ESF, Malvern, ISF 比較

little_angelll

有呢三間kindergarten offer, 你會揀邊間？

supervi

回覆 little_angelll 的帖子

ISF

RRDDragon

如果不考慮距離，學費，student mix, 將來會否移民，我都揀ISF

iseatrit2013

little_angelll 發表於 23-4-11 12:45
有呢三間kindergarten offer, 你會揀邊間？

性價比esf isf很難轉走

964000

little_angelll 發表於 23-4-11 12:45
有呢三間kindergarten offer, 你會揀邊間？

看各人的要求，我目標小學係重英文的IS, 所以會揀ESF
ISF幼稚園係中英係7:3比例，playground language 一半英一半普通話，如果要考其他IS，要自己另補英文

Youweird

964000 發表於 23-4-12 09:00
本帖最後由 964000 於 23-4-12 09:10 編輯

看各人的要求，我目標小學係重英文的IS, 所以會揀ESF

我想法跟你一样。
而且不论是教学理念还是升学理念isf太内地化，不是我的菜

964000

Youweird 發表於 23-4-12 09:17
我想法跟你一样。
而且不论是教学理念还是升学理念isf太内地化，不是我的菜

對，所以最好親自去參觀下，初初都以為ISF是「中文好的IS」, 去小學school tour時看見foundation year要背古詩，assembly 會一齊打武術，另外學校有show學生作品，以高小的英文writing 和ESF比（因為識人讀緊所以看過）感覺還是有點距離。小朋友巳在IS nursery本身教育理念都想自小跟返IS那一套，最後沒有取offer.
所以問人意見不如想清楚看自己教育理念，更不要只看成績，如果要求繁體中文水平高尤其PTH流利, 又有英文語境ISF是個選擇

simonchan1986

回覆 little_angelll 的帖子

It really depends on your kid. If he/she is more of an introvert who is willing to sit down and listen to the teacher, then ISF will be more suitable. Else ESF should be more suitable. I know from a couple of friends that ISF is quite strict, kind of like local school.
You should also keep in mind ISF has a much stronger focus on Chinese at pre-sch level (flip side being much less focus on English), is that something you can live with/mitigate through private tutoring. Of course if you want strong Chinese too, then ISF will be ideal choice.

I have no idea about Malvern.