英華 vs. SFA

beagoodman

原帖由 KikiDaddy 於 15-12-07 發表
回覆 beagoodman 的帖子

Around 1/3 of SFA P6 boys can be allocated to a school better than YWC.

Supposing your figure is correct, the failure rate is about 66% if studying in SFA aims at getting admitted to a secondary school better than YW. Frankly speaking, it is no good.

KikiDaddy

回覆 ppmmbb 的帖子

We don't have the DSE results of the "pure blood" YW students at this moment. However, you can still find the Pre S1 scores of the YWC S1 intakes in recent years from the school annual report and see if there is any improving trend of S1 intake quality.

KikiDaddy

回覆 beagoodman 的帖子

I would say 1/3 SFA graduates can be allocated to schools better than YWC, 1/3 to schools with similar DSE results as YWC and the remaining 1/3 to schools inferior to YWC. This % doesn't count the students transferred from SFA to other top through train / feeder schools before P6.
However, this is highly subjective. Prospective P1 parents should visit SFA website to look at the SSPA results and make their own judgment.
I just want to point out that YWPS is a very top primary school but the choice of its graduates will be limited by the through train relationship with YWC. The realistic choices of top YWPS graduates will be just SPCC and DBS while other private school top students can apply for both top DSS schools and government / subsidized schools.

KikiDaddy

回覆 ahpooh712 的帖子

Not just DBS. There are students allocated to other Band 1A schools.
You can take a look at the SFA SSPA results in recent years at its website:

http://www.sfaeps.edu.hk/

mimi222shi

Band 1 A / B / C, 不但成績有分別, 校內學生的讀書風氣也很大分別.

當年, 放棄左啲有龍小學( 之前問左好多朋友), 知道有些1C中學的學生頭幾名也有主科唔及格, 尤其是龍校/聯繫位上的, 成績一般也能上中學.

之前找小學資料, 知道英華老師走唔少, 如果間學校好, 點解老師要走?

直資受資助唔係要跟政府規定咩?想知課程點快?

ckcleung

回覆 mimi222shi 的帖子

如果1C 頭幾名都有主科唔合格,咁排十幾廿幾咪幾科唔合科?排五十名都應該三四科唔合格哦
咁B2C考第一咪起碼兩科唔合格囉

retriever

beagoodman 發表於 15-12-7 18:24
近年英華入U率可能仲高過男拔，什麼是band 1A?

there is not much details about dbs admission rate to local u...

checked the annual report of yw, the % for students attaining 5+ in english was about 27%.. to be honest it looks not very promising for a band one school. however, the results they have been achieving for now are by the boys who had been with yw before their ps turned into dss.

from the stats that sfa had disclosed over 50% of the boys went to elite band one schools (i meant those have long history), if counting other good band one school, the % should be over 70%... it looks very appealing for those parents who target top middle schools.

i would say yw is a play-safe choice, but not an easy school compared with sfa.

from what i ve heard about yw, it is a very competitive school, the boys have to work hard to perform, but they do have fun apart from the heavy school work.

mimi222shi

如果你有一些朋友教書，你又肯問，相信會知道揀學校唔係淨係睇學校名，當然要睇埋小朋友能力同家長期望。

ckcleung

其實,考入YW讀十二年既學生同家長.係TARGET 出狀元又或者50%入三大率,所以入讀呢?

我諗9成幾,已經考量過先會TAKE OFFER吧.

beagoodman

原帖由 mimi222shi 於 15-12-08 發表
本帖最後由 mimi222shi 於 15-12-8 11:32 編輯

Band 1 A / B / C, 不但成績有分別, 校內學生的讀書風氣 ...

同樣道理，SFA咁好，為何有位俾插下學期？

beagoodman

原帖由 balj 於 15-12-08 發表
知道有些1C中學的學生頭幾名也有主科唔及格

呢句應係近年其中一句EK金句。

小曳人

beagoodman 發表於 15-12-8 12:39
同樣道理，SFA咁好，為何有位俾插下學期？

SFA每個課室可容納45人早兩年真係收足45人一班，但開學就已經無減幾個 (d人退學唔通知 or 好遲先叩到門掛)

呢兩年好似都無收足45個，減去每年總有十個八個走，申請插班嘅又未必個個"合格"，所以總有d位
我都識人下學期先插入去，依家讀得幾好咁

melody228

原帖由 beagoodman 於 15-12-08 發表
同樣道理，SFA咁好，為何有位俾插下學期？

會唔會因為SFA唔會call waiting的關係？

用Drop offer而多出來的位收小一插班？

yuenkw

呢 d 無中學的私小唔會因唔夠人而降低收生標凖，個升中業績一跌，第二年唔會有人申請。

mimi222shi

Ryan_baba 發表於 15-12-7 17:58
揀SFA就預左小一開始已經開行Turbo全力衝, 如果谷唔起, 隨時車毀人亡. 但揀YW就可以慢慢睇定黎讀, 有天份又 ...

"如果谷唔起, 隨時車毀人亡" 讀唔好書就形容到咁, 呢啲先係經典金句!

老實講, 讀書盡左力就OK, 唔使咁誇張.

KikiDaddy

回覆 retriever 的帖子

The university admission rate of DSE students is mentioned on page 22 of DBS' school report: -
"More than two third of the students were admitted by local universities in the main round. Mostof them were accepted by HKU or CUHK followed by HKPU, CityU and HKUST. There is apleasing proportion of graduates being admitted to medicine, healthcare and other professionalprograms."

Taking into account some top students opting for the IB class, 67% local university admission rate for DSE students is indeed very good.