SPC VS St Paul Catholic

tsangnamnam

st paul catholic係半日班喎~~

Charlotte_mom

原帖由 tsangnamnam 於 12-06-26 發表
st paul catholic係半日班喎~~

現在很難取捨？好少見人渣spc offer 去叩st Paul catholic wor!

spmok1999

如果唔介意要比學費揀 SPC 啦!

bear2233

如果唔想做咁多功課就揀SPC啦

CrabPincers

兩間都係好學校
如果本身自己有D 家底, 我會叫人揀SPC
但我自己個人選擇, 幫個女揀, 我會揀ST PAUL CATHOLIC

純個人感覺咋.............

happysin

睇到呢d topic真係好鬼'蚊'....你去抽St Paul catholic之前, 唔係諗定抽到同唔抽到既選擇咩? 到今時今日先再上黎問邊間好? 先唔講你hold住d 位係唔係自私, 我只會覺得你自己連呢2間學校適唔適合個囡 (or family) 都要上黎問..., 有點講唔過去...不喜勿插!

仔仔錫錫你

第一聽到有人揸住spc 走去抽／叩catholic,如果你有遠見catholic 比spc 更適合各下女兒就catholic吧！

healtheworld

可能樓主有其他因素要考慮呢?

Kpang

我想有spc在手而去抽跑馬地St Paul不外乎兩個原因。一係$，另外就可能係有細妹跟尾而細妹不在spc度讀。咁都可以理解。

Tatyi

兩間都同屬一個教會！一樣好學校，問題在于錢同唔錢啫！有好多人認為家長讀得SPK只係住間SPC,但係我會分開睇，就算冇SPC,SPK都係一間好好嘅幼稚園，再講升Covent 好定Catholic 好，我覚得唔同家庭有唔同situation,有冇其他因素要考慮都好重要傢！冇分對與錯！大家只係想為小朋友好啫

QQ07011

另一考慮因素乃在六年後升中的問題,
雖然SPC不保證全部收回讀中一,
但基本上直資模式,中英數合格,升同一中學應無大問題.

如選政府資助模式,小五(或甚更早)開始又要
部署中學派位等的難題.

ggbwong

羨慕c人. !!!

harrybb2008

My girls study in SPC, as others said, if $ is not a concern, I would choose SPC.  Just personally think that their english skills is good (we don't speak english with our girls at home).

Also, for the P.6, they would have an interview (both english & cantonese), if you could pass the interview and you got a PASS in your P.6 exam, you would be admitted to their secondary school.

But if $ is a concern, of course SP Catholic la...

daisy17772

Definitely SPC because of its almost direct promotion to its secondary.  Otherwise St. Paul's Catholic is also a very very good school, its Chinese standard is really good, though you need to help her to strengthen on English.  Its secondary school's English is very high...in my days, the school was strong at science.  Go for St. Paul's Catholic if money is the concern.

Rattie

我都識幾個係由 spk/spn 升過去 sppcs
升中時有人揀直升 st paul sec
亦有人選擇考返去 st paul convent

阿女晌 sppcs 嘅 6年生涯
除了考試、測驗、默書，其餘時間佢都係返學返得好開心嘅

跑馬地唔駛 ＄ 校風頂瓜瓜
銅鑼灣要 ＄ 但個朵夠晌
相比下 d ＄ 係咪值得俾呢咁要你自己衡量喇
邊間適合你女多 d 應該冇人比你更清楚

升中升去隔離中學相信兩間比例唔差得幾遠
壓力最大嘅通常係嗰 d 要做到全級 top 20 同 keep 住唔好做包尾 20
難度相信不相伯仲
呵

4eyesDad

跑馬地 (St Paul's Catholic) is a Chinese primary school. No school fee.
銅鑼灣 (St Paul's Convent) is an English primary school. Some school fee.
Both primary schools have related/associated/linked top level English secondary schools.
If the kid's present language ability or English standard is not very strong, it is not a good thing to push her to learn a foreign language at primary level.

dogmonkey

leslie88 發表於 12-6-28 13:10
很多謝各位寶貴意見 ！首先對各位說 "對不起"，我都很想盡快解決這個問題。但對於還有一個幾個月妹妹的媽咪 ...

如果父母是working parents, 我覺得津校冇咁大壓力噃. 成績差最多repeat, 踢出校是否可laai死唔走?? 但私校要跟得好好.  不能用"有幾多樣功課"去衡量難度. 要看功課的要求. 一般津校功課是workbook之類, 女生自己完成非難事.  你要問問spc 是否要父母的involvement (做project, 搵資料, 高年班d 做group project, 管接送).  你看看九龍區那所名女校, 不是多麼歡迎家長有財力之餘, 阿媽"最好"唔洗做??  為什麼呢? 當然是跟得貼d啦.