Dbspd 和英華如何選擇？

ANChan59

fion_yinyin 發表於 12-11-10 19:15
報得既都係鐘意嫁啦，唔通報d唔鐘意既學校咩

除非同阿仔有仇....

virgokaren

y3y 發表於 12-11-11 01:04
回復 hadwinboy 的帖子

你估家長會唔會比個仔咁自由？

這是其中一個原因。另，
DBS 好多舊生的下一代。
好多家長係專業人士。有財力，能力培養他們的寶貝。

如果吾係的話，佢地揀d學生真係聰明，醒目，有特別才華果種。

我覺得冇家底而入到DBS的真係醒目仔來的，都大有人在架。

Mayandrew

Haha. I know many of their alumni are professionals and rich! My lawyer and doctor are from Ying Wa. So, I don't dare to say they are not :) btw, today is DBS garden fete and Ying Wa 194th anniversary. Feel free to visit. 各自精彩啦

Mayandrew

原帖由 hadwinboy 於 12-11-11 發表
咁我又好奇一問, 既然 DBS 這麼自由, 但公開考試成績又這麼厲害, 原因何在? 是不是因為學生多是精英, 讀書 ...

Same kind of teaching staff (even at SPCC).  Brand and facilities make good schools becomes super good schools.  See newspaper today. While DBS says don't really want to compare with famous international schools but sounds the new principal thinks this way. One of the key conditions is land, fund raising abilities. For SPCCPS, think if no huge donation and only a tiny campus, would parents so keen to send their kids there?

steven819

回復 Mayandrew 的帖子

For all these schools , they all have lots of donations. Land is a problem in the sense that if the school is willing to move to more remote places. I think parents send their kids to SPCC because of its school traditions and the students performance both academically and morally. Donations and schools facilities is minor issue.

Mayandrew

Good school management leadership, quality teaching staff will help to build good culture and traditions. Chicken and egg issue. Without good facilities (or simply good resources) some schools' sports and music performance won't stay at top. Take the latest swimming competition as example Fuijian (not sure the exact name) ranked fifth right after Ying Wa and well ahead Wah Yan etc.  It actively recruited good swimmers while training their in-house students at their own swimming pool and got good results in recent years. No need to mention DGS. Academic wise, true that all those traditional famous schools are good but when most parents perceive there is one best of the best it's students academic results will particularly be strong. Imagine some top students of Wah Yan, QE, Kings, Ying Wa, DBS, La Salle and SPCC switch to Fuijian school (or any 重點中學endorsed by the central government), it will definitely become a super school. (hope this is just a hypothetical example and joke :) in short, both traditions and resources are important.   See what happen if SPCC exchanges its school campus with Kau Yan? A tiny school can become a good school with good leadership, curriculum and teaching staff but won't be good enough to become a super school.    Having said that, does elite schooling is what most parents are after?  To address some parents thought above, I know some alumni of Ying Wa and DBS had not sent their kids to their mother school but other "good" schools they think more suitable for their kids.

ASamSam

原帖由 Mayandrew 於 12-11-11 發表
Good school management leadership, quality teaching staff will help to build good culture and tradit ...

Agree both are important though I think there are many factors leading to a school's success.

For academic performance, compared with SPCC, both YWC and DBS seem to have room for further improvement.

hadwinboy

原帖由 virgokaren 於 12-11-11 發表
這是其中一個原因。另，
DBS 好多舊生的下一代。
好多家長係專業人士。有財力，能力培養他們的寶貝。

今日去了 DBS fete, 有幸見到了如此多的 DBS 中學生. 不是賣花讚花香(我未有此榮幸去賣), 不過真的是有點不同.... 我也不是踩 YW 生(我未想死住), 只是我未有機會大批的見到.

lawsonmoon

ASamSam 發表於 12-11-11 22:30
Agree both are important though I think there are many factors leading to a school's success.

For a ...

蘋果日報今日話spcc文憑試通識,中文成績差。校長話知道,但佢地强項係英文,八成人考獲5级或以上(等於舊制C級或以上,唔係考獲A以上喎)。咁叫做强架嗱？冇room for further improvement架嗱？

ANChan59

hadwinboy 發表於 12-11-11 23:20
今日去了 DBS fete, 有幸見到了如此多的 DBS 中學生. 不是賣花讚花香(我未有此榮幸去賣), 不過真的是有點不 ...

What's the difference?

nkpa

有的家長覺得英華仔同拔萃仔在成績同課外活動上無得比, 佢地唔會有選擇的煩惱. 但有的家長唔係咁睇, 佢地認為英華轉了直資後, 學生過關斬將千挑百選, 質素同背景都有返咁上下, 所以家長先至想了解多的, 比較兩校教法, 取態, 對學生的要求同支持, 學校的風氣和傳統等. 講到尾, 個個同學都如魚得水, 曉飛, 都唔及自己個仔讀得開心, 岩channel, 咁先有健康成長, 高增值嘛. 係咪?

ASamSam

原帖由 lawsonmoon 於 12-11-12 發表
蘋果日報今日話spcc文憑試通識,中文成績差。校長話知道,但佢地强項係英文,八成人考獲5级或以上(等於舊制C級 ...

請參看升中派位討論區；
聖保羅明年䦕7班不減人頭........

ASamSam

原帖由 simpleway 於 12-11-12 發表
回復 ASamSam 的帖子

睇生果報唔自己過濾下照單全收既人，智力可能有問題！

同意，所以其實大家可上去各校的網頁download它們的prospectus。

clpp

Dbspd

lawsonmoon

simpleway 發表於 12-11-12 09:43
回復 ASamSam 的帖子

睇生果報唔自己過濾下照單全收既人，智力可能有問題！

俾人熄完屏,又講得番嘢嗱？好好珍惜啊。

hadwinboy

ANChan59 發表於 12-11-12 00:29
What's the difference?

昨天眼見的中學生大多數外型討好 (可以叫靚仔, 連我先生也如此說), 玩得放但斯文, 個個神彩飛揚. 雙眼有神. 如此推斷他們沒有被學業壓得辛苦.   至於小學生, 很有禮貌. 接觸之下也是口齒伶俐及非常醒目! 昨為一個母親, 若將來小兒能有如此模樣, 真的如願足矣.
(以上純粹個人去fete後觀感, 不喜者勿插).

ANChan59

回復 hadwinboy 的帖子

Very positive comments.
Yesterday, my wife and I was sitting in the hall and drinking tea. We observed what's happening in the Hall and saw all parents and boys from whatever grades were exciting and happy.......

That's may be the last year for us to visit  the Garden Fete.

babybear

原帖由 hadwinboy 於 12-11-12 發表
昨天眼見的中學生大多數外型討好 (可以叫靚仔, 連我先生也如此說), 玩得放但斯文, 個個神彩飛揚. 雙眼有神. ...

又玩得、又讀得~ 呢啲叫醒目樣~

ASamSam

原帖由 hadwinboy 於 12-11-12 發表
昨天眼見的中學生大多數外型討好 (可以叫靚仔, 連我先生也如此說), 玩得放但斯文, 個個神彩飛揚. 雙眼有神. ...

作為家長，我們應該希望香港有多啲好學校，教好下一代，令多啲小朋友受惠。
可有良性競爭，但不應互插。