英華 vs. SFA

Lindytiger

好多家長總認為自己既仔女係top 20%, 一定可以入到band 1A; 入D band 1b-c 既學校簡直就係浪費時間, 所以百貨應百客, 呢D topic 真係沒完沒了.

ckcleung

回覆 Lindytiger 的帖子

又或者，家長相信，不論任何資質，入到b1a學校，自然會教到個學生識飛

beagoodman

原帖由 www 於 15-12-07 發表
世事難料，可能升中時入唔到英華的級數，亦可能升中時入到比英華理想的Band 1A中學。

有幾成SFA的人可升上比英華更好的學校呢？

beagoodman

原帖由 Lindytiger 於 15-12-07 發表
好多家長總認為自己既仔女係top 20%, 一定可以入到band 1A; 入D band 1b-c 既學校簡直就係浪費時間, 所以百 ...

在EK，都幾多呢d家長。

karen55407

我認識的只有放棄SFA而取YW的朋友

ppmmbb

ckcleung 發表於 15-12-7 16:04
回覆 Lindytiger 的帖子

又或者，家長相信，不論任何資質，入到b1a學校，自然會教到個學生識飛 ...

咁又誇張啲！

不過近朱者赤，近墨則黑，90%時間都對的。
人想進步，就要向上挑戰。B2a想去B1c，B1c想去B1b，B1b想去B1a 好正常喎！

Ryan_baba

揀SFA就預左小一開始已經開行Turbo全力衝, 如果谷唔起, 隨時車毀人亡. 但揀YW就可以慢慢睇定黎讀, 有天份又受谷, 再衝上去.

beagoodman

原帖由 Ryan_baba 於 15-12-07 發表
揀SFA就預左小一開始已經開行Turbo全力衝, 如果谷唔起, 隨時車毀人亡. 但揀YW就可以慢慢睇定黎讀, 有天份又 ...

近年英華入U率可能仲高過男拔，什麼是band 1A?

beagoodman

原帖由 hoivy 於 15-12-07 發表
Band 1A 是入讀中學時既小學生標準， 入U率是讀完中學既中學生結果，過程就是一個迷。 ...

標準？
講標準，我只知band 1, 2,3.

細分a,b,c, 有什麼標準？網上那些表？人云亦云？

momama

讀過SFA, 見過英華d功課，深唔深、谷唔谷，無謂比較。比較客觀嘅，係英華要一體一藝囉，要用唔少時間。

KikiDaddy

Choosing a through train primary school, you should also consider its secondary school as well.

Most of the students are expected to finish the whole 12 years with a through train school. A P6 student of a through train primary school must give up the S1 place of its secondary school in order to participate in the SSPS. I don't think many students will do so as it is just too risky. Therefore, that P6 student can only apply for other DSS schools if he is not happy with its through train secondary school. Choices are then much more limited.

YWC doesn't release much information about its DSE results but you can still get some information about its 33222 % and English Languages credit rate from its school annual report:

http://www.yingwa.edu.hk/uploadf ... _ub0/1415Report.pdf

and make some comparison with other Band 1 schools:

2014 DSE results:

http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum ... 2959&highlight=2014

2015 DSE results:

http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum ... tra=page%3D3&page=1

KikiDaddy

回覆 beagoodman 的帖子

Around 1/3 of SFA P6 boys can be allocated to a school better than YWC.

ahpooh712

原帖由 KikiDaddy 於 15-12-07 發表
回覆 beagoodman 的帖子

Around 1/3 of SFA P6 boys can be allocated to a school better than YWC.

You mean DBS?

ppmmbb

原帖由 KikiDaddy 於 15-12-07 發表
本帖最後由 KikiDaddy 於 15-12-7 21:14 編輯

Choosing a through train primary school, you should al ...

可惜英華小學首屆自己揀的學生才中二，仍未見到小學訓練出來的真正料子！！！

MrBeast

KikiDaddy 發表於 15-12-7 21:25
回覆 beagoodman 的帖子

Around 1/3 of SFA P6 boys can be allocated to a school better than YWC.

Wouldnt this mean 2/3 goto level same as or below ywc?

mcl203

ahpooh712 發表於 15-12-7 21:35
You mean DBS?

我估.....SFA 近來緊係配 SJC 啦