教育王國

標題: advise for small b (oct 2012) [打印本頁]

作者: Sweetiesdragonb 時間: 17-2-14 15:21 標題: advise for small b (oct 2012)

My child is in esf K2 now unfortunately he received no offer from esf Y1 for 2017/18. Given he is small b (born in oct 2012) he is not eligible to apply most other Y1 international school which requires age of 5 before 31 Aug 2017.

Can anyone advise me what options I can have now? Repeat K2 in Esf??? Other school opening available?

Big thanks!

作者: Chase922 時間: 17-2-14 15:33

Sweetiesdragonb 發表於 17-2-14 15:21
My child is in esf K2 now unfortunately he received no offer from esf Y1 for 2017/18. Given he is sm ...

Is your kid on the waiting list?

My kid also small b (Dec) but she is still in k1 and I want to know what can be done as probably I will face the same situation.

And u may try some new schools like Stamford and the chances may be bigger to get in.

作者: evawyma 時間: 17-2-14 15:36

U can also try malvern, mount Kelly, think, Kingston and ymca intl sch.

作者: 貝珠 時間: 17-2-14 16:24

You should have applied other IS k2 as back up. E.g. Mass intake for JIS or CIS equivalent to local K2

作者: elsathomas 時間: 17-2-14 16:49

You have no back up school?

作者: Sweetiesdragonb 時間: 17-2-14 16:49

elsathomas 發表於 17-2-14 16:49
You have no back up school?

No back up now

作者: Sweetiesdragonb 時間: 17-2-14 17:06

貝珠發表於 17-2-14 16:24
You should have applied other IS k2 as back up. E.g. Mass intake for JIS or CIS equivalent to local ...

What is JIS and CIS?

作者: 貝珠 時間: 17-2-14 17:09

Japanese international school or Chinese international school.

Now, u may consider Malvern, Stamford

Just curious , how's the acceptance rate in Tung chung Esf ? Did u apply DC ?

作者: jk121299 時間: 17-2-14 17:19

Any parents out there with small b studying at NAIS? I need some advice too, pls PM me. TIA

作者: elsathomas 時間: 17-2-14 19:19

Sweetiesdragonb 發表於 17-2-14 16:49
No back up now

本帖最後由 elsathomas 於 17-2-14 19:20 編輯

You really shouldnt just rely on esf..
besides other IS, may also try k3 at Boxhill, joyful or some other 英文/英普幼稚園.

Then try CAIS, ICS next year.

作者: 貝珠 時間: 17-2-14 20:29

Also try nais as they have new campus in Tin Wan

作者: Sweetiesdragonb 時間: 17-2-14 22:45

貝珠發表於 17-2-14 20:29
Also try nais as they have new campus in Tin Wan

Already applied this 2 years ago.
His age is not applicable for year 1 yet... application year is 2018 for him....

作者: YYNGSUKI 時間: 17-2-14 22:54

本帖最後由 YYNGSUKI 於 17-2-14 22:55 編輯

My daughter is ESF kinder last year and she is a small b too (Nov). Our case last year is got no interview offer from SJS but interview from RC. As I know that RC's interview is a selection basis, I did not make too much expectation. At that moment, my best wish is my daughter will have chance to get a place to repeat K2. But the kindergarten said it's not likely to offer this place normally. So I will vote for repeat if the kinder offers a place to repeat. Actually, small b effect seems significant to my daughter till now!!

作者: little-pig-pig 時間: 17-2-14 23:02

YYNGSUKI 發表於 17-2-14 22:54
My daughter is ESF kinder last year and she is a small b too (Nov). Our case last year is got no int ...

So where is your daughter eventually going?

作者: YYNGSUKI 時間: 17-2-14 23:26

本帖最後由 YYNGSUKI 於 17-2-14 23:33 編輯

After I read the message about the disappointment from the ESF Kindy, I would like to change my tone to present what the magic happen to my daughters. Before that, I always tell my friend that how perfect and wonderful is ESF kindy. But after reading the other parent's comment, I thought the magic will only happen if ur kids are just fit with ESF! My daughter had applied many local famous kindergarten, due to small b effect, he is very shine, not willing to talk so that she did not got any offer! However, she kept talking as usual at home when she attended the ESF Kindergarten interview! Ofcourse dye to her good performance, she got the offer. Her small b effect still affected her at most of the environment (shine, no initiative...) but only not at school! And same scenario happened, she felt comfortable in RC and even raised up hand to answer questions during the interview. (I believe that it was because she could feel ESF culture there) So she got RC offer eventually which is totally out of my expectation. ( I even had paid 50 thousand as deposit to buy NR when I know she got no SJS interview offer )

作者: Sweetiesdragonb 時間: 17-2-14 23:45

Sweetiesdragonb 發表於 17-2-14 15:21
My child is in esf K2 now unfortunately he received no offer from esf Y1 for 2017/18. Given he is sm ...

