HKU Admission Scores 2017 仲未出?

nhi

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

You are rightThx

Choisumwong

回覆 nhi 的帖子

Roughly, I guess 15 students from IB and 15 students from A-level in HKU. I have no idea for CU. I  guess more than 50 students from IB. Maybe I am wrong.

nhi

Choisumwong 發表於 17-11-8 08:23
回覆 nhi 的帖子

Roughly, I guess 15 students from IB and 15 students from A-level in HKU. I have no ...

From the pie charts, many more students from GCE than IB for hku medicine.

Choisumwong

回覆 nhi 的帖子

I think the pie chart is not proportional. It said only 5 graduate students in 2017, but it looks like the same proportion as IB in the pie chart.

ANChan59

nhi 發表於 17-11-8 08:43
From the pie charts, many more students from GCE than IB for hku medicine.

My info may be outdated, HKU preferred GCEAL as some government officials and professors’ kids were studying boarding schools in UK with or without overseas educational allowance.  (From two professors of HKU medical school. )

Therefore more GCE than IB for some years. Relatively less graduate students.

In CUHK, the % of IB much more than GCE, also for graduate students (15).

CUHK prefers graduate students as they are generally more mature and the attitude of studying is better than high schools students, no matter what curriculum they come from.

nhi

Choisumwong 發表於 17-11-8 08:51
回覆 nhi 的帖子

I think the pie chart is not proportional. It said only 5 graduate students in 2017 ...

I did not intend to say that you are wrongBut is it possible that it is a misunderstanding of the genuine number for graduate students? A number of 5 is just too small to believe!

nhi

ANChan59 發表於 17-11-8 09:07
My info may be outdated, HKU preferred GCEAL as some government officials and professors’ kids wer ...

Fo you mean 15 graduate students for cu thick year? This number is also very small!

ANChan59

nhi 發表於 17-11-8 09:36
Fo you mean 15 graduate students for cu thick year? This number is also very small!

我以前有問到相關教授，他的解釋是部分畢業生可能第一個學士學位已經有資助，不能第二個學士學位又再得政府資助，所以這類學生一直數目不能太多，兩間醫學院都傾向不會收太多，從而影響其他學生的機會，始終香港不是美制收醫科生。

我自己識的兩個 graduate students 都是美國畢業，第一個學位沒有資助。

LingChiBaBa

如果pie chart比例同figure係啱，我估分佈如下。

HKDSE : 169人
GCEAL : 29人 (5A*x1, 4A*x12, 3A*x16)
IB          : 16人 (45分x3, 44分x8, 43分x5)
Graduates : 16人
Others  : 5人

ANChan59

LingChiBaBa 發表於 17-11-8 10:28
如果pie chart比例同figure係啱，我估分佈如下。

HKDSE : 169人

合理好多。