用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 小一選校 英華 vs St joseph (Wanchai) 小學
樓主: mamath
go

英華 vs St joseph (Wanchai) 小學

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3533
發表於 13-3-18 15:04 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 loveDD 於 13-3-18 15:05 編輯

兩間照報,如果你用20分去報ST JO自行,根本英華都未IN完已經有結果。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3628
發表於 14-3-10 22:47 |顯示全部帖子
mamath 發表於 13-3-15 17:02
Not yet ar, but we plan to have the 2nd baby :)

I am
interested in YW because of the principal and seems less drilling in academic.  But my hubby is St Joseph old boy and we got 20 marks already.  Not sure the chance of lucky draw for the latter though.   However, heard that St Joseph has too many homeworks.  Is it true? ...
灣仔聖若瑟 for sure

不過 20 分抽聖若瑟真係窄窄地

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3667
發表於 14-3-10 23:19 |顯示全部帖子

引用:Quote:mamath+發表於+13-3-15+17:02+Not+ye

原帖由 lugano 於 14-03-10 發表
灣仔聖若瑟 for sure

不過 20 分抽聖若瑟真係窄窄地
厳未夠多未夠煩,連舊post 都要找出來令題材更豐富,又多一間



Rank: 3Rank: 3


475
發表於 14-3-11 12:08 |顯示全部帖子
St Jo 高小功課量?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2886
發表於 14-3-11 12:26 |顯示全部帖子

回覆:mamath 的帖子

住九龍就英華,hk 同有細佬就 st joe la!




312
發表於 14-3-11 14:49 |顯示全部帖子

引用:Quote:原帖由+lugano+於+14-03-10+發表灣仔

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 3Rank: 3


448
發表於 14-3-12 11:03 |顯示全部帖子

YW


4531
發表於 14-3-12 11:53 |顯示全部帖子
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 3Rank: 3


448
發表於 14-3-12 11:55 |顯示全部帖子

In my opinion, St Joe is too tough. Lots of homework but no fun !
YW - work hard; play hard !

點評

SCKnight  如果St Joe 都算多,咁高X教、聖X瑟英文叫乜?  發表於 14-3-13 00:13


4531
發表於 14-3-12 12:02 |顯示全部帖子
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11


30359
發表於 14-3-12 15:04 |顯示全部帖子
mamath 發表於 13-3-15 18:42
thanks for sharing!  Oh maybe the comment on St Joseph primary i got was not that accruate.  Could y ...
my coworker said if he could choose again, he would not chose st. jo again... his son is studying in st. jo sec, academic is very good, but require a lot of assistance from parents...
it is becuz the workload is much exceeding the abilities of the young boys... hence, all boys need their parents to step in heavily.... one of our neighbor's boy is studying in sjps.... very demanding... and some of the arrangement doesn't really make sense at all, like a list of 40+ to fill the books you have read together with your boy. my neighbor just honestly filled in a few, then got a reply from the teacher with remarks saying "incomplete"... my neighbor purposefully filled in all entries, and the teacher made no complaint.... same for the museum visits required by the school.... what i was told is that they just didn't care how you complete the tasks... if other kids could do, why you didn't? that's why parents heavy involvement is quite crucial....  my coworker also mentioned that recalling the days when his kid had exams or tests, they could not fall asleep.

don't get me wrong, both my coworker and neighbor are quite proud of the school... just depends what kind of school life you want your boy and your good self to live.... heavy parents step in may have side effect, like your boy might have been used to get assistance from others hence making your boy much less pro-active... to secure a place in sjc, your boy has to be band one, that is around first 50% of the kids.

yw is a much safer choice...

Rank: 6Rank: 6


8186
發表於 14-3-12 17:38 |顯示全部帖子
回覆 retriever 的帖子

"a list of 40+ to fill the books "

The 40+ books have to be completed in what period?

