用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 小一選校 GH vs DGJS
樓主: Siammama
go

GH vs DGJS

Rank: 6Rank: 6


6679
發表於 12-9-28 10:08 |顯示全部帖子

回覆:Siammama 的帖子

從其他家長的回覆,看來很多家長已走火入魔了!忘了最緊要是揀一間配合家長的教育方針,和適合子女的小學了…有些家長居然從邊間出名d、校舍的建造費高而要見識一下、有幾多人最後會放棄學位…而去決定去邊間interview?未免太兒戲吧!
本人是GH家長,身份問題不便作出提議,而且最清楚自己子女,相信是自己了…客觀d講,找出兩間學校的不同處來比較,例如宗教、學校位置…實際d講,之前有家長已分享學校的面試模式,你認為貴子弟有能力完成嗎?



Rank: 3Rank: 3


209
發表於 12-9-28 11:04 |顯示全部帖子
ms.bead 發表於 12-9-28 10:08
從其他家長的回覆,看來很多家長已走火入魔了!忘了最緊要是揀一間配合家長的教育方針,和適合子女的小學了 ...

非常同意你的講法, 搵學校要配合家長對子女的教育方針, 找一家合適子女的學校是非常重要, 但不要忘記, 現在每家學校都有過千的考生, 要得到一個學位變得愈來愈遙遠, 對我來說, 我很喜歡陳守仁小學的教學方式, 亦覺得小孩非常合適這種較活動的模式, 但要在5000多人脫穎而出並不是一件容易事, 家長唯有可以做的, 就是適度的調整自己的心態, 在這場戰役, 愈一成不變, 就只會令自己更難過.......

Rank: 3Rank: 3


261
發表於 12-9-28 11:13 |顯示全部帖子

引用:Quote:ms.bead+發表於+12-9-28+10:08+從其

本帖最後由 Siammama 於 19-2-4 12:54 編輯
原帖由 步步驚心 於 12-09-28 發表
非常同意你的講法, 搵學校要配合家長對子女的教育方針, 找一家合適子女的學校是非常重要, 但不要忘記, 現 ...

你講得無錯,陳守仁小學係一所非常全面嘅活動教學小學




Rank: 3Rank: 3


209
發表於 12-9-28 11:16 |顯示全部帖子
Siammama 發表於 12-9-28 11:13
你講得無錯,陳守仁小學係一所非常全面嘅活動教學小學,大仔正在此校讀小三,仔仔同我哋都極滿意學校,如果 ...

預祝大家都成功

Rank: 6Rank: 6


6679
發表於 12-9-28 12:09 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 ms.bead 於 12-9-28 12:12 編輯

樓主因為GH同DGJS既INTERVIEW時間撞左,所以唔知點揀。點解無端端又走出第三間小學?當然,我都同意陳守仁是一間好學校...
其實,我想帶出的是機會率是"唯一"OR"其中"一個準則?50人爭一個位和100人爭一個位,家長就應該去間機會大嗎?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1571
發表於 12-9-28 12:15 |顯示全部帖子

引用:從其他家長的回覆,看來很多家長已走火入魔

原帖由 ms.bead 於 12-09-28 發表
從其他家長的回覆,看來很多家長已走火入魔了!忘了最緊要是揀一間配合家長的教育方針,和適合子女的小學了 ...
非常同意



Rank: 3Rank: 3


261
發表於 12-9-28 12:20 |顯示全部帖子

引用:樓主因為GH同DGJS既INTERVIEW時間撞左,所

原帖由 ms.bead 於 12-09-28 發表
本帖最後由 ms.bead 於 12-9-28 12:12 編輯

樓主因為GH同DGJS既INTERVIEW時間撞左,所以唔知點揀。點解 ...
我唔止三間,我總共報咗五間心儀小學,唔通只報一間,唔收先諗後路?我因為6/10上午GH 同DGJS相面試時間相撞唔知點揀而出帖問意見而已



Rank: 6Rank: 6


6679
發表於 12-9-28 12:53 |顯示全部帖子

回覆:Siammama 的帖子

本帖最後由 ms.bead 於 12-9-28 13:47 編輯

我想你誤會了,其實我大頭蝦,唔記得閣下就是樓主…hehe…以為其他人傾傾下又講埋其他學校,想集中討論這個問題,而且我都完全無話過唔比報幾間學校,唔好誤會...


Rank: 3Rank: 3


261
發表於 12-9-28 13:50 |顯示全部帖子

引用:+本帖最後由+ms.bead+於+12-9-28+13:47+編

原帖由 ms.bead 於 12-09-28 發表
本帖最後由 ms.bead 於 12-9-28 13:47 編輯

我想你誤會了,其實我大頭蝦,唔記得閣下就是樓主…hehe…以 ...




