教育王國

標題: ESF 升中的疑惑 [打印本頁]

作者: little-pig-pig 時間: 18-3-4 00:20 標題: ESF 升中的疑惑

以我所知ESF 升哪一間中學，是看Yr 6時報名的地址而不是哪一間ESF 小學。問題在這裏，如果ESF小學家長鍾情某間ESF中學，舉例：Shatin College，其實他們可以Yr 6 搬去Shatin College 的catchment area住，然後就可以中學入Shatin College。如果有很多ESF小學家長都是這樣，例如CWB 同BHS，而Shatin College 因此oversubscribed，唔夠位收曬SJS 的學生（suppose全部都係入Shatin College)，遇到咁既情況，ESF會如何處理呢？請問有沒有前輩可以分享一下嗎？

作者: 貝珠 時間: 18-3-4 09:25 標題: 回覆樓主

你可以打電話去esf quarry bay office 問，佢會解釋中學收生的priority 及情況。或者打去Shatin college 的admission officer, 他們應該可以答到

作者: fwc 時間: 18-3-4 09:45 標題: 回覆樓主

學校只是盡量跟校網，有機會派去kgv 和island school

作者: little-pig-pig 時間: 18-3-4 09:52

fwc 發表於 18-3-4 09:45
學校只是盡量跟校網，有機會派去kgv 和island school

請問是哪一間學校學生有機會派去KGV /Island school? BHS同CWB嗎？即是搬屋都沒有用嗎？

作者: fwc 時間: 18-3-4 09:54 標題: 回覆樓主

Bhs,搬屋後報地址，校網應該Kgv,但校方說太多人同一校網，都是抽入去，最後入到

但有同學去了island school

作者: little-pig-pig 時間: 18-3-4 09:57

fwc 發表於 18-3-4 09:54
Bhs,搬屋後報地址，校網應該Kgv,但校方說太多人同一校網，都是抽入去，最後入到

但有同學去了island schoo ...

抽

作者: fwc 時間: 18-3-4 09:58 標題: 回覆樓主

Bhs. 好多人想選Kgv

作者: little-pig-pig 時間: 18-3-4 09:59

fwc 發表於 18-3-4 09:58
Bhs. 好多人想選Kgv

咁KJS呢？是不是必入KGV?

作者: fwc 時間: 18-3-4 09:59 標題: 回覆樓主

聽聞是優先上Kgv

作者: little-pig-pig 時間: 18-3-4 10:01

fwc 發表於 18-3-4 09:59
聽聞是優先上Kgv

即是STC都有可能優先上SJS的學生嗎？

作者: fwc 時間: 18-3-4 10:04 標題: 回覆樓主

這個不太清楚

作者: little-pig-pig 時間: 18-3-4 10:05

fwc 發表於 18-3-4 10:04
這個不太清楚

沒關係，你的分享已經好大幫忙

作者: fwc 時間: 18-3-4 10:06 標題: 回覆樓主

當時我向校務處問

你不如直接問校務處

作者: 貝珠 時間: 18-3-4 10:14

little-pig-pig 發表於 18-3-4 10:01
即是STC都有可能優先上SJS的學生嗎？

應該係

作者: bbtung 時間: 18-3-4 10:18

My daughter was studied in KGV. I learnt from a teacher of KGV that their Year 7 applicants are oversubscribed every year. Only those applicants live in the catchment area is qualified and put under the waiting list. The priority will then depends on their academic result - only English and Maths will be counted. As the selection of students by academic result is their last resort and not the aim of ESF, the school will only express to public that they will select students by random.

作者: little-pig-pig 時間: 18-3-4 10:19

bbtung 發表於 18-3-4 10:18
My daughter was studied in KGV. I learnt from a teacher of KGV that their Year 7 applicants are over ...

So KJS students don’t have priority to KGV?

作者: bbtung 時間: 18-3-4 10:35

本帖最後由 bbtung 於 18-3-4 10:35 編輯

Some classmates of my daughter go to Island school.

作者: fwc 時間: 18-3-4 11:03

bbtung 發表於 18-3-4 10:18
My daughter was studied in KGV. I learnt from a teacher of KGV that their Year 7 applicants are over ...

本帖最後由 fwc 於 18-3-4 11:04 編輯

原來這樣，我還以為抽

作者: 964000 時間: 18-3-4 11:20

bbtung 發表於 18-3-4 10:18
My daughter was studied in KGV. I learnt from a teacher of KGV that their Year 7 applicants are over ...

So for outsider, I think even more difficult to get into KGV and Shatin college. My friend from RC tried to apply SC but was told to go to Island school instead. She didn’t accept and just stay in RC.

作者: thomastaxi 時間: 18-3-4 12:19

964000 發表於 18-3-4 11:20
So for outsider, I think even more difficult to get into KGV and Shatin college. My friend from RC ...

Heard a successful case that paid a nomination right to SC in order to transfer from RC.

作者: 964000 時間: 18-3-4 12:36

thomastaxi 發表於 18-3-4 12:19
Heard a successful case that paid a nomination right to SC in order to transfer from RC.

本帖最後由 964000 於 18-3-4 12:38 編輯

Of course if you are willing to pay NR will help. But If one wants SC so badly should have gone to ESF primary and even kinder from the start which is the most straight forward way.

作者: kiwipokiwi 時間: 18-3-4 13:44 標題: 回覆樓主

唔好意思，借位一問，請問有無人知已有siblings 讀緊中學，細佬妹係咪一定會派返個間？regardless of catchment zones

作者: lui 時間: 18-3-4 15:14

kiwipokiwi 發表於 18-3-4 13:44
唔好意思，借位一問，請問有無人知已有siblings 讀緊中學，細佬妹係咪一定會派返個間？regardless of catch ...

