公文式中文

陰公之人

我小朋友4歲(下個月升K2), 剛開始讀公文式中文, 但每次上堂要聽大約5分鐘CD, 跟住老師會教小朋友聲母發音等, 然後俾功課, 每日在家聽CD.

有無人知道究竟有無成效呢? 會幾時先教認字,寫字呀? 因有些擔心, 什麼也學唔成........

如轉1對1學普通話會否好D呢? 加學記憶課程的中文, 會否好D呢? 因怕到面試小一時, 什麼也不懂回答.......

有無家長可俾一些意見呢?

謝謝!

陰公之人

謝謝你的提議!

PandaVV

我個人認為, 如果係學校只係上堂要聽CD, 跟住老師會教小朋友聲母發音等, 然後俾功課, 每日在家聽CD. 起初會有幫助, 但日子耐了, 小朋友會覺得悶.

學語言要交流才會有進步.
假如要您用相同的方法學語言, 您都會悶. 但係如果有其他人一起對話及練習,
效果會好好多.

1對1的教學係針對性質； 1對2或以上係互動性質. 最好兩樣都有.

bbforever

• kumon 中文要聽cd 外在課堂上都要朗讀句子(pth)，小朋友從中係會認埋字，老師係會教他們锐pth，重有埋pth 拼O

  ---

  
  
  

hkparent

But other classes or tutorials are only 1 or 2 times per week.  The kid can't learn any PTH on the days without lessons. The ideal learning is: using Kumon material but with native PTH teacher speaking with the kid every day, 7 days a week.  If it's too expensive, then Kumon material + CD is a good choice.

hkparent

If the PTH teacher's fee is very low say $100/hour, 0.5 hour/day x 30 days = $1500/month.  But can the teacher come for 0.5 hour every day to earn just $50?

jojoplanet

hkparent 發表於 12-9-20 13:23
But other classes or tutorials are only 1 or 2 times per week.  The kid can't learn any PTH on the d ...

岩..我個仔之前都係PLAYGROUP形式上普通話, 但一星期一堂佢真係唔記得, 上咗公文日日聽好咗好多, 講的確係唔夠既, 再可以有普通話老師同佢一對一講就PERFECT.

Shirley3

My son doesn't like Kumon at all..  He cries whenever he is listening the CD..