Rank: 3Rank: 3


292
發表於 12-9-28 17:14 |顯示全部帖子
I can spot one difference in the GH interview requirement this year. Some parents from GHK say that it will take 1.5 hour for the P1 interview. According to this website posts, some parents in the last 2 years said that the interview took them only 30 minutes. I guess the interview format will be changed as the Headmistress has been changed from Sister Lucia to Sister Pauline. I wonder the selection criteria would change this year too. Anyway, let's see.

If the interview takes 1.5 hour, it is impossible to try both interviews although there is no harm to have a try on that day.

I agree that you need to think about the suitability of GHS and DGJS for your girls. You may also ask some GH parents about the new change of GH with Sister Pauline to act as a the new Headmistress. From academic point of views, both schools have excellent public examination results this year. You need to think which type of girls you prefer and your girl prefers.

Good luck and God blessed!

Rank: 4


600
發表於 12-9-28 18:31 |顯示全部帖子
其實5歲小朋友除非性格好明顯, 唔係好多都好難match邊一間小學的, 如果我係樓主會去DGJS, IN完再赶去GH求情再IN

Rank: 4


646
發表於 12-9-28 18:32 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 zzbchu 於 12-9-28 18:36 編輯

I will give up gh interview after saw this http://www.ghs.edu.hk/sec/scholarships_graduate.htm
Their outstanding graduate. Many is doing ass degree.

Rank: 6Rank: 6


6679
發表於 12-9-28 23:55 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 ms.bead 於 12-9-29 09:31 編輯
zzbchu 發表於 12-9-28 18:32
I will give up gh interview after saw this http://www.ghs.edu.hk/sec/scholarships_graduate.htm
Their ...

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
Sorry, deleted post!

點評

Ryan_baba  你諗多左了,他所指嘅ass degree係副學仕,relax!  發表於 12-9-29 08:42

Rank: 4


646
發表於 12-9-29 02:25 |顯示全部帖子
回復 ms.bead 的帖子

I should said the outcome of GH is very board.

Rank: 4


838
發表於 12-9-29 12:45 |顯示全部帖子

引用:回復+ms.bead+的帖子I+should+said+the+o

本帖最後由 GHcat 於 12-9-29 12:52 編輯
原帖由 zzbchu 於 12-09-29 發表
回復 ms.bead 的帖子

I should said the outcome of GH is very board.

I am a past student of GH. Yes , we do have a wide range of talents and outcome of university entrance is really board. We have schoolmates taking associate degree courses but lots of them do well with recognition. We also have recipients of scholarship from both Cambridge and Oxford Universities. We have been taught not to judge ourselves and others from academic achievements only.
In addition, many of our schoolmates are now university students abroad.




Rank: 3Rank: 3


464
發表於 12-9-29 13:15 |顯示全部帖子
GHcat 發表於 12-9-29 12:45
I am a past student of GH. Yes , we do have a wide range of talents and outcome of university entra ...
就是的,現今部份家長都很功利,只看成績,希望子女每個都出類拔箤,就和女拔精神一樣,每一個都是精英,自己永遠高人一等,家長又能滿足其虛榮感,孩子往往就要犧牲其愉快童年及 純真的友情了。
所以有些人和子女小一選校時,往往是跟父母的主觀願望,而不是跟小朋友的性格去做配對,最終苦了的是孩子了。

點評

carolmum    發表於 12-10-5 00:25
onepiece    發表於 12-10-4 01:07

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2644
發表於 12-9-29 14:29 |顯示全部帖子
Finding a suitable school for children is not one way.  You can identify a school that fit your child best but that school may consider your child does not fit the school.  If you just find one, eventually there may be nothing.  
Therefore, it is fare for parents to choose some suitable school, just like buying insurance.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1155
發表於 12-9-29 16:04 |顯示全部帖子
i really agree  and hope that i can control myself mentally to choose a school which suits to my little boy. But, reality is reality..... as his parent, i hope he can get a token to get into universtiy one day..... so, today we try my best to screen the schools for him.....this is the thing but not the least I can do.

Rank: 3Rank: 3


152
發表於 12-9-30 02:19 |顯示全部帖子

回覆:Gagagogo 的帖子

上年我也遇到同一問題,結果我選了德望。當年的決定只因们覚得入dgs的机会好微因為太多考生而且我囡囡不是讀名幼而且又是12月B. 結果囡囡in waiting list,最後入到GS.
報此兩校只因為它們同樣注重学術和体藝很適囡囡,經過 一个多月的小学生涯及学校们講座,我發覺我當年设有選错。囡囡讀得很开心,進步很快而且不用补習,老師給她的工作紙、練習都是related to 课本,囡囡溫習默書沒有難度而且朗朗上口。每一課都能靈活運用,作為要工作的媽媽,我真的很滿意。但相反讀dgs要读很多material +课本知識,即在家中要有額外的support 才可完成。 這我也是途聽途説,如有错請指正。



Rank: 2


55
發表於 12-9-30 02:40 |顯示全部帖子
受到警告
回復 sotsang 的帖子

If your daughter studies at GH, how do you know DGJS?  Stop your BS unless you are parents from DGJS.