8級鋼琴對考中學有用還是投資其他樂器？

dbbcowmama

小女小三，打算今年考5級鋼琴和正在初學長笛。想問問大家意見，考完5級琴是否應投資時間去考其他樂器考到高級？因為再繼續考琴，就好難專注長笛或再學多樣樂器，畢竟時間同精力有限…
如果識精通其他樂器，但鋼琴只有5級，對考中學有冇幫忙？

ivory0915

鋼琴就算有 8 級, 都唔覺得有咩幫助, 太多人 8 級了,

(我小朋友當年升中前, 都係 8 級)

cmchang0927

如果以升中為本，piano係最冇用的因為幫不到學校樂團。
其實很多學樂器的也是piano 和另一樣同時一起學，好像沒有太大差別的。

bbbusy

太多人中學前已經 8 級了

lovecupid

最好是學 管弦樂團 編制內有的常規樂器（可參考香港管弦樂團）
鋼琴現在不太受學校重視
一來不能幫手學校管樂團、弦樂團或管弦樂團….
二來有八級鋼琴證書但琴技和造詣連初學的學生實在太多….既幫不了合唱團伴奏、連校歌都彈不出來….（就當他們是為培養興趣，陶冶性情吧…..）..

諷刺是鋼琴應是最難學的樂器之一，卻被看低…..

相反常規樂器…就算多爛的造詣，ABRSM八級100分合格的水平也能應付學管樂團或管弦樂團的4-5級樂譜要求。（小提琴例外…..）

fany

我也有類似疑問，但與升中無關。女也是小三，明年考長笛三級及鋼琴四級，要專注一樣樂器，也不是易事，須用不少時間，不知應否專注一樣。

muse_melody

fany 發表於 16-11-16 23:14
我也有類似疑問，但與升中無關。女也是小三，明年考長笛三級及鋼琴四級，要專注一樣樂器，也不是易事，須用 ...

我自己個人經驗，我係考完DipABRSM 鋼琴，才由零開始學小提琴。可能因為我有一定鋼琴程度，所以拉小提琴時睇譜，拍子都唔會成問題，考8級小提琴時，sight reading 和aural 係相對高分過scale 和pieces. 我覺得係我有鋼琴底，所以sight reading 和 aural先高分。因為鋼琴睇兩行譜，小提琴一行，所以sight reading 相對容易。至於aural, 學鋼琴對樂曲的和聲了解較多，對aural都好有幫助。

fany

謝謝兩位意見！

I also agree that children don't spend enough time practising the instrument. My daughter prefers playing the flute more but seems she's not talented in flute( as I noticed that she tries so hard to control the tone and breathing). She can sight read quite well because she also plays the piano. She has a good piano teacher and to me and her, I think piano is easier than flute( as she has a good teacher and I also play the piano). However, it's difficult to find a good flute teacher ( it's been the third teacher already, touchwood this time the teacher seems alright).

I want her to join any kind of band so that she can enjoy playing music with others....never wish for being a professional.

She's still ok at this point. I will see how she's going after taking both exams. Have to consider if she can manage school too.

moon.ng

原帖由 Oboe_FRSM 於 16-11-16 發表
If your main goal of learning music is to get into a school, piano is almost useless and flute is n ...

如果有鋼琴8級distinction證書，校際比賽5、6、7、8級都有冠亞季獎呢？

cmchang0927

回覆 moon.ng 的帖子

上年我女報中學，佢p4時有g8 piano distinction, 校際有D頭三名獎，最後的music audition piano冇被選中作測試，反而被選中了級數較低的銅管作測試。後來取錄了，申請music scholarship也是憑著銅管獲得點點的scholarship. 我不知道其他學校的取向是否一樣。。

moon.ng

佩服！👍👍！

cmchang0927

回覆 moon.ng 的帖子

女的同學叻好多，有一個小六前已piano saxophone singing g8, 仲識彈guitar, 成績又級頭五，乒乓中國功夫又有奬，呢D真係才女。

moon.ng

我們不奢望以鋼琴為特異功能入到理想中學，只希望可以在課外活動欄目裡面有那麼一兩分加就滿足了。

moon.ng

那真是神人!她本身一定是十分享受音樂！還要保持到成績！否則會被人話沒有快樂童年回憶！

cmchang0927

回覆 Oboe_FRSM 的帖子

Oh yes, her school has both wind band and orchestra. My girl only joined the wind band and she told me that for the woodwind, members are g8 and above. For brass, g6 or above is ok.