the interview of priority group(i.e. staff's kid, sibling etc) will happen before the interview of ESF kindergarten student? I cannot find this arrangement in RC primary 1 admission website.

---

作者: 貝珠    時間: 18-11-20 16:16

namyatyat 發表於 18-11-20 15:49
does this mean the interview of priority group(i.e. staff's kid, sibling etc) will happen before th ...

Not necessary, can happen on the same day or even later than those without priority. As long as they pass the entry requirement, even applicant X ( without priority) performs excellent in the interview, applicant Z (with priority) performs good only, applicant Z will rank higher on the list.

---

作者: evacalbee    時間: 18-11-20 16:40

mandy_ng207 發表於 18-11-20 13:09
回覆 Karen2009 的帖子

再舉個例子：A同B都有kindergarten priority, A排500（out of 2000), B排1000（out ...

---

作者: namyatyat    時間: 18-11-20 16:43

貝珠 發表於 18-11-20 16:16
Not necessary, can happen on the same day or even later than those without priority. As long as the ...

This is what I understand in p1 admission before, but this year RC will interview ESF student first, then kids from other kindergarten.  
Unless school will reserve some places for sibling currently in Boxhill and other kindergarten, most place should be taken by ESF student who pass the interview and confirm the offer in first round. Seems the interview date matters under new system and sibling better study in ESF kindergarten to secure their place in primary.

---

作者: 貝珠    時間: 18-11-20 16:58

namyatyat 發表於 18-11-20 16:43
This is what I understand in p1 admission before, but this year RC will interview ESF student first ...

Siblings have higher priority than kinder. I mean it doesn’t matter about the date of interview. Eventually, it is all about priority and random number

---

作者: 貝珠    時間: 18-11-20 17:03

evacalbee 發表於 18-11-20 16:40
想問係咪先interview咗，再根據choice派邊間學校？定係假設SJC有10個位，只會安排10個人interview？
...

不是，現階段Esf central office 已經based on priority based on random number 派左一間學校給applicants ，有人有interview ，pass 左就收果間學校offer ，唔pass 的話，個chance goes to those on waiting list.

---

作者: evacalbee    時間: 18-11-20 17:06

貝珠 發表於 18-11-20 17:03
不是，現階段Esf central office 已經based on priority based on random number 派左一間學校給applicant ...

---

作者: 貝珠    時間: 18-11-20 17:21

evacalbee 發表於 18-11-20 17:06
即係assume有interview就=有學位，除非fail就call waiting interview？

Yes

---

作者: mandy_ng207    時間: 18-11-20 18:05

回覆 namyatyat 的帖子

I think if the siblings received an interview invitation on a guarantee list, then they will get an offer once they pass the interview.

---

作者: pinkmania    時間: 18-11-20 19:57

namyatyat 發表於 18-11-20 15:49
does this mean the interview of priority group(i.e. staff's kid, sibling etc) will happen before th ...

according to previous posts kids with sibling priority have already been given offers.
whereas kindie kids will have in-class assessment within Nov and be notified of the result on 30 Nov.

---

作者: columbae    時間: 18-11-20 21:36

pinkmania 發表於 18-11-20 19:57
according to previous posts kids with sibling priority have already been given offers.
whereas kin ...

NR holder is not yet assessed,  but those studying at esf kinder will get result by end of Nov? I understand NR holder has higher prority than kinder students

---

作者: namyatyat    時間: 18-11-20 22:21

pinkmania 發表於 18-11-20 19:57
according to previous posts kids with sibling priority have already been given offers.
whereas kin ...

I miss that post, meaning kids with sibling priority will know the result before the result for ESF kindergarten student?

---

作者: ddbb0099    時間: 18-11-20 22:44

namyatyat 發表於 18-11-20 22:21
I miss that post, meaning kids with sibling priority will know the result before the result for ESF ...

yes

---

作者: namyatyat    時間: 18-11-20 22:46

ddbb0099 發表於 18-11-20 22:44
yes

thanks for the info

---

作者: pinkmania    時間: 18-11-20 22:49

columbae 發表於 18-11-20 21:36
NR holder is not yet assessed,  but those studying at esf kinder will get result by end of Nov? I u ...

i am not certain of the arrangement for NR holders.

---

作者: littlesun    時間: 18-11-21 03:08

pinkmania 發表於 18-11-20 22:49
i am not certain of the arrangement for NR holders.

照我所知, 有買NR/夠早買NR的而又有位的 (每間ESF 小學都再有NR QUOTA), 已經同SIBLING或其他有PRIORITY 的申請有INTERVIEW.

---

歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/)

Powered by Discuz! X1.5