用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 小一選校 高小vs sjps
樓主: nanakochan
go

高小vs sjps  


55254
發表於 20-7-10 10:30 |顯示全部帖子
fruitfulsnoopy 發表於 20-7-10 10:19
Rcps 校舍唔好?(不過真係唔太好,哈哈)但你入到sjps的校舍就知。
另外,覆埋另一jm,sjps係冇 ...

SJPS只係路過望到,我真係未入過去~~~

RCPS係佢初期搬入去去過,舊校舍囉,無太大感覺,係華小隔離~~~

校舍對我來講唔太重要~~~

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

醒目開學勳章 貢獻勳章


33464
發表於 20-7-10 11:01 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 小曳人 於 20-7-10 12:03 編輯
lambeanmama 發表於 20-7-10 09:21
但SPECIAL NEEDS也要看是小朋友自己本身的天賦或是後天父母的早教;作為一所謂名私幼家長,身邊學習能力高 ...

只係俾個相反嘅情況供參考
我當年都無諗得太複雜....
恐龍家

Rank: 4


544
發表於 20-7-10 11:42 |顯示全部帖子
回覆 小曳人 的帖子

趙sir的書,信一半都太多!

點評

小曳人    發表於 20-7-10 12:40

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4503
發表於 20-7-10 13:15 |顯示全部帖子
lambeanmama 發表於 20-7-9 14:19
首先要了解一吓,小朋友學得快是因為家長超前教育還是小朋友資優? 兩者有很大的分別。如果小朋友是資優,我 ...

本帖最後由 kimlam953 於 20-7-10 13:37 編輯

哈哈我都留意到身邊有唔少「被資優」小朋友

不過有趣嘅係,佢地驗完又真係有130以上,只係理解能力,記性etc 又同我心目中嘅資優好唔同(我心目中嘅資優係一講就明,再自己理解,鑽研;自學能力強,而不是靠被充實而強)(我知我知,資優有好多種)這些資優朋友仔共同點都係阿媽由細到大都安排補中英數音樂十幾樣...

所以好有興趣知,到15歲大啲再驗,呢班小朋友仲會唔會係資優呢?

Rank: 4


798
發表於 20-7-10 13:52 |顯示全部帖子
感謝各位的寶貴意見,還有幾位版友私下給我的意見,真的萬分感謝,已放位!

另外有版友討論資優和被資優的問題,我誠心推介一本書叫《智力革命》,由一位Mensa 成員寫的,其中有部份探討西方社會如何對高智力這件事嗤之以鼻的風氣,有參考價值


Rank: 6Rank: 6


9351
發表於 20-7-10 14:02 |顯示全部帖子
回覆 nanakochan 的帖子

My son transferred from SFA to SJPS. The major motive for the transfer is to reduce the pressure from SSPA on our family.
In recent years, about 110 students from SJPS are promoted to SJC (99 reserved places for Central Allocation and remaining via Discretionary Stage and "Knocking Door"). With a few Band 1 and 2 students will go for DSS schools and international schools, 110 places should cover all the Band 1 and 2 students of SJPS. A SJPS student is almost guaranteed a place at the college if he works decently hard. As a result, my son could still afford to participate in a few ECA and competitions even in P5 and P6 and this made his school life more balanced and enjoyable.

Regarding the academic standard, SJPS has no advance teaching and just follows the EDB curriculum. It doesn't mean SJPS' academic standard is low. Taking English as an example, the school will give its own worksheets and supplementary exercises to complement the textbooks in teaching. If you take a look the school yearbook of SJPS and read the essays written by its students, you can see their English standard is very good.

It is hard to tell one school is better than the other. You should think about what your family is looking for before making the decision.

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

醒目開學勳章 貢獻勳章


33464
發表於 20-7-10 14:10 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 小曳人 於 20-7-10 14:10 編輯

關於被資優

HK係全球IQ score 最高城市,以100為平均數,HK係107

而如果以WISC IV 香港版做嘅評估,會將107 調節返去100
所以,如果真係用香港版作評估 (要滿6歲),部份被資優嘅問題已經corrected
但如果係做幼兒版的話,有可能做到130,但其實响HK未算資優

又,資優有好多特質,包括一樣令家長好頭痛嘅無學習動機、潛能未展,引至學業成績未見突出

恐龍家

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3220
發表於 20-7-10 18:51 |顯示全部帖子
提示: 該帖被管理員或版主屏蔽

Rank: 6Rank: 6


9351
發表於 20-7-10 20:51 |顯示全部帖子
回覆 legoisland2005 的帖子

sure

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4216
發表於 20-7-11 00:09 |顯示全部帖子
mcl203 發表於 20-7-10 10:30
SJPS只係路過望到,我真係未入過去~~~

RCPS係佢初期搬入去去過,舊校舍囉,無太大感覺,係華小隔離~ ...