點會呀？一定跟升中時的catchment zone。

作者: kiwipokiwi 時間: 18-3-4 22:25

lui 發表於 18-3-4 15:14
點會呀？一定跟升中時的catchment zone。

因為學校嘅house system, 如有家姐哥哥同校，細路妹一定會安排入同一個house, 諗緊會唔會派中學時都會同一做法，希望sibling間緊密聯系返

作者: Ivymom 時間: 18-3-5 09:14

本帖最後由 Ivymom 於 18-3-5 09:17 編輯

bbtung 發表於 18-3-4 10:18
My daughter was studied in KGV. I learnt from a teacher of KGV that their Year 7 applicants are over ...

一間好嘅學校自然多學生想入,
學校根據成績收學生都非常合理呀. 如果用抽籤方法反而有啲怪.

作者: 貝珠 時間: 18-3-5 13:08

Ivymom 發表於 18-3-5 09:14
一間好嘅學校自然多學生想入,
學校根據成績收學生都非常合理呀. 如果用抽籤方法反而有啲怪.
...

你試下打去問，佢地真係咁講。其實有少少同primary one 收生類似，有priority 入梗，其他人按random number 去offer assessment , pass 到就入，如果random number 差，叻到識飛都冇用。

作者: mimibama 時間: 18-3-5 13:23 標題: 回覆樓主:

outsider 入 island school, incl south and west island school 机会如何呢?

作者: 964000 時間: 18-3-5 13:36

mimibama 發表於 18-3-5 13:23
outsider 入 island school, incl south and west island school 机会如何呢?

Island school high chance, cuz they are moving to Tai wai for renovation.

作者: Chase922 時間: 18-3-5 15:06

貝珠發表於 18-3-5 13:08
你試下打去問，佢地真係咁講。其實有少少同primary one 收生類似，有priority 入梗，其他人按random numbe ...

Does it mean that even a SJS student living in the catchment zone may not get a place from SC if he/she has a bad random no?

作者: 貝珠 時間: 18-3-5 15:09

Chase922 發表於 18-3-5 15:06
Does it mean that even a SJS student living in the catchment zone may not get a place from SC if he ...

No, what I know is if students study in year 6 in sjs at the time of year 7 admission, they are likely to get year 7 offer for Shatin college . No more random number for them , sjs placement for 1 form is less than 1 form in Shatin college

作者: Chase922 時間: 18-3-5 15:57

貝珠發表於 18-3-5 15:09
No, what I know is if students study in year 6 in sjs at the time of year 7 admission, they are lik ...

Thanks

作者: bbtung 時間: 18-3-5 16:09

I don't want to argue. However, I am just curious. If ESF schools are not care about the academic result of a student, why there are English , Maths and Science admission test for all the applicants other than P1 and S1.

作者: 貝珠 時間: 18-3-5 16:29

bbtung 發表於 18-3-5 16:09
I don't want to argue. However, I am just curious. If ESF schools are not care about the academic re ...

And why there are interview for primary one ?

I think the passing line of the interview ( or may be the written assessment) are quite low when compared to other well established IS

作者: babycakes 時間: 18-3-5 21:39

bbtung 發表於 18-3-5 16:09
I don't want to argue. However, I am just curious. If ESF schools are not care about the academic re ...

Everyone knows that ESF is a non selective school! The entry test is not for the academic purposes. All u need are luck to get a spot!

作者: nintendo 時間: 18-3-6 11:08

bbtung 發表於 18-3-5 16:09
I don't want to argue. However, I am just curious. If ESF schools are not care about the academic re ...

ESF do care about academics. But is it still a non-selective school in a way that they do not screen students once they got into ESF. When I used the term non-selective, it only means it would not be like other local schools that kick students out merely because they are not surviving the curriculum. All the way from Year 1, students can proceed in their own pace. Students that are behind or students that are fast can learn with different "groups" or at different pace. Year 12 students can choose IB, IB certificate or BTEC. Unless there are other issues (behaviour issues, or learning problems, eg serious special needs), ESF do not "screen" students.

Yes, there might be different admission tests for students applying to join after Year 1. And as there are so many applicants, it does make sense to set up policies to choose who they should take. While making sure the applicant have good English standard is important, it is also important to make sure applicant can catch up with the curriculum. ESF curriculum is not particular hard but there are bench mark the schools would want applicant to meet so that the applicant would benefit from being with ESF. So, thus the admission tests.

作者: shadeslayer 時間: 18-3-6 11:22

nintendo 發表於 18-3-6 11:08
ESF do care about academics. But is it still a non-selective school in a way that they do not scre ...

Even a highly selective school I know, they don't push students out just because they fall way behind the average.

作者: nghinyau 時間: 18-3-10 00:11

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: SAS 時間: 18-4-22 04:36

kiwipokiwi 發表於 18-3-4 13:44
唔好意思，借位一問，請問有無人知已有siblings 讀緊中學，細佬妹係咪一定會派返個間？regardless of catch ...

會，sibling的話學校會問你意願，我有朋友呀哥讀緊KGV，之後搬咗屋，但如跟當時住址呀妹應去Island，到呀妹Y6KGV打電話問佢想跟呀哥去KGV定跟地址派去Island，咁我朋友當然話一齊啦，最後呀妹都去KGV

作者: kiwipokiwi 時間: 18-4-23 08:41

SAS 發表於 18-4-22 04:36
會，sibling的話學校會問你意願，我有朋友呀哥讀緊KGV，之後搬咗屋，但如跟當時住址呀妹應去Island，到呀 ...

多謝解答，呢個做法好好

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)