FIS vs ESF, which one is better?

Wwong071

melobi12 發表於 21-11-12 13:42
FIS IBDP成績唔標青，一嚟同應考人數少有關，應該唔夠50人考? ESF 考IBDP嘅人數就多好多了，咁「中狀元」 ...

ya~~ agree. what u mentioned are so valid, especially on the laid back part(emoji)(emoji)(emoji) I am totally that style(emoji)(emoji)(emoji)

dem0cracy

melobi12 發表於 21-11-12 13:42
FIS IBDP成績唔標青，一嚟同應考人數少有關，應該唔夠50人考? ESF 考IBDP嘅人數就多好多了，咁「中狀元」 ...

係，過去有啲graduating cohort得二三十人。人少所以IBDP成績波動大，我明呀，但好多人唔係咁諗呢…所以都係FIS唔受"目標為本型"家長青睞嘅原因呀～

講開先講，疫情期間IBDP免試計分法，學校往績佔好大權重（前年係，上年唔清楚），FIS雖然近年穩步上揚但歷史上variation大，咁嘅algorithm對呢兩屆FIS IB考生係好不利的，我都好鄧佢哋唔抵，不過也幸好外國好多大學唔淨係睇分數。

goodanta

回覆 dem0cracy 的帖子

IS新手，其實我都唔係好明點樣先為之ib 成績好, 雖然冇其他學校咁多狀元，我亦唔覺得/冀望個仔做到狀元 haha~ 同埋見到佢平均分都有三十幾分, 100%pass rate, 對我自己Standard來講算幾好啦 😅 ， 我見有啲家長都話佢幾academic

964000

I don’t think there Is any huge difference in IB results between ESF and FIS, in the past FIS used to be slightly better (range 37 ) and ESF average mark used to be 35.x . Last year is atypical with grades inflation and ESF suddenly went up to 38  and FIS remained at 37  with an exceptionally small cohort, so ESF became slightly ahead.
FIS used to be academically robust for its primary so there shouldn’t be a sudden change.
The communities are different between two schools, FIS is more “westernized” and laid back, even the locals there are more relaxing. ESF has more locals and local parents will find more comfortable to mingle here.

wingjaiii

本帖最後由 wingjaiii 於 21-11-12 16:22 編輯

鹹魚青菜各有所愛
我覺得如果一心想讀ib就Esf, 想英制就fis，唔難選擇

knk83

Off topic
見大家咁中意講IB result
DBS 勁喇啩
但係考頭三分一先有得揀讀IB
其他就dse
我個表弟就瀬嘢
中二先開始搞去英國
嗱手唔成世
所以睇學校唔可以浄睇IB result

Wwong071

knk83 發表於 21-11-12 19:06
Off topic
見大家咁中意講IB result
DBS 勁喇啩

totally agree~~~其實㨂任何學校 (local or IS) 都係應該睇適唔適合自己小朋友!!!!!!!!
unless there is a crystal ball telling me my son is the future Einstein, orelse the academic results of the school really doesn't matter to me.
I just want my son loves going to school like I did.

sabsab122

回覆 wingjaiii 的帖子

如果比較校風、 老師質素、關愛及學習風氣、硬件配套呢？這兩間邊間較好？我見有啲國際學校處理欺凌問題好差， 可以話係視而不見。
所以比較着重關愛/心理支援方面，請問你覺得FIS /ESF 邊間好啲？

wingjaiii

knk83 發表於 21-11-12 19:06
Off topic
見大家咁中意講IB result
DBS 勁喇啩

所以一早講咗如果想讀ib就一定係揀Esf，咁多年經驗。如果讀讀下英制想轉IB，其實真係會揦手唔成勢，兩樣唔同嘅嘢嚟。反而如果IB想轉英制，都係死記死背，易上手好多。

btw我最憎啲學校要成績好先可以揀ib，自己想讀唔得咩？所以dbs嗰啲算吧啦。

另外可以比較埋fis其他公開試嘅成績，睇吓有冇你想要嘅嘢

wingjaiii

sabsab122 發表於 21-11-12 19:17
回覆 wingjaiii 的帖子

如果比較校風、 老師質素、關愛及學習風氣、硬件配套呢？這兩間邊間較好？我見有啲 ...

Esf用家，我唔覺得學校唔理bully喎，會引導小朋友處理問題同埋注重建立小朋友自信心，同埋學校成日強調「kind & peace」我好鍾意，覺得學校好關愛。

fis未真正讀過不能評論，聽朋友講比較自由，再開放啲，不過講真讀國際學校你都係想佢開放姐

wingjaiii

dem0cracy 發表於 21-11-12 14:45
本帖最後由 dem0cracy 於 21-11-12 14:45 編輯

係，過去有啲graduating cohort得二三十人。人少所以IBD ...

其實英制又何嘗唔係，今年全部校內評估，導致出現勁多「狀元」

knk83

另外
去英國升中學
好多都睇second language
French, Spanish, German

FIS 同esf 呢方面應該有啲唔同
要留意下

wingjaiii

knk83 發表於 21-11-12 19:48
另外
去英國升中學
好多都睇second language

本帖最後由 wingjaiii 於 21-11-12 19:53 編輯

其實佢哋唔會介意你好大個學，朋友個仔都係入英國名寄宿學校，14歲，都係去到先開始學德文，完全冇問題，講真好多local school過去都唔會有人學左second Language啦。

咁當然語言早學係好好

重申，帶頭盔先，從來都唔係覺得Fis唔好，如果覺得唔好，我哋當時都唔會報名一直都好鍾意法文。

knk83

wingjaiii 發表於 21-11-12 19:51
本帖最後由 wingjaiii 於 21-11-12 19:53 編輯

本帖最後由 wingjaiii 於 21-11-12 19:53 編輯

Er..我前幾年幫表弟表妹搞去英國中學

去到嗰邊interview 五六間
都問其他language
有啲仲即時揾個老師同你chat
好彩佢哋學開Spanish
吹到兩咀

當然你可以話間間睇幾重都唔同

goodanta

FIS 係咪舊年(2020-2021)先開始有nursery? 之前一直得reception?

liubabyliu

goodanta 發表於 21-11-12 20:28
FIS 係咪舊年(2020-2021)先開始有nursery? 之前一直得reception?

Yes, 唔記得今年定上年開nursery, 之前only RC 之後Y1

goodanta

回覆 liubabyliu 的帖子

我今年成九月尾先申請2022-2023既nursery，就算pass左interview都唔知有冇機會 ….

Wwong071

goodanta 發表於 21-11-12 20:28
FIS 係咪舊年(2020-2021)先開始有nursery? 之前一直得reception?

不是。今年21/22是nursery的第一年搞。今年年頭開始interiew

Petitmonde

回覆 Wwong071 的帖子

I have an elder boy in ESF Y6 and a younger girl at junior primary school in FIS
Both schools have their strengths - overall though I like FIS which seems to have a relatively high expectation and commitment to academic excellence including maths.  Another consideration is smaller class size for FIS and less SEN support, being a more selective school

AIW

Petitmonde 發表於 21-11-13 18:29
回覆 Wwong071 的帖子

I have an elder boy in ESF Y6 and a younger girl at junior primary school in F ...

你好，介唔介意講下，PYP同IPC的分別，及各自優劣？謝謝你