請問有冇人知DBS今年DSE成績

friendlyguy

webeheld 發表於 13-7-20 20:15
印象中讀IB的學生要有主動的探索及分析能力，然後能清楚表達自己的論點 ---> Honestly, IB subjects are st ...

''印象中讀IB的學生要有主動的探索及分析能力，然後能清楚表達自己的論點'' is about how the student acquire the knowledge.

''marking criteria and grade boundaries etc'' is about how to differentiate which student has better understanding of a certain topics. Saddly that all exams , no mater it is IB, SAT, AP, GCE or DSE, have to grade the candidates.

For all the curriculums, I think we need to look further into how the knowlege is deliver apart from how the students are graded.

For IB, which aim is to produce life time learner, I have the confidence that those success in the culculum will not 大個咗，阿媽唔係身邊怎辦.

NKpa

DSE未成熟,睇多幾年先啦.

needaplan

讀IB始終是得很少學位，SPCC加男拔只得70人有得讀，但DSE相信兩間學校有超過400人讀。男拔除了中文失手外，其它科目DSE又唔知考成點？

KikiDaddy

I'm just a passer-by. It seems that DBS put a lot more resources, both hardware and software, in IB than DSE. Are most of the top students go for IB? Do the remaining DSE students feel that they are just the second class citizens in the school?

Most prestigious schools can have excellent results in public examinations not just because they got good teachers. Quality of students, morale and positive peer group pressure are essential to success.

As DBS is a DSS, it's quality of student intake should be among the best in Hong Kong. If its DSE results are not good enough, the school management should revisit whether their strategy of offering both IB and DSE at the same time is a right one.

ANChan59

needaplan 發表於 13-7-21 08:15
讀IB始終是得很少學位，SPCC加男拔只得70人有得讀，但DSE相信兩間學校有超過400人讀。男拔除了中文失手外， ...

Good question!
Too focus on Chinese.

ANChan59

NKpa 發表於 13-7-21 02:41
DSE未成熟,睇多幾年先啦.

同意，2012 初中開始修改中文課程，三四年後會看到結果。

ANChan59

回復 KikiDaddy 的帖子

Are most of the top students go for IB?
(Previous years ~15 % students from outside, the balance are DBS boys, their academic performance are from top to 150, each form has around 240 students.)


Do the remaining DSE students feel that they are just the second class citizens in the school?
(Difficult to say. Just like the IB library, students, parents and outsiders may not know the real case, they may consider its biased. For the first two batches, some top boys focus on local professional programs, they prefer NSS, as more seats through JUPAS. Like last year double cohorts, much more medic students from NSS then IB. The real issue is the under-achiever and not the mid to top NSS students in DBS.)

As DBS is a DSS, it's quality of student intake should be among the best in Hong Kong. If its DSE results are not good enough, the school management should revisit whether their strategy of offering both IB and DSE at the same time is a right one.

(Agree, evaluation is needed, should take a few more years to observe the improvement in curriculum and team spirit and sense of belongings, then public exam results. The new principal does a few good things, like to reduce the elites to 較腳, attend classes is equal important as ECA and school teams...... Give the principal some time to restructure the school.)

nintendo

原帖由 NKpa 於 13-07-21 發表
DSE未成熟,睇多幾年先啦.

呢個係部份名校生轉戰IB原因之一。
部份家長子女還細，可以講得口響。
IB唔一定好，但起碼老師有經驗，亦有更多past paper參考，知道題目形式。
就算係IB,舊年語文科修改課程，都有學生會驚一驚。
新Iphone出，都有人選擇睇定D先買啦。
可能IB學校學費貴，形成分化，令IB學生（尤其是本地名校）被無理批評。

mirage

IB result 大攞大鼓宣告，DSE提都唔提，取態不一，讀DSE而又取得好成績的同學們不知會怎想？

ANChan59

mirage 發表於 13-7-21 11:55
IB result 大攞大鼓宣告，DSE提都唔提，取態不一，讀DSE而又取得好成績的同學們不知會怎想？ ...

對，這方面做得不好。
最好兩面都接受或不接受傳媒採訪。無謂產生誤會！

needaplan

原帖由 ANChan59 於 13-07-21 發表
對，這方面做得不好。
最好兩面都接受或不接受傳媒採訪。無謂產生誤會！
...

我覺得應好似女拔, SPCC公佈DSE成績，大家都是聖公會的學校。

ANChan59

needaplan 發表於 13-7-21 12:49
我覺得應好似女拔, SPCC公佈DSE成績，大家都是聖公會的學校。

提高透明度是好事。
我不太肯定，但記憶所及HKCEE及AL都冇公開，在家長會，年報及畢業禮有提及，只是有狀元，記者會作專訪。

nintendo

ANChan59 發表於 13-7-21 12:31
對，這方面做得不好。
最好兩面都接受或不接受傳媒採訪。無謂產生誤會

其實報章訪問就最無謂，亦係宣傳的舊手法。而家網上資訊發達，在學校網頁發佈消息，自然就有大把人轉載。到時唔怕冇人知你叻。spcc 今年好醒，慢慢黎睇定 d 先，冇急不及待上網話學生點叻點叻；而事實人地亦真係成績好過 dbs。

ANChan59

nintendo 發表於 13-7-21 13:00
其實報章訪問就最無謂，亦係宣傳的舊手法。而家網上資訊發達，在學校網頁發佈消息，自然就有大把人轉載。 ...

提高透明度！

nintendo

ANChan59 發表於 13-7-21 13:04
提高透明度！

post 上學校網頁一樣透明。

ANChan59

回復 nintendo 的帖子

希望盡快公報！

KITTY.WONG

NKpa 發表於 13-7-21 02:41
DSE未成熟,睇多幾年先啦.

作為一間老牌名校，還要收取數千元學費，很難講得通因為新考試制度或部份學生轉讀IB引致這兩年成績大幅滑落，只可說以往太谷精英那一、兩班，會考過後升上預科都是這一班精英，其他學生都被西走出來，故以前高考成績那麼好。
現在那麼多地區名校趕上來甚至超越，雖然這些學校都有可能分精英班，但証明其資源分配較平均。
所以在新考試制度下更可看到學校是否用人心栽培每一位學生，亦可給家長知道選校不是為名校與否，入大學都是睇成績的。

nintendo

ANChan59 發表於 13-7-21 13:12
回復 nintendo 的帖子

希望盡快公報！

其實，公報都係得個知字。舊年名校整體 dse  成績都唔算好，比以往有大量 hkcee  狀元時的光輝歲月，已經不同。現在的 dse，應該較貼近 hkal  的生態：有學生可能老早選擇唔讀 dse，例如出國讀名牌高中再入外國名大，或轉外國高中課程 (以往都好多名校生轉去國際學校讀 ib )。以往 hkal  都唔係主流名校係大嬴家，但仍然大把人想讀名校，名校的 status ，唔會比如恆商等預科學校取代。而家其實只係好多非名校的學生和家長，好似有點想 "睇下你點衰" 的心態，等 dbs 公佈成績，然後入位承機踩下。

needaplan

原帖由 ANChan59 於 13-07-21 發表
回復 nintendo 的帖子

希望盡快公報！

對

ANChan59

回復 nintendo 的帖子

大家心照！