馬鞍山區 ：學之園 vs 合一堂 vs 靈糧堂

catchopBB

呢三間有offer其實係咪唔洗簡一定係學之園？
不過另外兩間又好又免費好似放棄又好可惜

piglover

比錢，仲要學費唔平 vs 免費

當你覺得比錢貴，擔心物非所值時，我會叫你選券幼加外補算啦。

piglover

每年7萬幾 vs 幾千，真係好大分別㗎。三年後，三十萬 vs 1萬。 30倍價錢。

有人會選擇拎30萬去外補嘅。

leemiuling

吾諗錢一定學之園，冇的輸。

longlongching

一定係學之園

mlsbbe

回覆 catchopBB 的帖子


Ling Liang?
LH (DC campus) doesnt appear too high on some kindergarten rankings. And of course, cost $$$. We also went for interview at Hop Yat / LH but first impression the teachers don't seem too enthusiastic compared to other schools. I guess it depends what kind of person your child is right? My child is the lively/active kind and would probably hate sitting down quietly so I would choose schools with more "enthusiastic" teachers I guess. (By that I mean they wouldnt frown on the more active kids)

Didn't get offer at LH (DC campus) or at Hop Yat but we luckily we did get offer at Think (Ma On Shan) which seems to appear high on the rankings. Pre-interview / Interview the teachers do appear genuinely nice & experienced. But of course also cost $$$ there. I  think these kindergarten offers are like lottery and depends if your kid is on form that day...

We have another offer at an affiliated "Dragon School" (that a lot of LH students  went on to attend) so its a difficult choice and big headache for me.   

piglover

樓上有嘅龍校offer係浸幼，不過，浸幼不是直升wkf(詳情大家可以上浸幼個web site)，而wkf更並非LH學生首選。

樓上提過，好少LH學生入到wkf，其實係錯覺，因為有好多LH學生更好offer，自然就會放wkf。唔通有spcc，dbs，yw，港同，TSL，仲會要wkf咩？

piglover

LH間間課程都一樣. LH賣點係自家教材，以及教學方法。快 活 谷。小朋友可以學得深，但又可以吸收到。好多私幼課程係深，但小朋友識唔識就另一回事，好多家長要不斷自己再教小朋友。

至於點解某d分校好似睇落成續好d，某d差d，同家長取態，仲有居住地點考慮。tko校家長通常願意讀番原區嘅直資就算。

而青衣，凱帆，家長願意搬屋來就小朋友升小，所以會選校更積極。

piglover

如果錢並非考慮因素，就LH。

如果要考慮學費，我會選擇合一堂加外補。

mlsbbe

piglover 發表於 19-12-29 09:28
樓上有嘅龍校offer係浸幼，不過，浸幼不是直升wkf(詳情大家可以上浸幼個web site)，而wkf更並非LH學生首選 ...

Actually 18 LH students went to WKF last year. That's a lot! Who knows whether they got other offers?

Admission to LH doesn't guarantee you to be admiited at 100% of all primary schools of your choice. Who knows what will happen 3 years later?  Does it give you the best chance? Not according to the primary school placement statistics.

If you look at the placement statistics to primary schools at LH (Double Cove), a few of the schools aren't too bad but aren't the top. The no. of top school admissions at LH ( DC Campus)  is similar to Liang Liang/Hop Yat. But I believe that doesnt justify the $$$. Of course, at other LH campus' is a different story, their admissions rate at top schools are much higher.

wg_ann

私幼同券幼從來都係兩個不同市場，睇餸食飯，如果經驗有壓力，不要勉強揀私幼，如果無壓力，私幼固然有其好處，如英文語境，教學模式，學術程度及其他支援等等。如果唔係，都唔會咁多人俾錢讀私幼，買既就係比券幼既增值服務。

Cigaretteyip

LH於學術、語文環境、名氣及家長質素，都較其餘2間優勝，只是要付出學費，考慮清楚吧。