中西區禮賢會

helimonster

dreamdream081 發表於 16-12-6 11:14
Yes, this should be one of the key reason

我唸唔會係尼個原因掛...
無理由專登收d表現無咁好的學生，如果真係咁樣收生，間學校的質素都唔方好。

in得好唔收，in得無咁好但收左，尼d情況好多學校都會有。只不過in得好的學生連waiting都無就奇怪左d

fasic88

同意每間學校有不同收生准則，也不一定要收全部會做到的。當年大仔單獨見SMM，老師問粒糖什麼顏色，我仔答是外面白色，裡面紫色，老師特登在走時告訴我阿仔這樣答，我都很surprise,覺得一定收啦，結果連waiting 都沒有。


今次細佬見禮賢，只做到一半task，但是對老師提問有回答，家長問答我也不是回答很詳細，有下午班waiting。

Maggiechanwa

jacky400 發表於 16-12-6 11:25
I think most of our daughter/son who perform well and did't get offer are put AM as 1st choice (incl ...

咁應該都唔導致waiting都無呀

Chichikid

或者學校已經心中有數係會收邊一部分條件既人，所以當日表現只作參考。即使你表現一般只要中條件都會收，其他既即使叻到識飛佢都唔會考慮。

jacky400

回覆 Maggiechanwa 的帖子

that's mean the number of those who have elders or old school mates are much more than the available offer (standard offer + waiting offer)

Therefore , if you choose AM as 1st choice , interview performance is basically irrelevant. however , if you choose PM as 1st choice and perform well , it should be very high chance or at least in the waiting list.

Lupdoy

哈，大家都有同樣諗法，又覺得唔公平，咁我地一齊忘記呢間學校，期待更好的！

helimonster

Maggiechanwa 發表於 16-12-6 11:34
咁應該都唔導致waiting都無呀

我估計佢am連waiting都好少quota，所以好多人連waiting都無份。

而佢又唔肯將報am的人考慮俾pm offer，所以am一無位，就好易咩都無。相反，報pm世襲比較少，學位自然多，面試表現一般的學生可能都有機會。

當然尼d都係我地估，事實係點無人知。不過如果佢肯問下d家長如果am無位肯唔肯讀pm，情況可能會唔同。

jacky400

helimonster 發表於 16-12-6 11:44
我估計佢am連waiting都好少quota，所以好多人連waiting都無份。

而佢又唔肯將報am的人考慮俾pm offer，所 ...

I believe so.

dreamdream081

Lupdoy 發表於 16-12-6 11:43
哈，大家都有同樣諗法，又覺得唔公平，咁我地一齊忘記呢間學校，期待更好的！ ...

monchichipapa

rachelchow 發表於 16-12-6 09:38
我收到下午班offer...其實當日我地冇去in,因為同另一間學校撞期，過左2日之後主任打比我地問我地想唔想補in ...

咁奇怪？

monchichipapa

Forgetmenot999 發表於 16-12-6 11:11
就是因為表現太好，她們認為其他港島女龍幼有offer的機會很高，依過往經驗最終會放棄學位，那就幹脆的連wa ...

多謝你安慰我

不過今次令我覺得所有嘢都係一場戲

包括老師的讚美

Lazycat128

原帖由 monchichipapa 於 16-12-06 發表
多謝你安慰我

不過今次令我覺得所有嘢都係一場戲

Agree.
老師吾應該講話遲d見呀依d説話，俾左假希望人地，最後乜都冇㑹另人失望到谷底

monchichipapa

Lupdoy 發表於 16-12-6 11:43
哈，大家都有同樣諗法，又覺得唔公平，咁我地一齊忘記呢間學校，期待更好的！ ...

Yes

我哋一齊忘記佢！

jacky400

I think 嘉諾撒聖心 should be in similar way to choose students otherwise i cannot explain why their interview is so easy and only last for few minutes

rayau

monchichipapa 發表於 16-12-6 12:25
多謝你安慰我

Wish you good luck and you will find a good school !

monchichipapa

jacky400 發表於 16-12-6 12:36
I think 嘉諾撒聖心 should be in similar way to choose students otherwise i cannot explain why their  ...

咁天主教，中西區，interview 做到哂

會不會有機會？

我怕到時又用另一種方法去screen

因為又有人話聖心中宗教地區舊生都唔收

St Clare's 我中哂，interview 做到95%

收嗎？

不過60個位

會唔會又冇份？

救命！

愈來愈緊張

monchichipapa

rayau 發表於 16-12-6 12:39
Wish you good luck and you will find a good school !

Thanks

U too

rachelchow

del..

monchichipapa

Sofia88 發表於 16-12-6 13:28
應有問㗎

冇問