3月9日中提琴初級, 聯署投訴, 是日小提琴2級(青年廣場)請入

marcuscyrus

原帖由 yuengooluk 於 15-03-11 發表
上半場
你呢?

我仔都上半，80分，我地拉完就即走，只留低阿爸聽

Candy925

原帖由 marcuscyrus 於 15-03-11 發表
我仔都上半，80分，我地拉完就即走，只留低阿爸聽

yuengooluk

咁我見到你哋走.......我和另一媽咪都覺得冠軍麻麻地......

yuengooluk

marcuscyrus 發表於 15-3-11 13:24
我多年前去過一場6級piano,評判講comments時都係好惡，會話冇expect6級水準咁低，話好多參賽者balance同ped ...

有評語都好.
這位maureen yuen女士,written comments極少,我們來來去去得一樣要改善.難怪今日一個接一個上台.我們伴奏說之前另一外國人評判,每人六分鐘(連拉),今日咪三分鐘左右囉.

Candy925

原帖由 yuengooluk 於 15-03-11 發表
咁我見到你哋走.......我和另一媽咪都覺得冠軍麻麻地......

我哋仲慘，冠亞季都聽唔到只知輸一分，好似發咗場夢咁，不過我同伴奏都讚亞女今日表現，佢第四年玩，未贏過，所以今日心情都唔錯。

marcuscyrus

原帖由 Candy925 於 15-03-11 發表
下半場。
冠亞季都上半場，冇得聽。
老實講，下半場真係唔掂，伴奏（佢係小交樂團小提琴手）話， ...

爸爸話上半場都多人有失誤，但佢對音樂0認識，信一半好了，我仔可能驚炒，拉得慢過平時，push極唔郁

Candy925

原帖由 yuengooluk 於 15-03-11 發表
有評語都好.
這位maureen yuen女士,written comments極少,我們來來去去得一樣要改善.難怪今日一個接一個上 ...

係呀！今日好似接力賽咁，呢個情況我未見過！

marcuscyrus

原帖由 yuengooluk 於 15-03-11 發表
咁我見到你哋走.......我和另一媽咪都覺得冠軍麻麻地......

我老公貼中冠軍喎，佢話，我仔激死人，唔知咩事全程對住我拉

marcuscyrus

原帖由 yuengooluk 於 15-03-11 發表
有評語都好.
這位maureen yuen女士,written comments極少,我們來來去去得一樣要改善.難怪今日一個接一個上 ...

我仔那張寫滿哂

Candy925

原帖由 marcuscyrus 於 15-03-11 發表
爸爸話上半場都多人有失誤，但佢對音樂0認識，信一半好了，我仔可能驚炒，拉得慢過平時，push極唔郁:naught ...

下半場炒到飛起，有個小朋友拉咗頭兩句已甩，佢企圖入返，但好多16分音符，佢當時揸住隻琴好似數手字咁，大半首歌都係咁，入幾粒音又再甩，睇到「鄧」佢難過！

Candy925

原帖由 marcuscyrus 於 15-03-11 發表
我仔那張寫滿哂

我女都係，話佢唔夠大聲，arm可以多d令聲響d, 其他tempo, articulation, contrast, intonation 都讚好.

marcuscyrus

原帖由 Candy925 於 15-03-11 發表
我女都係，話佢唔夠大聲，arm可以多d令聲響d, 其他tempo, articulation, contrast, intonation 都讚好.



  ...

差不多，我仔右手麻麻

snkldan

Sindy 發表於 15-3-10 20:44
'.今日中提琴好好彩呀... 又係佢, 最高91分... 老師話可能我話完佢, 比分鬆手左...

Sindy 發表於 15-3-10 00:29
今日最少兩個應該有80分以上的, 一個係白色裙個女仔, 我知佢能力, 一定拉得唔錯(伴奏有伴上半場, 都話有個 ...

This is the first time I leave a comment in Baby Kingdom.

Without any doubt, the adjudicator has double standard.  

