教育王國

標題: Latest ISA results [打印本頁]

作者: fdwweebb 時間: 14-4-22 17:20 標題: Latest ISA results

本帖最後由 fdwweebb 於 14-4-22 17:39 編輯

Can we start a threshold to list the latest (Apr 2014) ISA results so that information can be consolidated and shared?
VSA (from a recent information session in Apr 2014)
            Math Literacy Reading Writing A-Narrative Writing B-Non-Narrative
Year 3          381                                  402                         461
Year 4          446                                  439                         495
Year 5          488                                                                   531

2013 results can be found from this link:

If can reply with your kid's school's result.  I can help to consolidate.  Thank you!

作者: fdwweebb 時間: 14-4-22 17:58

btw, here are the HK schools sat in Oct 2013 ISA/ACER exams:

Beacon Hill School
Bradbury School
Canadian International School of Hong Kong
Clearwater Bay School
Discovery College
Glenealy School
Hong Kong Academy
International College (Hong Lok Yuen)
Kennedy School
Kingston International School
Kowloon Junior School
Norwegian International School
Peak School
Quarry Bay School
Renaissance College
Sha Tin Junior School
Yew Chung International Primary School

作者: poonseelai 時間: 14-4-22 18:09

Well, I was wondering the purpose of making such a comparison. ISA is not an examination like the IBDP. You know, some kids will not take this seriously. For me, looking at the result for one year only does not give you much information. Rather I keep track of my daughters' results over a few years to see whether they have improved over the years.

作者: Radiomama 時間: 14-4-22 18:37 標題: 回覆：fdwweebb 的帖子

ESF used to announce the mean score in the annual report. You could find the result of 2012 Oct on website.

作者: tcbobo 時間: 14-4-22 20:43 標題: 回覆：fdwweebb 的帖子

其實學生有冇為考ISA或InCAS做任何預備工夫呢？例如學校有冇mock exam？

作者: sschiu 時間: 14-4-22 21:06 標題: 回覆：fdwweebb 的帖子

I wonder if we should regard such "exams" or "assessments" in international primary schools so seriously? Is it meaningful? For parents to choose schools for kids?

作者: hkparent 時間: 14-4-23 00:00 標題: 引用：I+wonder+if+we+should+regard+such+"exams

原帖由 sschiu 於 14-04-22 發表
I wonder if we should regard such "exams" or "assessments" in international primary schools so serio ...

Local minded parents with kids studying IS.

作者: fdwweebb 時間: 14-4-23 09:31

本帖最後由 fdwweebb 於 14-4-23 09:31 編輯

hkparent 發表於 14-4-23 00:00
Local minded parents with kids studying IS.

Hmm, VSA published this and was very proud of it. I don't think the school is ran by "local minded parents"?

作者: hkparent 時間: 14-4-23 09:45 標題: 引用：+本帖最後由+fdwweebb+於+14-4-23+09:31+編

原帖由 fdwweebb 於 14-04-23 發表
本帖最後由 fdwweebb 於 14-4-23 09:31 編輯

Seldom heard of schools comparing academic results among themselves at primary level in UK or US. HK schools like to do this.

作者: wywy0b0j 時間: 14-4-23 09:59

回覆 fdwweebb 的帖子

From what i can see, VSA's parents are probably the most "local-minded" among the major IS....

作者: oooray 時間: 14-4-23 10:22

回覆 fdwweebb 的帖子

I don't think most parents/schools would proud of "better than average" result in ISA.Personally, I only take these data as on of the indicators of my children progress throughout their learning stages.
Of course, schools can refer to the result and make any necessarily enhancement in their curriculum.
Such data reflect the progress of individual child and i don't feel there are any direct contribution from the schools (or reflecting particular school's quality) unless those schools take intensive effort to prepare these assessment.

Last but not least, I DO congratulate to those schools and parents who are excited to their excellent achievement in ISA.

作者: caa 時間: 14-4-23 12:03

I believe schools taking part in ISA simply wish to gauge their overall literacy levels against international average. I don't think schools or parents will be seriously concerned about the results of individual students unless they are significantly below the average. It is kind of "health check". As long as your kid is within the normal range, who would care for comparing?

作者: poonseelai 時間: 14-4-23 12:21

caa 發表於 14-4-23 12:03
I believe schools taking part in ISA simply wish to gauge their overall literacy levels against inte ...

Agree. For schools running IB PYP that are not allowed to have any kind of exams or assessments, the ISA provides a benchmark whether schools are on the right track.

作者: HKTHK 時間: 14-5-20 12:34

回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

Agree, it is helpful to have some benchmarks to make sure schools are not under-performing or lacking in particular areas

作者: annie40 時間: 14-5-20 21:20

以香港中產，富貴家庭的資源和父母的十擔心機，低過英美同齡普通孩子的平均水平，幾乎是「沒可能」。

參考指示應為高於二至四年水平。香港家長開心些，継續努力，好快第二個愛恩斯坦就誕生了。

小女念小學時，完全無家長當這些reports是一回事。水平高四年，咪開心笑下，高兩年又唔差，跟同齡鬼仔同水平，都飲得杯落。

孩子能力高低，跟老師溝通已清楚。除非學校有心騙！

作者: HKTHK 時間: 14-5-21 09:51

回覆 annie40 的帖子

I think it is quite different between established and new schools. There are no established curriculums for these newer schools to follow and they need these benchmarks for finetuning.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)