2個小朋友分，一個讀LS,另一讀IS

MPSW

有沒有人因為性格特質及能力的原因，將仔女分開一個讀LS，另一個讀IS?
長遠有不良後果嗎？例如2個的溝通問題、感情、價值觀.....等

如有此cases, 可否分享一下，謝謝！

papa8888

I had one son attend IS and another son attend LS and my only advise is if you are financially stable send both to IS.  This not to say LS is not good, but just too stressed.  

MPSW

papa8888 發表於 19-2-9 23:46
I had one son attend IS and another son attend LS and my only advise is if you are financially stabl ...

謝謝回覆，可否分享多一點2兄弟於不同的教育制度下，兄弟及父母有沒有面對什麼難題？

我讀緊LS的那個（高小）很喜歡現在的模式，也應付到，佢話唔想轉IS

papa8888

It all depend on the kid   My younger child started at local kinder and than LS so used to the routine.  My older son went to UK and was in primary 2 and couldn’t speak too much Chinese so we had to send him to IS.  

Just to compare a typical day...my younger son leave home at 7am and back home at 7pm (as he goes to after school tutor class to do his homework.  My older son who go IS leave home at 8am and home by 4pm and plenty of of free time after school.  

MPSW

papa8888 發表於 19-2-10 00:00
It all depend on the kid   My younger child started at local kinder and than LS so used to the routi ...

Did your younger son complain to you “why my brother can be so free but I’m so busy?”

Will u send young one to IS too?

papa8888

Also I can compare the difference especially the way English is taught in local school....by memorising the words rather than using Phonics..there is so much I can compare that I can go on and on with the difference.

papa8888

But I think if your kid is doing well in local school and enjoying it then no need to change to IS.  

papa8888

回覆 MPSW 的帖子

No since he was still young and did not compare and also he is used to local system (ie lots of homework)

papa8888

回覆 MPSW 的帖子

After 5-6 years at primary LS, younger son is now studying at IS.

MPSW

papa8888 發表於 19-2-10 00:38
回覆 MPSW 的帖子

After 5-6 years at primary LS, younger son is now studying at IS.

Thanks for your sharing.
Why u finally take younger son to IS too?
Language concern or workload issue?

My concern is the difference on language (English) standard when they grow up. For sure study in IS one will be better. Scare LS one will blame me why I don’t send him to IS too.....(but he say dun wanna change now).

papa8888

回覆 MPSW 的帖子

Exactly what you mentioned, the English standard and workload was major reason I now send my younger son to IS.  My younger son never complained once about being unfair send brother to IS and not reason I am sending him to IS now.

hitommycc

MPSW 發表於 19-2-9 23:52
謝謝回覆，可否分享多一點2兄弟於不同的教育制度下，兄弟及父母有沒有面對什麼難題？

我讀緊LS的那個（高 ...

尊重佢個人意見嘍。有的小朋友喜歡LS everything under control，IS go wild會冇安全感。

samsam123321

hitommycc 發表於 19-2-10 00:58
尊重佢個人意見嘍。有的小朋友喜歡LS everything under control，IS go wild會冇安全感。
...

......

hitommycc

samsam123321 發表於 19-2-10 13:07
Ls點every thing under control?IS點go wild 法？

LS統一課本練習，大家學同樣內容，重溫書默書操卷，分數成績是唯一標準。IS尤其IB對research能力要求高，注重思考/發問，以personal inquiry為例，更多是啟發式自主學習，要「讀得好」，課外也都需要花費很多時間精力，再到課堂與大家分享、討論，每個人學習內容不同，學習程度短期內難以以分數量化，因此是「wild」。

LS優勢是基本功紮實。IS優勢是思維靈活知識面廣。兩種截然不同的學習方式，各有各適合人群。

我見過LS讀完primary轉IS的仔，無閱讀習慣，不會自主學習，以為IS=hea，每天開心到爆。私以為這一類學生不轉反倒是好事。

papa8888

回覆 hitommycc 的帖子

Yes. From my older son experience happy and relaxed (hea) up to maybe year 9.  But from year 10 onwards had been busy and not like the first 8-9 years....

hitommycc

papa8888 發表於 19-2-10 14:44
回覆 hitommycc 的帖子

Yes. From my older son experience happy and relaxed (hea) up to maybe year 9. ...

Then he must be very smart. My boy isn’t one of the smartest kids so he hasn’t been「hea」since y5. He is the kind of student who is very conscientious and would do well at LS. After transferred to IB curriculum he realized he had to spend more time on his projects and learn more to join class discussions. I’m just happy to see that he’s always trying his best.

papa8888

回覆 hitommycc 的帖子

He is not very smart, average I would say but he wants to do well so puts in the effort.  Yes lots of project works which suits him rather than a loads of test and end of season exams.  

papa8888

But going back to the original question, anyone thinking of transferring to IS from LS should not leave it too late otherwise it will be harder to adapt as they get older.  Also unless they go to an English medium LS it is very hard to catch up with English (as the other student would consider English to be their first language). This is what I am finding from my younger son.

Osiana

hitommycc 發表於 19-2-10 14:03
LS統一課本練習，大家學同樣內容，重溫書默書操卷，分數成績是唯一標準。IS尤其IB對research能力要求高， ...

"LS優勢是基本功紮實" -- 好多人都咁唸，其實只不過係LS係一隻填鴨，只係不求理解，不斷咁塞。 可能初期係有D 優勢，不過，其實不求甚解，只係背咗好多野入腦，水過鴨背，考試後忘記得一乾二淨。

tcbobo

Osiana 發表於 19-2-23 01:25
"LS優勢是基本功紮實" -- 好多人都咁唸，其實只不過係LS係一隻填鴨，只係不求理解，不斷咁塞。 可能初期係 ...

非常同意，講得好！