兩間我都去過,其實差不多大同殘


55254
發表於 20-7-11 00:13 |顯示全部帖子
monodad 發表於 20-7-11 00:09
兩間我都去過,其實差不多大同殘

我去RCPS果陣應該係新裝,將舊校翻新,當然唔知RCPS近年有無豪裝過~~~

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2374
發表於 20-7-11 17:44 |顯示全部帖子
Frankly speaking, just take out 1 test paper of P5 SJ and RC you will soon have an idea of how hard the syllabus is.
It's no meaning if a school tell you they are teaching in advance...sometime like the topics in English could be arranged in different orders. But if you compared about the difficulty, the comprehension of SJ in p5 could give you a hint. RC English is way too easy in this aspect. And RC exams papers always resemble what the school exercises, while SJ exams papers are not resembling what the kids learn in class. Unless your kids are very talented, many go to tutorial classes.
So When you compare the school, you better see what do you want. if you want hard, sj must be your first choice, but whether the students gain it by school or by any other means......I can't give a comment here

Rank: 3Rank: 3


379
發表於 20-7-11 17:49 |顯示全部帖子
kimcheeball 發表於 20-7-10 07:22
樓主都係一個快樂的煩惱⋯但我自己就會簡原本已經有offer間私校。
正如去公立同私家醫院咁。私校大家都係考 ...

比喻得好好,有能力去私院生梗係好d,但公立都大排長龍架

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2374
發表於 20-7-11 17:51 |顯示全部帖子
There are 99 seats out of 150 students who could go to SJC. And I can tell you the competition is really huge as people are trying to get into band 1 to make admission to be 100% grantee. Band 2 may have around 90% chance as some top students go to QC. The life in sj is study study study.....
So You can't simply say SJ or RC is better. it depends on what you want.

And of course, RC would have more resources to teach the kids.
But when the pressure is less hard, students result won't be that competitive ....
but if it is necessary to push the kids at primary level?
Hennessy Road didnt teach very hard stuff and many students go to QC because of the linked seats
Those students will eventually have better results than those of SJC.....
em...the road is too long and there are a lot of variables....

Don't worry too much.
Each school has its advantage , just choose the one fit your needs and expectation....

But one thing you really need to bear in mind If you choose SJ, the campus is extremely small to cater 5 classes per grade......dont expect you can run or walk smoothly in recess.....

usually kids stay at desk to play with friends...
But If you kids can get into SJPS by knock door, guess your son must be a talented one....
but in sj or dse...sometime , apart from talent, diligence is more important....

Rank: 10Rank: 10Rank: 10


28772
發表於 20-7-11 23:14 |顯示全部帖子

回覆樓主:

本帖最後由 yuenkw 於 20-7-11 23:20 編輯

睇過SJPS 高小數學paper, 同SJC S1差無幾!

Rank: 6Rank: 6


5130
發表於 20-7-12 18:31 |顯示全部帖子
chanchancat 發表於 20-7-11 17:51
There are 99 seats out of 150 students who could go to SJC. And I can tell you the competition is re ...

咁軒小一級有幾多人?有幾多入QC?你話軒小教得唔深,咁點解入QC果d會比SJ考得好?

Rank: 6Rank: 6


9424
發表於 20-7-12 20:24 |顯示全部帖子
I ll pick sjps

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2374
發表於 20-7-13 16:32 |顯示全部帖子
kwokbobo 發表於 20-7-12 18:31
咁軒小一級有幾多人?有幾多入QC?你話軒小教得唔深,咁點解入QC果d會比SJ考得好?
...
There are 12 years in primary and secondary.All I can tell you is Hennessy Road is teaching normal stuff.....not hard
but the ones who go into the QC would be trained in that secondary 6 years...

many people disagree with it and think school should teach hard stuff in early ages....
it depends...
sometime 拔苗.....
Em.....if you look at st Paul cat...the syllabus in primary Is also not hard....
but in secondary they will work very hard ......

sometime in primary...should we really not pushing them too hard ...
to give them the thirst of learning....'
em...really a philosophic question.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2374
發表於 20-7-13 16:35 |顯示全部帖子
SJC must be better than RC in term of academics...
but see if you would like to fight for that 99 seats or just want a relatively more guaranteed seats in RC

heard 樓主 will study overseas...
maybe you need to concern more on your grandson


2102
發表於 20-7-13 17:54 |顯示全部帖子
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