點評

retriever  咁樣講, 又係回"簡單比較"LOGIC.... 瑪記一年睇100+ make sense? 當然有勁人做到, 但我想更多是填哂當交差...  發表於 14-3-13 11:44
SCKnight  嗰個係Dear圖書閱讀計劃,一年分三階段,每個階段睇十本中文同十本英文書。都唔算多!瑪利X一年睇過百本都大不乏人。學校都冇要求本本書都要好厚  發表於 14-3-13 00:19

Rank: 1


28
發表於 14-3-12 20:27 |顯示全部帖子
利申我仔讀緊灣仔聖若瑟。如果英華對聖若瑟,應該揀英華。

現實條件,一條龍一定最保險。因為聖若瑟只係直屬,始終要面對升中壓力。不過因為小學已經由八班減到五班,升中壓力可以減d。至於樓上有人講40+閱讀課外書計劃。會唔會係誤會?

學校鼓勵閱讀,但每一次計劃係讀中英文書各十本,一年有三次,每次有成兩三個月時間做,計一計正常過正常。如果根本唔鐘意閱讀,就一本都嫌多,一定係苦事。長遠計,唔鐘意閱讀,就算讀邊間學校都唔係好事。我個仔只係按平曰閲讀習慣,然後寫低資料就攪掂。

至於參加音樂會和有關藝術的活動,每年都要做報告,但亦好簡單,去完寫低少少資料就完成,而且都比充分時間先交。

英華升中一定最穩陣,學費又平。但課程唔淺,而且科科也再排名次。有d家長話可以知己知彼。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1735
發表於 14-3-12 20:52 |顯示全部帖子

回覆:英華 vs St joseph (Wanchai) 小學

St joe邊有坊間講得咁恐怖?佢地有好多課外活動比你簡去參加,並唔係死讀書型,依家升中壓力減低左,又有名氣又唔洗$,如果有幸入到唔洗諗。申利:小兒已升上SJC



點評

SCKnight  其實St Joe功課真係唔算多,假期比較上亦唔算少。冇拔尖班,亦冇假期補課。係學生同家長都操得勁就真。  發表於 14-3-13 00:24

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2662
發表於 14-3-12 22:00 |顯示全部帖子
回覆 KBP 的帖子

請問一年三次閱讀計劃, 每次中英文各十本, 是否一年要看60本?

Rank: 1


28
發表於 14-3-12 23:34 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 KBP 於 14-3-12 23:39 編輯
kokobo 發表於 14-3-12 22:00
回覆 KBP 的帖子

請問一年三次閱讀計劃, 每次中英文各十本, 是否一年要看60本?  ...

最少60本。印象中如果小一同二。學校好似仲有額外派書比學生睇,但不用做任何報告。亦有好書推介要做,鼓勵學生睇書後寫 d comments ,㸃解想推介本書。另外每逄長假期,學校會派中英文書各一本,有張簡單工作紙要交。所以一年,學校要求睇書超過60本。對唔鐘意閱讀的學生,可以講係推動力,亦可以話係壓力。但一向有閲讀習慣就根本好好。

Rank: 6Rank: 6


5974
發表於 14-3-13 00:24 |顯示全部帖子
kokobo 發表於 14-3-12 22:00
回覆 KBP 的帖子

請問一年三次閱讀計劃, 每次中英文各十本, 是否一年要看60本?  ...
Yes

Rank: 4


886
發表於 14-3-13 11:17 |顯示全部帖子
又吹YW 同個校長? SJ LS 系同YW 完全唔同班... 都係個句真正名校唔駛係baby kingdom 曰日吹.... 幾何講 DBS DGS 呀?
SJ LS 年年各十幾個尖子十幾個入medi,年年出狀元。YW 出倒嗎?高下立見. 而且old boys 係社會上地位成就都差好逺....SJ LS old boys support 好勁個MENTORSHIP program 年年比機會中學生入banks clinics legal firm 實集對其入u 找internship 極有幫助,因為此program 極多一入u就搵到MS GS....internship. 依d 就係江湖地位。

Rank: 4


886
發表於 14-3-13 11:24 |顯示全部帖子
Nbranson 發表於 14-3-13 11:17
又吹YW 同個校長? SJ LS 系同YW 完全唔同班... 都係個句真正名校唔駛係baby kingdom 曰日吹.... 幾何講 DBS ...
依d先至叫做真正贏在起跑線....

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4787
發表於 14-3-13 11:27 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 ckcleung 於 14-3-13 11:38 編輯
Nbranson 發表於 14-3-13 11:24
依d先至叫做真正贏在起跑線....

陰功囉,一間得十年既英華小學就搞到你精神咁緊張