請問有無聖保祿2018報名時間表? - 小一選校

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2007

81^#

發表於 17-10-6 21:52 |只看該作者

For my year... my girl’s class has no wait list as we have 4 boys in our class.

siden

公爵府

Rank: 10


	25420

82^#

發表於 17-10-7 09:16 |只看該作者

Monghar 發表於 17-10-6 21:52
For my year... my girl’s class has no wait list as we have 4 boys in our class.

有幾多個男仔根本冇關係

某年某班有4個男仔，有5個女仔waiting

果5個女仔由10月wait到8月，冇一個waiting收得番

bbaunt

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1218

83^#

發表於 17-10-7 10:05 |只看該作者

siden 發表於 17-10-7 09:16
有幾多個男仔根本冇關係

某年某班有4個男仔，有5個女仔waiting

好慘！其實小朋友都唔開心，見到同學仔無得升上去

little_goat

Rank: 2


	34

84^#

發表於 17-10-7 11:05 |只看該作者

siden 發表於 17-10-7 09:16
有幾多個男仔根本冇關係

某年某班有4個男仔，有5個女仔waiting

Yes.有一年6個女仔on waiting.
3個肯定到開學都無被call waiting.
仲未計有d可能唔講比人知on waiting 的.
SPK & SPCS各自為政的，幼稚園老師自己都唔知準則。
收唔到的學生完全靠自己出面再拼過，幼稚園都唔會幫到什麼。

Bevaja

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	260

85^#

發表於 17-10-7 13:20 |只看該作者

little_goat 發表於 17-10-7 11:05
Yes.有一年6個女仔on waiting.
3個肯定到開學都無被call waiting.
仲未計有d可能唔講比人知on waiting 的. ...

唔好睇少修女嘅網絡，佢肯幫你講，你間間都入到，但問題係佢肯 recommend嘅學生又點會入唔返SPCS?

有個朋友，同校長關係好，结果校長幫佢個仔攞咗2間男校 offers. 另外有朋友住九龍，個女喺羅便臣道嗰間幼稚園，小學收咗，讀咗一年，又係同修女關係好，學校保送佢插班尖沙咀間女校小二。

老師就未必有力，但佢地都好好。我地遞咗個 decline offer 信之後，班主任同我地傾，想阿女上SPCS，不過同佢講係入咗DGJS之後，佢都祝福我地同話間學校都啱阿女。

fluty

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2533

86^#

發表於 17-10-7 14:34 |只看該作者

Bevaja 發表於 17-10-6 11:22
每一年，小學校長都會去K/N 同啲小朋友傾計，佢會叫啲有家姐嘅小朋友舉手的，跟住問d家姐喺唔喺SPCS(PS)。 ...

咁如果家姐哥哥唔係神校會不會一樣小氣唔比offer

hygge

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	377

87^#

發表於 17-10-8 22:11 |只看該作者

回覆樓主

大埔間spcn上小學部係唔係特別少？即使上到，佢地是否比起spn 同spk的小朋友讀得吃力呢？

BallBall417

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2023

88^#

發表於 17-10-8 22:19 |只看該作者

hygge 發表於 17-10-8 22:11
大埔間spcn上小學部係唔係特別少？即使上到，佢地是否比起spn 同spk的小朋友讀得吃力呢？
...

約6成。有年24個女仔，最後收約15個。

3hearts

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1775

89^#

發表於 17-10-8 23:22 |只看該作者

Bevaja 發表於 17-10-7 13:20
唔好睇少修女嘅網絡，佢肯幫你講，你間間都入到，但問題係佢肯 recommend嘅學生又點會入唔返SPCS?

有個朋 ...

你相信真的不是幼稚園㨂人上小學嗎?

sicam

Rank: 2


	75

90^#

發表於 17-10-9 00:42 |只看該作者

Bevaja 發表於 17-10-7 13:20
唔好睇少修女嘅網絡，佢肯幫你講，你間間都入到，但問題係佢肯 recommend嘅學生又點會入唔返SPCS?

有個朋 ...

