本地學校讀IB,和去英國中學讀IB，考香港大學的分別

nintendo

ANChan59 發表於 18-2-19 14:37
我知你說那幾個網友，都是奇人！

如果只 share 意見，也 fair ，各自表述。
最怕是基本資料錯誤，指出佢錯，佢認自己唔熟，但過一個星期又再 post 同一錯誤資料。
又軟皮蛇，話極唔聽。

elbar

nintendo 發表於 18-2-21 12:27
如果只 share 意見，也 fair ，各自表述。
最怕是基本資料錯誤，指出佢錯，佢認自己唔熟，但過一個星期又 ...

咁真係累人(筆錢)

ANChan59

nintendo 發表於 18-2-21 12:27
如果只 share 意見，也 fair ，各自表述。
最怕是基本資料錯誤，指出佢錯，佢認自己唔熟，但過一個星期又 ...

EK 自己個平台都唔 care，why bother?!

shanna852

nintendo 發表於 18-2-19 14:18
EK 部分人真係害人不淺。
有幾個仇 non-jupas 的人，成日話 IB 易。
又有某人，佢自己小朋友好釆，A Level ...

好有同感！

shanna852

Bluegene 發表於 18-2-19 21:30
不要認真，純粹攪笑，當然有些真實。

攪笑搵第二樣，不要誤導網友家長。

Bluegene

shanna852 發表於 18-2-24 18:22
攪笑搵第二樣，不要誤導網友家長。

有些真實，不是完全攪笑，20未夠 CU畢業。一個 Case唔表乜嘢，冇理由以偏概全。

ABC-DAD

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/educa ... is-it-any-good.html
幾年前，the Telegraph 教育版嘅文章，睇下都唔錯嘅。節錄部份如下。
"The IB was introduced in the late Sixties to cater for the growing numbers of internationally mobile students who wanted an education that was not tied to any national government’s agenda. More than that, it sought to bring together Cold War children from the West and the East, and thereby promote future peace.

Even today, the International Baccalaureate Organization is driven by a somewhat grand mission statement, which reads: “The International Baccalaureate aims to develop inquiring, knowledgeable and caring young people who help to create a better and more peaceful world through intercultural understanding and respect.”

Of the four study programmes now offered by the IBO, by far the most popular in the UK is the IB diploma. It is not just an alternative to A-levels but an entirely different two-year programme of learning.

During the course, students pick one subject from each of six subject groups – languages, sciences, the arts, and so on – and study three of these to a higher level. In addition, they take a course in “the theory of knowledge” (TOK), write an extended essay and participate in “creativity, action, service” – a nonexamined module that focuses on — yes — creativity, sport and community service.

Grading at the end comes down to a points score: marks out of seven for each subject, and three possible additional points for the combined TOK and essay, for a maximum of 45 points."

ABC-DAD

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/educa ... -levels-and-IB.html
。。。。。。。

Richard Cairns, head of Brighton College
12:00PM GMT 10 Nov 2011
To choose between A-levels and International Baccalaureate, ask whether you are a specialist or an all-rounder.
This is the time of year when Year 11 students across the country are enrolling at sixth-form open mornings to consider their future options. One factor they increasingly need to consider is whether to study A-levels or the International Baccalaureate.

With 150 British schools and colleges now registered to offer the IB – still a very small proportion of the schools in England – there is a very real alternative to the traditional A-level route to university entrance.

So what are the differences?。。。。

。。。。

ANChan59

ABC-DAD 發表於 18-2-25 06:40
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/secondaryeducation/8881037/How-to-choose-between-A-levels-and-I ...

我的認知是個校長講完一大堆事實及歷史，，過份集中了專才及通才(菜)的分別，然後 full stop。他忽略了 IB 課程的整全(holistic)及知識整合(integration)。

IB 評分不是單純標準答案，還有 rubrics ，讓學生可以獨立分析，個人意見及觀點被接納！

這種訓練讓學生就算出來社會，亦可以好短時間掌握資料，分析，將重點以文字及或口語表達出來，如果是修讀雙母語，真的接近兩文三語的要求！

ABC-DAD

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

我估你只睇左我節錄嘅部份。

ABC-DAD

分享上面兩文，係畀家長樓主同其他家長睇下英國方便對IB Al 之間某啲睇法，只係 一鱗半爪。

Head of BC 文中結尾係咁:

"My advice to Year 11 students is the same as the motto carved into the wall of the oracle’s temple at Delphi: know thyself. Think very deeply about what would best suit you as an individual.

And remember, the best sixth formers are not outstanding because they follow the A-level or the IB, they are outstanding because they have teachers who inspire them intellectually. That is what you must look for as you head from one open day to another."[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delphi]

而且亦是2011嘅觀感，現時會否就社會脈搏調整左，看官自行決定。有無課程比其他課程更優秀，會深度幫到學生更有力去適應社會，我[ 不敢苟同]。父母師長朋友的元素我會看重一點。

LeeCC

ABC-DAD 發表於 18-2-25 11:35
分享上面兩文，係畀家長樓主同其他家長睇下英國方便對IB Al 之間某啲睇法，只係 一鱗半爪。

Head of BC 文 ...

謝謝分享

ABC-DAD

回覆 LeeCC 的帖子

唔好客氣，做大決定前，可以有多角度嘅訊息會實在點。

ABC-DAD

事實好多香港去嘅y10學生,GCSE考11/12 科全A，三種語言嘅大有人在，8/9個A*升sixth form再報4/5科AL. 我估佢地都好有競爭力。

LeeCC

ABC-DAD 發表於 18-2-25 12:06
事實好多香港去嘅y10學生,GCSE考11/12 科全A，三種語言嘅大有人在，8/9個A*升sixth form再報4/5科AL. 我估 ...

有親戚仔仔話，係香港band1學校讀完中三，成績中游的，過到去英國，已經係精英

ABC-DAD

回覆 LeeCC 的帖子

係咪精英尚言之過早，能夠揾到合適嘅土壤，多多少少會有助益嘅，重點係自願去，有志向同目標最重要，更加上可以培養獨立能力，並且不在父母直接影響下發展個性，如條件許可，係一個好嘅方向。

ABC-DAD

去得日子長，就會發覺天外有天，人上有人，同埋在文化差異的環境下如何自處。

ANChan59

ABC-DAD 發表於 18-2-25 12:37
回覆 LeeCC 的帖子

係咪精英尚言之過早，能夠揾到合適嘅土壤，多多少少會有助益嘅，重點係自願去，有志向 ...

你這點我同意，精英是會隨階段改變，不會永遠不變，一直要保持精英中的精英會十分辛苦！

當然，太低端會被歉棄，中上就好！大家對中上有不同理解，最緊要自己舒服！

ANChan59

ABC-DAD 發表於 18-2-25 11:35
分享上面兩文，係畀家長樓主同其他家長睇下英國方便對IB Al 之間某啲睇法，只係 一鱗半爪。

Head of BC 文 ...

多謝你介紹 Delphi 的概念，我略有認知是用於作 Long term planning 或 Qualitative forecast 的 Delphi Model！

是同一個題目，不同專家有不同看法，若果有機會看到其他人的觀點，個別專家會調整自己的觀點，經過多次調整，各人觀點會越來越接近，達到共識！

我沒有實際應用過，但一直感覺是知易行難。越精英的人，普遍越難接受其他人的觀點！

ABC-DAD

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

好在我唔係，我主要在享受生活。