Ying Wah or Paul Boys

2ndsister

回覆 mmhchung 的帖子

唔係喎, 我認同, 我都係因為仔仔讀書而住來香港島區, 由細到大係九龍區, 搬來兩年多, 我發覺香港島區的人質素係平均高過九龍...不喜勿插

ckcleung

自我感覺良好就ok了

radialforearm

除左學術，體毅發展，表現，邊間成績出衆D呢？依家D學生要發掘佢地既長處，不可以淨係讀書了

芝士BB

原帖由 2ndsister 於 14-07-11 發表
回覆 mmhchung 的帖子

唔係喎, 我認同, 我都係因為仔仔讀書而住來香港島區, 由細到大係九龍區, 搬來兩年多 ...

如此類推，原來住在St Paul Boy 華富邨的人比住在英華南昌邨的人素質高

3kidsdaddy

Dear Buddies,
Thanks all for your expert opinion and sharings. I cannot agree more that both YW and Paul Boys are great schools with apparently different ways of teachings. To me, YW is a school of energetic, creative and it is definitely leaping forward under the leadership of Miss Lam. On the other hand, Paul Boys is a school of humble, confident and bear the good name of tradition. It is really a tough job to drop any one of them.

JKR

雖然要係兩間學校中做選擇不是容易的事，始終一讀就12年，但都希望樓主可以盡快做決定，放出其中一個學位俾仲等緊的小朋友。

AnMViE

原帖由 3kidsdaddy 於 14-07-11 發表
Dear Buddies,
Thanks all for your expert opinion and sharings. I cannot agree more that both YW and  ...

We had the same question last year and chose YW. Our considerations may be different from yours, but we think we made the right decision. The boys at YW learn happily and creatively, and are given many deveolpment opportunities. Also, the principal and the teachers are caring and encouraging.
SPB is good too, but I guess the ways of learning is more traditional.

wendysuperbaby

講高貴就一定係SPB. 英華强調平民化， 學費都已反映了。

AnMViE

原帖由 wendysuperbaby 於 14-07-12 發表
講高貴就一定係SPB. 英華强調平民化， 學費都已反映了。

如果比較兩間的價錢， 更令人覺得YW物超所值。

radialforearm

有冇前輩答到，除了學術，其他體毅，音樂，邊間比小朋友多D空間發展，往績又如可呢？

neogeo1111

Of course, 100% 英華！文武雙全！SPB...好名一個！

3kidsdaddy

I've discussed with the parents of YW and Paul Boys.

YW parents love YW usually because the students can PLAY HARD (many extra-curricular activities and need to stay behind school even at night) and WORK HARD (all exams, tests, dictations need to have ranking).

Paul Boys parents love Paul Boys because students are being take good care by teachers on individual basis (fewer students in each form) and more concentrate on core stuffs but less extra-curricular activities.

As a result, YW students will become brighter after years of training but to some extent more elbowing. Paul Boys students will become more humanic and less aggressive.  

Any insider please give us some hints and share your expert opinions. Thx

ASamSam

I think both schools have ranking.  As a matter of fact, my son's YW school report only has marks and grades.  We know the ranking through our own intranet account only.

It is true that many our parents like YW very much.  The reasons seem to be variable.  However, I think one main reason is that you can see your son grow and learn happily in this school.

NKpa

...........

ericby

Gary_family 發表於 14-7-12 14:38
最緊要讀出嚟個小朋友又乖又叻！係咪交學費時＂高貴＂啲根本無所謂，亦唔多覺，再講比如喇沙都唔駛$$，但亦 ...

dont think that comparing YW and LS is appropriate.  YW has a God principal.

甘恩

koala_choco 發表於 14-7-12 08:27
你点知yw des 成績？

在EK高中教育，可找到不少學校DSE成績。

Nbranson

But the principal has no track record at all....  Just talk talk talk... If you ask around people know 英華女校 is top notch.... 英華男校 .... First tier bottom.  People talk about how good the future is..... If it is sooo good why it didn't perform 50 years ago?   There are plenty if great school why need to bet on something to happen in the future???😴😴😴

wingszew

一家藍籌股，一家概念股，看您睇法！特別概念股的靈魂人物如果退下，傳期能否延續是個值得思校的課題！