To add on, kjs replied me they don't care about your recent school report (they never take mine as part of the assessed but asked us to bring along with it) they claimed they will only observe the child's performance during that one hour interview. If your child happened to be shy or not willing to co-operate, follow teachers' instruction, you are likely to fail the interview regardless how active your child is in school.

作者: Sweetiesdragonb 時間: 17-2-14 23:46

Sweetiesdragonb 發表於 17-2-14 15:21
My child is in esf K2 now unfortunately he received no offer from esf Y1 for 2017/18. Given he is sm ...

作者: Chase922 時間: 17-2-15 07:19

Sweetiesdragonb 發表於 17-2-14 23:46
To add on, kjs replied me they don't care about your recent school report (they never take mine as ...

Thanks for the information.

作者: heihei33 時間: 17-2-15 08:20

YYNGSUKI 發表於 17-2-14 23:26
After I read the message about the disappointment from the ESF Kindy, I would like to change my tone ...

U had paid NR to get the interview offer fm Rc? my kid is also small b, really feel worry whether she can pass the interview.
she is esf kindy

作者: jk121299 時間: 17-2-15 08:48

Sweetiesdragonb 發表於 17-2-14 22:45
Already applied this 2 years ago.
His age is not applicable for year 1 yet... application year is 2 ...

They have nursery and reception class now at Tin Wan

作者: jk121299 時間: 17-2-15 08:51

Does anyone know, do sept-oct small b usually defer 1 year in IS (become super big b) or go normally with the batch within their year borne (i.e. Jan-Dec)

作者: GC0060 時間: 17-2-15 08:56

Depends on the school. Some schools has cut off date on August 31 etc but some school like ESF takes students born within the year. My daughter who is a small B (born in November) will be going to ESF Y1 in September.

作者: YYNGSUKI 時間: 17-2-15 09:21

heihei33 發表於 17-2-15 08:20
U had paid NR to get the interview offer fm Rc? my kid is also small b, really feel worry whether s ...

No, I paid NR for KJS as I thought my girl had little chance to be picked be RC at that moment!

作者: 964000 時間: 17-2-15 09:23

Sweetiesdragonb 發表於 17-2-14 15:21
My child is in esf K2 now unfortunately he received no offer from esf Y1 for 2017/18. Given he is sm ...

Check with Anfield primary their cutoff is Jan-Dec

作者: LuckySesame 時間: 17-2-15 09:38

jk121299 發表於 17-2-15 08:51
Does anyone know, do sept-oct small b usually defer 1 year in IS (become super big b) or go normally ...

I had wanted my son to wait one year and be a big b for next year, but ESF would only look at the birth year and you do have to apply within the year they specify and it's not up to the parents. They specifically told me it's unlikely he'd be allowed to wait a year, unless they see him this year and the school decides he's not ready.

作者: Alvin32 時間: 17-2-15 11:48 標題: 回覆樓主：

本帖最後由 Alvin32 於 17-2-15 12:21 編輯

I also want to say if your kid can perform well in the interview, no matter how small is your kid, she or he will be accepted. This is more likely to happen in international school than local school I guess. My kid is late December kid and he still got offer from more than 2 good through train international schools, one is ESF. We didn't possess any passport, NR nor sibling priority in both schools she got offer. My feedback is the admission will really count on the kids ability to give out offer, and the school will still reject those kids who fail to meet their requirement even they got interview with guarantee places. So I think it's somehow fair and we have hope, though it's always luck which depends on kids performance that day.

作者: jk121299 時間: 17-2-15 12:08

My son was born in Sept 13 and he's studying at K1 in an IS right now, coping well and willing to socialise, only that his English speaking skills 'needs improvement'. Now we got an K1 offer from another IS (our 1st pref) starting 2017 which means he has to repeat the grade while others move on. He seems ok in his class right now, so I requested for a K2 interview although the cut off for that school is 31 Aug. Do u think I'm doing something stupid? I don't want him to repeat, and personally think there is no need esp in an IS environment.

作者: AJW2010 時間: 17-2-15 15:19

Sweetiesdragonb 發表於 17-2-14 23:46
To add on, kjs replied me they don't care about your recent school report (they never take mine as ...

May I know if you are on the waiting list or rejected.

I know a child repeated K2 in ESF kindergarten and is Dec baby. You may talk to the school for options. This was a few years ago.

作者: Sweetiesdragonb 時間: 17-2-15 15:52

AJW2010 發表於 17-2-15 15:19
May I know if you are on the waiting list or rejected.

I know a child repeated K2 in ESF kinderga ...

Honestly I was quite disappointed with esf and will not appeal. I will turn to other school now. I am sure esf is not the only way out for my child.

作者: Petitechien 時間: 17-2-16 00:45 標題: 回覆：Sweetiesdragonb 的帖子

It is purely the decision of primary school to ask ur kid to repeat. Not an option. We are the same case and we switched to another school as we even got no interview chance

作者: Chase922 時間: 17-2-16 07:00

Petitechien 發表於 17-2-16 00:45
It is purely the decision of primary school to ask ur kid to repeat. Not an option. We are the same ...

Your kid was is esf kindy? No interview chance from both esf school and private school?

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)