用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索

Secondary School Admission Criteria - 1

熱度 9已有 1353 次閱讀 12-4-24 21:42 |個人分類:Tips|系統分類:教育

khmama and redkoni used different ways to present the ranking for different secondary schools, like their HKCEE, HKALE and EAS results as reference, which is reviewing and help the parents to identify the target schools.

In EK, not many parents analyse the admission criteria of different schools. So I try to use some districts' schools to illustrate the focus of different schools. I list the table first and explain the strategy later.

                                                Admission Criteria
District School Name Academic Rank Order Conduct Interview ECA & Awards Others Remarks
CTL Kings       *      30% 50% ** * + ** = 20%
CTL Raimondi          60% 10% 20% 10%
CTL SSGS          60% 30% 10%
CTL Ying Wa Girls          50% 10% 30% 10%
ED BPS             40% B 40% 20%
ED CCSC          50% 10% 20% + 20% No interview
ED Chinese Women's Club          40% 20% 20% 10% 10% English Proficiency
KLC DBS           50% 20% 25% 5% Association
KLC Heep Yunn            30% 20% 30% 20%
KLC Meng Sang          50% 35% 15%
KLC PLKNPL          40% 15% 30% 15%
KT Chuen Yuen          60% 10% 15% 15%
KT Lam Woo 12% 12% B 64% 12%
KT On Chue 20% 30% B 30% 20%
ND Chan Chun Ha         20% 30% 40% 10%
ND Tang Hin * 20% ** 30% 20% * + ** = 30%
ND TWGH's Kap Yan         56% 30% 14%
SSP CSWCSS 20% 15% 15% 30% 15% 5% Principal recommendation
SSP Holy Trinity 25% 25% * ** *** English * + *** = 25%; ** + English = 25%
SSP Ming Yin         50% 30% 20%
ST Christ College 15% 20% 20% 35% 10%
ST Lui Ming Choi         25% 25% 25% 25%
ST Tsang Shiu Tim * 60% 30% ** * + ** = 20%
TM Leung Kau Kui         30% 5% 50% 5% + 5% 5% English Proficiency
TM Li Shiu Chung         50% 30% 20%
TM Tang Yuk Tien 50% 25% 25%
WC QC          50% 5% 30% 15%     
WC SPCS        25% * 50% ** * + ** = 25%
WC SPSS        40% 20% 20% 20%
WC True Light        55% 15% 15% 15%
WC WYHK * 20% ** 50% *** * + ** + *** = 30%
YTW DGS        50% 50%
YTW QE 20% 15% 35% 20%
YTW WYK 30 pt 30 pt 5 pt 40 pt 25 pt Points to shortlist for interview








Academic and rank order 20% - 60+%, the lowest is Chan Chun Ha (20%), Lam Woo (24%), SPCS (25%)…  Tsang Shui Tim (60+%), Chuen Yuen, SSGS, Raimondi (60%)

Conduct may not be counted in some schools, some is B as minimum, the % ranging from 0-30%, the highest is Chan Chun Ha (30%), LMC (25%), Heep Yunn, Christ College, SPSS, Chinese Women (20%).

Interview performance is from 0-64%, CCSC is no interview at all. Lam Woo 64%, Leung Kau Kui, SPCS, WYHK, and Kings are 50%.

ECA and Awards is from 10% to 40%, the lowest is Lam Kau Kui, Christ, Chan Chun Ha, chinese Women, YWG, SSGS, Raimondi (10%), Lam Woo (12%), the highest is CCSC (40%).

Others are English proficiency, association and principal recommendation.











路過

雞蛋
2

鮮花

握手

雷人

剛表態過的朋友 (2 人)

熱門日誌導讀

發表評論 評論 (22 個評論)

回覆 manmanchubb 12-4-24 23:46
多謝你無私既分享,你一直既資料都好深層次同詳盡,而呢個入場計分數據好有用,另外多謝你 IBDP既詳盡分析, 我還須要時間慢慢消化你提供IBDP 既資料...btw, Thank you for yr info ,nice to meet you
.
回覆 ANChan59 12-4-24 23:47
Me too.

Pls comment and share your views.
回覆 Yanamami 12-4-25 08:56
其實我覺得講係禁講, 但以上%作不得準. 以阿囡為例, 佢ECA無乜特出, 而佢而家間中學亦不太重ECA, 佢P6成績只屬中上, 所以我覺得佢而家間中學收佢, 只係睇中佢英文"比較"好.
回覆 ANChan59 12-4-25 09:19
Yanamami

妳的情況跟我講的%冇衝突,學校以此標準作詳估是可信性頗高。妳女兒的情況是跟其他人比較,例如她成績中上,升中後,妳女兒仍然中上是合理情況。如果她在中下,則妳女兒被取錄是由於其他因素,例如優異的英文能力或特異功能。妳不需要妄自菲薄妳女兒的能力。我列出此表之前,都有分析考量,我對此都有d信心。我在第2部分,會針對部分家長的錯配作分析,例如DBS給大家的感覺是專收特異功能,是否事實的全部,面試呢? 比例呢? 希望妳明白。

再者,妳選了一間合適及合理的學校給妳女兒。
回覆 Yanamami 12-4-25 17:52
其實點解我禁講呢.....係因為St Paul's Convent School的admission criteria係: Academic Performance 25%, Non-academic Performance 25%, Interview Performance 50%.  但去簡介會時, 老師話係睇全港排名.  而且阿囡當日無2nd in.(Fair enough, 佢interview表現並不突出), 一個校內排名差佢3x~4x名的但interview performance都俾校長讚的女仔有2nd in.  若以SPCS所列的criteria, 這女孩應被取錄, 但當然是失望而回.  所以我地d mami個個覺得, 乜都係假, 成績最重要.  謝謝你的鼓勵, 我和囡都很喜歡現時的中學.  但有時她會動搖, 問我如果去差一點的中學, 做到top25%, 那入U希望會否高些? 我要消化一下, 想想如何能給她一個合理答案.
回覆 ANChan59 12-4-25 20:30
多謝妳的分享,若果妳的說法是對的,亦可以幫助其他家長。

