2010 - 2013 自行分配申請競爭形勢

nicksonma

fefemom

Thank you Ian, as always.


想再問問：自行階段註冊以後，教育局會否公佈每間學校實際統一派位有多少學額，以供家長參考？

iantsang

原帖由 fefemom 於 13-09-26 發表
Thank you Ian, as always.

As always 你都不用客氣！

教育局唔會有「實際」統一派位名額，到一月填表前只會有「暫定」統一派位名額，係根據自行派咗幾多，同間學校一貫選擇留作留班位名額計出來的。

wai_wai113

Thanks for your sharing

chung210

ggsbb

謝謝！

subb

你的表列中是否扣了每班1個位的留級位???? 留級位是每間學校一定會扣除?????

iantsang

subb 發表於 13-9-26 14:14
你的表列中是否扣了每班1個位的留級位???? 留級位是每間學校一定會扣除?????  ...

你的表列中是否扣了每班1個位的留級位???? ==> Yes


留級位是每間學校一定會扣除?????==>  Not necessarily

subb

咁講統一實際是沒有50%, 只是百份之46%左右 (因要預留留班位) ????

iantsang

原帖由 subb 於 13-09-26 發表
咁講統一實際是沒有50%, 只是百份之46%左右 (因要預留留班位) ????

你留心睇教育局講自行係寫50%，但統一派位係寫約50%！

如只計同校網乙部，減多10%去甲部無校網限制，只得41%！

munce

Hello Ian,
Wanna to seek your opinion. I noted LSPS has got a total of 180 seats, which means 54 seats are reserved for those who have elder brothers currently studying there. There are 6 classes in P1, which means 9 out of 30 per class have elder brothers? Does that sound logical ? As it is a boys' school, any chance that elder brothers per class is less than 9?

Thanks.

wendywcl

想問問你意見, 我有兩個囝囝, 但家住中西區, 如果自行揀St. Joseph 或華仁, 只有15 分, 勝算有幾大呢?這兩間學校又係唔係一定要１－１－１先可以叩門呢？但朋友同我講其實中西區讀小學有利啲，因為全港最多Band 1中學應該喺中西區，但我真係好心儀灣仔果兩間男校，可否比少少意見？
中西區有無邊間小學推介？　　

iantsang

wendywcl 發表於 13-9-26 17:48
想問問你意見, 我有兩個囝囝, 但家住中西區, 如果自行揀St. Joseph 或華仁, 只有15 分, 勝算有幾大呢?這兩 ...

自行揀St. Joseph 或華仁, 只有15 分, 勝算有幾大呢?  ==> 勝算 = 0

這兩間學校又係唔係一定要１－１－１先可以叩門呢？ ==> 這兩間學校叩門同１－１－１無關係，因無公開收叩門。

iantsang

munce 發表於 13-9-26 17:18
Hello Ian,
Wanna to seek your opinion. I noted LSPS has got a total of 180 seats, which means 54 sea ...

I think you have mixed up the concept of QUOTA and ACTUAL PLACEMENT.  The 30% quota are reserved for younger siblings only and if there are less than that, then these reserved seats will be transfer to the allocation under points system.

sandra28

sandra28

原帖由 iantsang 於 13-09-26 發表
As always 你都不用客氣！

教育局唔會有「實際」統一派位名額，到一月填表前只會有「暫定」統一派 ...

Thanks!

munce

回復 iantsang 的帖子

I know those 54 seats (30%) are reserved for siblings and 36 seats (20%) are for "points" system.
If no. of siblings is less than 54, then those seats will be allocated to "points" system.
I just wanna to have a rough estimation as to how many seats will be occupied by siblings.
If all 54 seats are occupied, and there are 6 classes, that would imply 9 siblings per class. Does that sound too much?
If only 7 per class, then that would be 7 x 6 = 42 seats, so 54 - 42 = 12 seats will be allocated to "points" system, And "points" system will have 36 + 12 = 48 seats.

I just wanna to see my chance under "points" system.

iantsang

原帖由 munce 於 13-09-26 發表
回復 iantsang 的帖子

I know those 54 seats (30%) are reserved for siblings and 36 seats (20%) are f ...

Well, I am quite sure it must be less than 9 per class.  However, with total over 900 students in p.2 to p.6, it's not that difficult to have many siblings a year.  So, it won't be too far.

WWBaby

Ian, 想問一問自行20分揀St Jo係咪機會好微？
爸爸是old boy, 有機會叩門成功嗎？
如果net 12 甲乙都揀St Jo, 機會都好細嗎？

LittlePanda101

Thx