Both of them are my students - the girl in white dress, and the boy with 91 marks.  Although the boy's techniques is more advanced than the girl, their performances of this particular piece is of the same level I would say. They played in front of me last Sunday in the presence of their parents.  We all agreed that both of them are well prepared.  So I think I would be an appropriate person to say that the adjudicator indeed has double standard.

PS. To be precise, I'm (still) the 91 mark boy's violin teacher and I only give comments to his viola playing sometimes as he has an official viola teacher.  Nevertheless, I do believe that I contributed quite much (if not a lot) in his techniques.  And two more classmates of the girl got 2nd and 3rd respectively in viola junior group (by another adjudicator).  I know their playing standard well enough before I speak.

To be honest, I DON'T really mind whether they win or lose since it is part of a competition (and I've got A LOT more students losing then winning), but I think the little girl, who spent numerous hours practicing Viola, deserves a little "merit" and some encouragement.

titibaby

似乎要多謝Sindy，評判之後幾場先正常返d

Sindy

titibaby 發表於 15-3-11 23:24
似乎要多謝Sindy，評判之後幾場先正常返d

做左件好事我都開心D, 係真的, 5級比賽, 要求八級水準.. 望住咁小既小朋友, 點忍心架... 鬼唔知要音準, 要dynamic, 要基本功咩.. 咩級數做到咩野, 佢可能對住D高級太耐, 唔記得左, 我提下佢先記得返?不過之前都遇到D評判比冠軍係要基本功多過首歌, 見到有人拉得麻麻, 但基本功係度, 就比左佢, 呢D唔奇怪, 最奇怪就係全場最高得79, 我仔都最尾行flat左, 佢都77分, 佢係抵, 就係鄧白裙妹妹同老師個學生唔抵, 佢地拉得幾好, 以五級/初級黎計, 不過無法, 佢以八級黎計, 梗係唔好啦....

Sindy

snkldan 發表於 15-3-11 22:27
This is the first time I leave a comment in Baby Kingdom.

Without any doubt, the adjudicator has d ...

真係好, 呢個topic引到你咁有分量入黎留言...評判既double standard好難去proof, 不過我覺得可以改善既係出年佢地揀既初級歌.. 如果揀返啱程度, 我諗評判唔會覺得全場都唔得... 我同佢講呢首係5級考試歌, 佢好似如夢初醒咁, 佢望住D小朋友, 都有一絲憐憫眼神...

ong84

我真係覺得個協會選曲有問題，其實選曲的人是否識弦樂？鋼琴組果邊冇咁離譜

Sindy

ong84 發表於 15-3-12 00:37
我真係覺得個協會選曲有問題，其實選曲的人是否識弦樂？鋼琴組果邊冇咁離譜
...

[tr][/tr]

音樂委員會 蔣陳紅梅女士 (主席) (個人會員) 李漢光先生 (副主席) (東華三院鄧肇堅小學) 陳家曦先生 (九龍華仁書院) 鄭基恩先生 (拔萃男書院) 蔣頌恩小姐 (拔萃女書院) 鍾梓萍女士 (聖保羅男女中學附屬小學) 黎如冰女士 (個人會員) 吳朝勝先生 (新界婦孺福利會梁省德學校) 黃德倫女士 (個人會員) 余之期先生 (聖士提反書院)

呢堆人選曲架喎, 有無人識佢地? 我就一個都唔識喇

Sindy

snkldan 發表於 15-3-11 22:27
This is the first time I leave a comment in Baby Kingdom.

Without any doubt, the adjudicator has d ...

阿妹妹仔果時係音統老師已經話佢超晒班(我仔舊同學), 所以無上I1, 出去搵老師, 唔想擔誤左佢, 佢又對自己有要求.. 好有天份, 學左兩年, 由咩都唔識開始, 睇住佢神速進步...所以佢真係好唔抵..

ong84

Sindy 發表於 15-3-12 00:46
呢堆人選曲架喎, 有無人識佢地? 我就一個都唔識喇

如果所有組別都係佢地選，好可能要改善下弦樂組，我以為小提琴選曲有問題，原來中提琴仲大件事!其實一般人都係考ABRSM的試，大概上個程度都唔好差太遠(雖然同一級都會有分別）我意思係同ABRSM個程度。