CKY or YWPS?

MrBeast

fguy 發表於 13-12-11 15:21
How about Logos?  Their first IB result sounds better.  Are those IB candidates all starts from Logo ...

Dont think so. someone (said she was an ex teacher there) said the current principal shifted the school to more traditional style, apparently.

fguy

回覆 MrBeast 的帖子

Or express in this way....
Why Logos can do pretty good in the first IB exam but CKY not?  Just cos CKY's 1st batch graduates are from other school and not started at G1.

四隻貓

fguy 發表於 13-12-11 15:46
回覆 MrBeast 的帖子

Or express in this way....

國際學校果邊有討論過.當時提出幾點:

1. 真道IB 英文科選修的是B 課程, 而CKY IB 英文科是比較難的A課程.
我估情況類似以前我地HKCEE 時代英文分A同B 課程.

2. 真道部分學生可以選修IB, 部份學生是選修DSE ; 而CKY是全部學生也要選修IB.

3. 好似仲有提及真道IB學生是有三年去學習和準備IBDP , 而CKY是只有兩年.

有錯請指正.

kwansara

四隻貓 發表於 13-12-11 16:54
國際學校果邊有討論過.當時提出幾點:

1. 真道IB 英文科選修的是B 課程, 而CKY IB 英文科是比較難的A課程.

好似仲有提及真道IB學生是有三年去學習和準備IBDP , 而CKY是只有兩年.==> 為何CKY 只有兩年 ?

四隻貓

呢度有前輩討論緊CKY IB 成績

http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum ... age%3D1&page=21

spiderlily

phoebe_ming5 發表於 13-12-11 11:01
please advise where can I find the IB results?  31.2 seems not very attractive

There is another thread "2013 IB results under the International School section.

	Updated as of Dec 10, 2013. 1:21 PM
School	No. of Students	Average Score	% 40+	% Pass	% Bilingual Dip	IB Only
SPCC	27	40.67	78%			N
DBS	45	39.3	54%	100%		N
LPCUWC (HK students)		39.23
Logos	15	38.3	40%	100%	100%	N
CIS	108	38	43%	97%	12%	Y
LPCUWC	128	37.53	38%	97%		Y
SIS	23	37	35%			Y
FIS	19	36.05	32%	100%		Y
CDNIS		35.5				Y
CSS	65	35.3	22%	97%	56%	N
Shatin C	146	35.3	17%	97%	15%	Y
West IS	127	35.2	18%	99%	3%	Y
YCIS	94	35	16%			Y
ESF	831	34.6	17%	98%		Y
ISF	33	34.5	12%	97%	67%	Y
KGV	194	34.2	17%	97%	6%	Y
VSA	60	34.1	15%	98%		Y
South IS	141	34.0	14%	98%	9%	Y
Carmel	4	33.25		100%		Y
RC	119	33.2	11%	98%	43%	Y
CKY	14	31.2		93%	93%	Y
Global		29.81

For comparison purposes, here is the info from 2012 thanks to ChiChiPaPa
http://www.edu-kingdom.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=35057&do=blog&id=1549


Here is a more detailed version of 2012 thanks to ANChan with breakdown by range of grades
http://www.edu-kingdom.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=107125&do=blog&id=1552

wendysuperbaby

I will choose YW as I believe graduates from YW would still have choice for DSE or IB or studying aboard

ANChan59

回覆 四隻貓 的帖子

第三點只是籍口，他們一向標榜 lB Approach, 即是預備了12年，何來2年。唔考 lGCSE 咪有時間囉，唔見 ESF 及 lS 投訴。
其他學校因為直資要行雙軌，三年高中，唔通一年NSS再加兩年IB，緊係到高中要分流啦，冇得賴。

