APS, KTS, SFA, TSL, KC 升中派位比較

hkpapa852

大家咁鍾意攞D有名氣既直資/私立小學嚟VS, 我就幫你地整個: (其實半年前整過, 不過係人地個vs帖入面......)

	2012/2014				2013/2015
小學	升讀B2A-B1中學%	升讀B1中學%	升讀B2A-B1中學%(直資)	升讀B1中學%(直資)	升讀B2A-B1中學%	升讀B1中學%	升讀B2A-B1中學%(直資)	升讀B1中學%(直資)
APS	90.91%	81.12%	7.69%	41.26%	94.12%	86.76%	6.62%	39.71%
KC	77.78%	75.93%	1.85%	41.67%	79.31%	77.01%	2.30%	33.33%
KTS	85.15%	71.29%	11.88%	35.64%	95.10%	79.41%	10.78%	43.14%
SFA	88.28%	78.62%	4.14%	19.31%	85.27%	79.84%	2.33%	15.50%
TSL	80.25%	45.86%	34.39%	15.29%	81.76%	54.09%	27.67%	27.04%
	2014/2016				2015/2017
小學	升讀B2A-B1中學%	升讀B1中學%	升讀B2A-B1中學%(直資)	升讀B1中學%(直資)	升讀B2A-B1中學%	升讀B1中學%	升讀B2A-B1中學%(直資)	升讀B1中學%(直資)
APS	94.04%	81.46%	11.26%	46.36%	93.92%	82.43%	10.81%	36.49%
KC	79.55%	78.41%	1.14%	31.82%	68.42%	66.67%	1.75%	28.07%
KTS	95.12%	82.11%	13.01%	38.21%	89.60%	70.40%	16.00%	33.60%
SFA	90.15%	78.79%	6.06%	21.97%	85.82%	78.36%	4.48%	14.93%
TSL	86.11%	59.72%	26.39%	25.69%	80.67%	58.67%	22.00%	24.67%

*** 2015/2017年升中派位表現, KC資料由家長提供, APS, SFA和TSL以校網料為準, KTS未有官方公佈 (但有會員把校內派位名單拍照上傳), 稍後會再更新 ***

APS: 九龍塘宣道小學
KTS: 九龍塘學校(小學部)
SFA: 聖方濟各英文小學
TSL: 保良局陳守仁小學
KC: 北角蘇淅小學

一線中學名單, 包括以下帖中既"B1中學"和"B2A-B1C中學":
2016年B1中學名單+部份中學Banding (以DSE成績/入U率評分)

ANChan59

I considered the Band 1 students %, also considered the effort in academic drilling.

hippoo

多謝分析! 好有用!!!

mrs.frog

hkpapa852

ANChan59 發表於 16-4-29 20:18
I considered the Band 1 students %, also considered the effort in academic drilling.

In reality, no one will know the B1 student % of primary school except EDB, but EDB will not disclose this info.

Therefore, we can only based on the number of student promote to so-called B1 Secondary School to estimated the % of B1 student of that primary school.

Alll of those schools are good with high % of B1 school, and some of them are come with special pattern every year:

APS - Many boys like move to DBS, as well as other SKH B1 Elite schools, like DGS and SPCC

TSL - High % of student move to NPL (may be many of them are NCS), the other popular are those girl school keen on English (like Marymount and St Paul Convent)

SFA - Among the other few schools, the % of student move to DSS is the lowest one. Girls are focus on the HTC, boys are focus on WY(Kln) in the past but shifted to St Joseph last year.

KTS - Distribution of student are relatively more even than the other few schools.

KC - Focus on Island side school

ANChan59

回覆 hkpapa852 的帖子

How about Kei Wan at Eastern District ?

hkpapa852

ANChan59 發表於 16-4-29 23:37
回覆 hkpapa852 的帖子

How about Kei Wan at Eastern District ?