剛剛過関,明天才寫第2篇。我不是說必入名校秘笈,而是從Admission Criteria 分析不同學校的目標學生,錯配的原因及機會。
回覆 Yanamami 12-4-25 20:47
其實也不知對不對的, 只是個人經歷.  小女也有住華英中學(kln City)面試.  華英的criteria是40%成績, 30%面試, 40%獎項/服務.  之不過面試是6~8人一組, 用英文介紹自己, 朗讀一篇英文文章, 然後中文題(抽咭片就咭上題目自由講)&小組討論.  阿囡經過SPCS的interview後, 只覺華英的十分「行貨」, 似是循例式多一點.  她的結論是直資名校像是要起你底一樣, 津校的interview就相對"easy job".  註: 這也是我給她報SPCS的目的, 見識一下+先苦後甜.
回覆 ANChan59 12-4-25 20:58
請不要介意,SPCS在妳來說是練兵,得自然開心,失敗亦無妨。現在當事後孔明,妳覺得妳女兒的profile 是否合理符合該校的Admission Criteria?

我反而覺得小兒不是best fit, 第一階段備取是合情合理,要第二階段入到反而合理。世事無絕對,大家分析之下肯定有d 新發現。妳講講下,我有d 想更深入研究,將來做升學顧問更賺錢。
回覆 Yanamami 12-4-25 21:10
Not at all! 我都無諗過佢會考到.  Get experience o者.  佢考另外兩間DSS分別是沙田培基(band2, 有免學費offer添) & 匯基(Kln East).  兩間都有offer, 但當時唔知點解頗有信心入華英, 所以HTC都無信心入只係自行時搏高一線, 禁o岩佢同校有幾個女仔(校內排名皆比她高)選左DSS, 佢先好彩博到咋 ....係EK好多升中老手, 你仲有排學呢(IB你就熟).
回覆 Yanamami 12-4-25 21:14
其實我早問過班主任, 我校入SPCS的女仔校內排名是多少. 佢話1X~20(我女之前果年學校有4個入左).  我女排41~50.  所以早知SPCS唔會so佢, 但勝在SPCS會in晒所有applicants, 我知一定有得in(唔會連in都無得in而打激佢自信心)先至apply.
回覆 lillymarie 12-4-25 21:17
嘩!interview原來要過關斬將咁刺激!好在我囝囝不用經這考驗,肯定無望。
回覆 Yanamami 12-4-25 21:21
所以過完P5/P6, 個人老左好多呀~~~~
回覆 Snakemama 12-4-25 21:54
Yanamami: 其實點解我禁講呢.....係因為St Paul's Convent School的admission criteria係: Academic Performance 25%, Non-academic Performance 25%, Interview Performan ...
非常同意你所說:成績最緊要。因看到有幾間知名的DSS學校、官津校,都是在教育局出了全港學生成績排名後,才出面試或2nd面試名單的。
回覆 ANChan59 12-4-25 21:57
Yanamami: Not at all! 我都無諗過佢會考到.  Get experience o者.  佢考另外兩間DSS分別是沙田培基(band2, 有免學費offer添) & 匯基(Kln East).  兩間都有offer,  ...
妳講得啱,升中的心得只有幾間中學,不及其他高人,我亦在日誌內讚賞他們。今次亦只是探索其他觀點而已,可能辛苦幾年搞定個博士,休息咗大半年,有d技癢。
回覆 Yanamami 12-4-25 22:01
Wooooo~~~~厲害!
回覆 Yanamami 12-4-25 22:27
By the way, Hip Yan =>  Heep Yunn?
回覆 ANChan59 12-4-25 22:29
Yanamami: By the way, Hip Yan =>  Heep Yunn?
Amended.

Thanks,,,,,,
回覆 One-Mama 12-4-25 22:49
GOOD JOB!如果放在升中派位置頂, 應該會幫到更多家長.  當年如果我手上有你地咁豐富INFO, 我就唔使咁震啦!, 又唔可以震到比呀囡知...
我等過氣升中家長現在仍感受到被當年的震撼情境影響著, 說是為後來者分憂打氣, 可能亦是為我自己解窘吧...HA!
回覆 Yanamami 12-4-25 23:00
Eeeeee.....會唔會我地解讀呢d criteria錯左呢?  呢d percentage係applicable to 果d已有資格interview既applicants, 而唔係general criteria?  即係睇完全港排名選中你有份in, 之後用呢d criteria去評學生.  事關你話林護睇重interview>成績, 我唔信o羅.  被邀請有得in, 成績已有番禁上下, 所以其他比重可多d?
回覆 ANChan59 12-4-25 23:07
Yanamami: Eeeeee.....會唔會我地解讀呢d criteria錯左呢?  呢d percentage係applicable to 果d已有資格interview既applicants, 而唔係general criteria?  即係睇完全港排 ...
You demonstrate different parents have different interpretations of those criteria, I guess most of us not really understand the criteria.

After reading those info during data collection, I discovered that WYK used point system to shortlisted the eligible students first, then based on interview performance to finalize the candidates. So the shortlisted are upto certain level before interview.

facelist

你需要登錄後才可以評論 登錄 | 註冊

Copyright c 2002 - 2018 Baby-Kingdom.com Limited, All Rights Reserved.
GMT+8, 18-7-21 09:49, Processed in 0.072081 second(s), 10 queries , Xcache On.