蔡繼有，ISF 你會點簡？

shadeslayer

原帖由 annie40 於 13-07-15 發表
牌頭或血統? 出世Day One 就已经无啦! 信唔信重要,是,有就有, 没有就是没有, 不要明明没有又扮到以为有就得 ...

對，暴發戶老粗，亂把名牌住身上推，或喝紅酒騎馬，也不會變成藍血。

shadeslayer

原帖由 HKTHK 於 13-07-15 發表
回復 shadeslayer 的帖子

If anyone wants blueblood, ISF would not be the right choice.  It is filled ...

HKTHK,

Right, you are more sensible.

21Ckid

Even CIS and HKIS are predominantly filled with professionals. Blue blood is born but good pedigree can be groomed. It can start at primary school, secondary, univ, or in your career. The earlier the better chance. That's a fact of life. You could argue against it, but this wouldn't change reality.

Smart money buys branded products to make even greater gains, such as school debentures, art work , 1970s ferraris, while stupid money buys consumables that account for a disproportionate share of their income. Who are slaves?

I am not ISF parent nor can I afford its debenture, but funny enough, these 3 letters always instigate lots of hatred and resentment in BK.

luckyveronique

ISF成績都唔算突出個D lor，唔通名牌在收費貴？就算$唔係問題，我都會揀平D，但成績卻勝出一DD既esf

HKTHK

回復 luckyveronique 的帖子

If a parent is comparing ISF and CKY, they are going for a certain type of school.  ESF would not be their choice.

fanfanbb

21Ckid 發表於 13-7-15 20:01
Even CIS and HKIS are predominantly filled with professionals. Blue blood is born but good pedigree  ...

Yes, this is today's HK albeit pple might have diff views. I totally agree with your view though my hubby said it was wrong. Other than academic results, other factors such as networking, social stratifications, family background, etc. also count.
It's like branding management and pricing strategy when u r doing a business. May be not worth for it but pple still go for it.

gigi812

ISF學生只是比較有錢，學校成績，暫未有Ferri質素。只是暴發戶文化，貴野就=好野，有錢人的名牌，不管質素如何

HKTHK

回復 fanfanbb 的帖子

I don't think there is a right answer but just different belief systems.  Some parents believe affluence and good family backgrounds are a negative in a school community and some don't.  Personally, I believe affluence and wealth are negative factors but education level of parents is a positive factor.  Unfortunately, those factors are correlated.  

HKTHK

回復 gigi812 的帖子

Since when is 有錢 = 暴發戶文化?

Littleho

其實這個post 発言的人有多少是CKY或ISF 家長 。小兒有幾個同學轉往ISF，我認識ISF的家長都不是暴發戶

fanfanbb

回復 gigi812 的帖子

暴發戶？你點知？

kafool

Thanks Littleho, for your comment. You speak my mind!

fanfanbb

回復 gigi812 的帖子

點解ISF會係暴發戶文化？

annie40

回復 Littleho 的帖子

世情是我们对不怎么熟悉的事, 往往比较偏爱接受'作大' 或是抹黑'之谣传.反而不会接受幸福得来平平实实的. 因此有点知名度的学校, 有点漂亮的人, 有点钱的爸妈, 有点能力的孩子, 每天总吃上不少死猫,

112200

其實個題目根本無野可討論。Cky和任何國際學校都不能相提並論。上課講英文和pth並不就是國際學校。在國際學校無論小息，放學後，在洗手間不會有學生講廣東話。不會強制學生一定要學一種樂器，不會有什麼英語日因為英語係complusory人人都很舒服樂意地用英文。cky其實只係一間貴的英文local school,和st stephen 一樣。比較唔到。

112200

我贊同你。可負擔讀國際學校就有罪？ 等於有錢就有教育？ 大家知不知is比local school 考核更困難。以我所知好多間都要做卷中英數，囗試，智力問題，共二至三小時。本地小一又點考呢？在深灣有間is四千人得一百個位。四千人都負得起學費先去報。香港神級個幾間dss考人數也不是間間有四千。我有朋友考到cky 和st stephen, 個個月連雜費什麼音樂費都差不多成萬銀落樓，學校可以提供的英語pth環境都只限於課室內，這又不是”暴發“嗎？公平點。

kafool

原帖由 Annie123 於 13-07-16 發表
有些家長會不自覺地對其他學校有敵意甚至恨意
然後就將一些未能証實的謠言加以無限放大，再扣上帽子

Yes Annie40! I feel the same too!

shadeslayer

第一個在這裏用「暴發戶」三個字的是我，但我的原意不是指 ISF。我是解釋比網友我認為何謂名牌奴隸，以暴發戶的行為作例子，絕無指 ISF 家長是暴發戶。我看不過眼的，是一些只問價錢夠不夠貴，人龍夠不夠長的名牌盲信的心態，和 ISF 或其家長無關。

penguin_chick

回復 112200 的帖子

CKY一開始就定位為bilingual學校，不會，也不能收外藉學生(一方面是政府規定，另一方面是中文程度問題)，除三兩混血兒外，其他都不是Eng native speakers.所以學校要求學生逢星期一三五 在學校內都講英文，二四則講普通話，上課時則依學科語言。