~6x% student promote to B1 school in past to years

qooqoobaby2010

如果女仔， kts 定 sfa 升上band 1機會大d?

lui

原帖由 qooqoobaby2010 於 16-04-30 發表
如果女仔， kts 定 sfa 升上band 1機會大d?

不是邊間上b 1機會大吧？是學校有幾多上band 1%?

mymelody0701

KCS not bad

Lindytiger

mymelody0701 發表於 16-6-10 04:40
KCS not bad

其實KCS 不嬲都勁架, 同SFA 有少少類似都係較著重學術&升中成績好. 不覺係EK 少人提, 港島區會多人認識多D. 我諗原因有幾個: 香港8成人口 住九龍&新界, 而新界人又好多唔介意出九龍區返學, 所以自自然然多人討論APS, KTS, SFA & TSL. 另外, KCS 校舍又真係舊同埋少課外活動又要比學費, 教學模式又較傳統,  所以如果介意呢D樣野既家長可能會選基灣/軒小...... 願意比學費既又可能會讀救恩, SSCPS, 港同, SPC, SPB等等.......再加埋港島又咁多間有中學back up 既傳統名校, 少人留意KCS 係好正常.

hkpapa852

Lindytiger 發表於 16-6-10 09:32
其實KCS 不嬲都勁架, 同SFA 有少少類似都係較著重學術&升中成績好. 不覺係EK 少人提, 港島區會多人認識多D ...

不過, 事實亦唔係咁多人頂得順KCS個種超傳統+催谷+全英普既教學.

Lindytiger

hkpapa852 發表於 16-6-10 09:55
不過, 事實亦唔係咁多人頂得順KCS個種超傳統+催谷+全英普既教學.

我尤記得那些年去聽入學講座, 全國語加冇powerpoint 既 presentation 簡直令人呼呼入睡 我諗要做最Top 個班既學生就應該同讀另外嗰幾間都一樣要咁谷, 不過佢有功課堂所以可以完成到大部份功課先返屋企, 可以留返時間去操體藝/補習. 至於普通話教學就要睇小朋友適應能力囉!

hkpapa852

Lindytiger 發表於 16-6-10 10:11
我尤記得那些年去聽入學講座, 全國語加冇powerpoint 既 presentation 簡直令人呼呼入睡 我諗要做 ...

由幼稚園直上個班會易D適應既

beautyhar

我住港島的朋友好多都去考KCS, 好多都幼稚園上小學, 中學都派的唔錯。

mymelody0701

KCS 係EK真係好小人提，以佢地嘅成績在東區絕對稱得上一線小學，傳統有傳統嘅好，當然加多些課外活動，會更收家長歡迎。

Lindytiger

mymelody0701 發表於 16-6-10 10:49
KCS 係EK真係好小人提，以佢地嘅成績在東區絕對稱得上一線小學，傳統有傳統嘅好，當然加多些課外活動，會更 ...

我成日都覺得港島區家長相對地係少D係EK 發言, 有時我會諗如果將KCS & 港同放係九龍區, 可能立刻變成超大熱

hkpapa852

Lindytiger 發表於 16-6-10 11:10
我成日都覺得港島區家長相對地係少D係EK 發言, 有時我會諗如果將KCS & 港同放係九龍區, 可能立刻變成超大 ...

潮流興"愉快學習","追捧傳統名校"同"追捧新派一條龍直資", KCS三者都唔係, 自然唔受歡迎

hkpapa852

lovecupid 發表於 16-6-10 11:29
我想問，大學醫科，會計，環球商管，精算呢啲龍頭科...是不是活動教學.. happy school？多唔多測驗考試？
...

其實我覺得愉快學習可能會帶嚟兩個問題:
1. 學生日後抗壓力低
2. 如果學校生活仲愉快過係屋企, 咁..... 遲D會唔會出現家庭問題呢?

所以我一向都唔會理學校是否Happy School (不過都唔好太Tough), 因為我相信子女在學習上是否愉快, 其實係取決於父母既態度, 而唔係學校