重有第四點，又話其他學校雙重篩選。

第五點，ESF 都分流 BTEC 及 lB，他們只可以選 lB，事實上可以行雙軌，GCE 加 lB，或者 DSE 加 lB。

hadwinboy

我只可以說出 YW 的情況。學校會有很多諗頭去激勵及推動男孩子學習，又有很多課內外活動，可以說是 happy learning，起碼我個仔到現在也是 happy 的。學校對紀律有要求，上堂要専心、先舉手後說話等等，同一般傳統學校一樣。我仔遇著個班主任超有愛心，是他的福氣，但聽聞有些老師比較惡。功課平均5-6樣一日(連改正)，若不要求寫字要甲等，我仔平均30分鐘內做完。但小二、三開始會多。感覺上學校給小一生很長的適應期，我很滿意。學術方面，YW 應該數學最強。

Jane1983

Cky的IB成績要睇多兩三年，若無明顯改善，家長會以脚投票。始終去到底，講到幾grand都好，都系睇deliverables。不過，第一届差過真道，真系幾愕然。

ANChan59

原帖由 Jane1983 於 13-12-29 發表
Cky的IB成績要睇多兩三年，若無明顯改善，家長會以脚投票。始終去到底，講到幾grand都好，都系睇deliverabl ...

我都有些跌眼鏡。

phoebe_ming5

Jane1983 發表於 13-12-29 11:17
Cky的IB成績要睇多兩三年，若無明顯改善，家長會以脚投票。始終去到底，講到幾grand都好，都系睇deliverabl ...

very disappointed on the result

bbysh

language 方面呢？cky 似乎pth /eng 比較流利, 我有无想錯？

lawsonmoon

spiderlily 發表於 13-12-11 18:36
There is another thread "2013 IB results under the International School section.

分析一D學校公怖既數字要好小心,因為越來越似上市公司既年報。将佢地擺埋一齊更加危險,因並不是蘋果比蘋果。一D百幾二百人既學校,少過三十人考,精英教育vs全民教育！？再睇睇佢地考A or B課程？印象中有好幾個滿分既來自英基,如果英基和DBS只準頭27人考IB,平均分會比SPCC低！？

spiderlily

lawsonmoon 發表於 14-1-15 15:31
分析一D學校公怖既數字要好小心,因為越來越似上市公司既年報。将佢地擺埋一齊更加危險,因並不是蘋果比蘋果 ...

My friend's son studyies in SPCC.  They choose whether to go the DSE or IB route.  

For DBS, they have both IB and DSE route too.

ESF does not provide the option and hence all go IB.  Not 精英教育vs全民教育.

For those taking IB in local elite schools, they usually not eye on Us in HK.  

73662710

The result of logos was really impressive, it took only 11 years for their intakes to finish primary and secondary school education.

All students from esf took igcse before taking up IB, and students from lpc also have only 2 years to prepare for their IB examination,it is very unreasonable for the proponents of cky to ascribe the poor result of cky to the igcse exam and the preparation time of merely 2 years.
What's more, someone stated in this thread that the first batch of IB graduates were not promoted from their own grade 10 but were leftover of other schools, which was obviously INCORRECT and irresponsible.

bubuG

原帖由 73662710 於 14-01-15 發表
本帖最後由 73662710 於 14-1-15 18:50 編輯

The result of logos was really impressive, it took only ...

Absolutely agree with u

PotterLai

回覆 bbysh 的帖子

鄰居的朋友開補習社，收很多蔡繼有的學生，他說蔡的學生有幾個特點：

一、程度比一般學校低，和其他名校比差距更遠；

二、英語一般，因為不懂文法，口音也不地道；

三、大部份人都要校外補習，因為學校教得太淺，不足以應付 IB。

還有，那些補習社，請很多蔡繼有的前老師

behappydad

原帖由 PotterLai 於 14-01-16 發表
回覆 bbysh 的帖子

鄰居的朋友開補習社，收很多蔡繼有的學生，他說蔡的學生有幾個特點：

yes, most of students have tuitorials after school.