請問你知唔知，如大女走左去dg/spcc，會否影響呀妹直上convent小學嘅機會？謝謝

BallBall417

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2023

91^#

發表於 17-10-9 01:15 |只看該作者

3hearts 發表於 17-10-8 23:22
你相信真的不是幼稚園㨂人上小學嗎?

本帖最後由 BallBall417 於 17-10-9 01:22 編輯

這永遠係一個迷

Bevaja

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	260

92^#

發表於 17-10-9 08:25 |只看該作者

sicam 發表於 17-10-9 00:42
請問你知唔知，如大女走左去dg/spcc，會否影響呀妹直上convent小學嘅機會？謝謝
...

呢D嘢冇人知，但係我信，所以報嗰時冇填家姐資料。

sicam

Rank: 2


	75

93^#

發表於 17-10-9 10:27 |只看該作者

Bevaja 發表於 17-10-9 08:25
呢D嘢冇人知，但係我信，所以報嗰時冇填家姐資料。

謝分享

Thunderbolt3

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	469

94^#

發表於 17-10-9 13:51 |只看該作者

回覆 little_goat 的帖子

其實大家會唔會認係幼稚園老師選那一些waiting 的學生而不小學的Sister呢？Sister 只係去幼稚園逗留很短的時間就能決定??

Thunderbolt3

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	469

95^#

發表於 17-10-9 14:12 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 Thunderbolt3 於 17-10-9 20:20 編輯

bbaunt 發表於 17-10-7 10:05
好慘！其實小朋友都唔開心，見到同學仔無得升上去

其實真的好殘忍。因為選不到你真的不是小朋友的能力！
幼稚園也不會解釋，只是叫你寫信去小學。
但最重要係大家不要灰心，努力裝備自己。
到時候去考其他小學及叩門時會有surprises!
要證明給他們知道選了我的小朋友去waiting list，
我們也會努力不懈考到更好的學校！

little_goat

Rank: 2


	34

96^#

發表於 17-10-11 18:15 |只看該作者

Thunderbolt3 發表於 17-10-9 14:12
其實真的好殘忍。因為選不到你真的不是小朋友的能力！
幼稚園也不會解釋，只是叫你寫信去小學。
但最重要 ...

no clear instruction or directions or support would be given by school if the students were not selected. parents’ disappointments are well understood especially no one knows the selection criteria and they were being told that their girls were doing good at school. Some rejected girls are really nice & clever. The best will come.

Thunderbolt3

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	469

97^#

發表於 17-10-11 21:07 |只看該作者

little_goat 發表於 17-10-11 18:15
no clear instruction or directions or support would be given by school if the students were not sel ...

I fully agree with your comments.The pain point is no acceptance criteria and the kindergarten's class teachers only said it was the decision by the primary section. (Which I'm not certain about it)
Fortunately I know that most of the girls in the waiting list are smart enough to get the offers from other good primary schools.

Bevaja

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	260

98^#

發表於 17-10-11 21:25 |只看該作者

Thunderbolt3 發表於 17-10-11 21:07
I fully agree with your comments.The pain point is no acceptance criteria and the kindergarten's cla ...

I can understand your feeling. It is somehow not about whether the girls on waiting list are smart or not, it is the disappointment after studying in SPK for 2 years or SPN for 3 years but your girl is eventually not accepted by the primary school.

perhaps only the primary school headmistress knows the selection criteria, if there are....

3hearts

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1775

99^#

發表於 17-10-11 22:52 |只看該作者

Bevaja 發表於 17-10-11 21:25
I can understand your feeling. It is somehow not about whether the girls on waiting list are smart ...

i guess it all come down the hidden agenda... degree of relationship.. other than that..hard to explain why they will put those smart girls on waiting.

siden

公爵府

Rank: 10


	25420

100^#

發表於 17-10-11 23:30 |只看該作者

回覆樓主

I’ve never seen any spk girl who was not accepted by primary was problem free.

It’s not a secret at all that kinder would provide reports to primary to indicate the performance of the girls for primary selection. You may search the forum, parents made this same comment years ago.

Those girls who were “smart and nice” in others’ eyes had their own problem in class which were noticed by their experienced teachers but were not obvious to others.