用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 幼校討論 聖心明天 Interview la
樓主: Yipapa
go

聖心明天 Interview la  

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1935
發表於 12-1-9 15:42 |顯示全部帖子
Ackl1002 發表於 12-1-9 14:08
My girl didn't know the cucumber and green pepper, and told the teacher "I don't know", then the tea ...
我個女都唔識青瓜;
我個女只係攞住支青瓜問"咩黎架?"....我當時又唔想提佢, 所以話我都唔知, 咁老師就話係"青瓜"

我覺得老師唔想搵啲小朋友識青瓜; 而係睇吓佢地係唔識既情況吓有咩反應...

老師問咩係"衣服"; 囡囡手指已經游咗去衣服張圖度.....
但老師再問多次......咁阿囡就拎起咗隻手指...但又唔知放邊好;
老師再問一次囡囡先再指返幅衣服張相度
我都唔知係老師特登見囡囡指啱但都再問佢多次睇佢咩反應定係真係以為囡囡估估吓想confirm吓~~~

anyway, 我覺得聖心雖然問得兩個問題...但其實都唔淺

面試安排點講都唔算係好架啦........但其他學校可能人手真係多啲都唔奇

間學校design啲問題算幾叻, 可以係幾分鐘時間睇到好多野

anyway, 見完都知入唔到 :(
good luck to other parents @ babykingdom

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4187
發表於 12-1-9 16:29 |顯示全部帖子
w_y 發表於 12-1-9 15:41
當競爭如此激烈, 有咩選取條件係唔可能呢? 睇整體之餘, 有無邊d 環節係必定要全對? 邊個知? 我只係想話天外 ...

今年的BK巳變了好多,無謂太認真了

點評

markbean  Agree x 100000!  發表於 12-1-10 15:26
LittlePanda101  Yes   發表於 12-1-10 00:56
"即使你是友善的,人們可能還會說你自私和動機不良,不管怎樣,你還是要友善。即使你是誠實的,人們可能還會欺負你,不管怎樣,你還是要誠實。你今天做的善事,人們明天可能就忘記,不管怎樣,你還是要做善事。” 杜麗莎修女。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2082
發表於 12-1-9 16:47 |顯示全部帖子
"To Iantsang" :  Thanks for your suggestion.  Yes, I did already.  SH is a great school.  I am just trying to give some nice/kind suggestions here.  May be my tolerance level is too low (just being trained as working at a corporate world, being 10 mins late for a meeting is not acceptable)...For people with a close mind and not consider my suggestions, that's OK to me.  I will shut my mouth then.  

Rank: 3Rank: 3


272
發表於 12-1-9 17:35 |顯示全部帖子
我女果時interview完都覺得係吾收佢架,因為我都係照答返個女既日常生活既野,老師問佢生果後再叫佢跳去拎野,我女都係企左係度,我用手勢示意佢做,走果時大家都忘記泊好張櫈,我就覺得老師都係睇小朋友反應多d,吾係睇佢係咪答晒就收,老師問我個女平時做咩,我都係好老實咁答佢唱歌,跳舞咋喎,我果時等interview好多家長仲係門外拎住本英文書同d小朋友睇tim,仲要有家長同老師傾到吾願走都有,但係我吾理得咁多啦,判斷又吾係我地控制到!平常心啦!祝大家好運!

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4187
發表於 12-1-9 17:39 |顯示全部帖子
膽小媽媽 發表於 12-1-9 17:35
我女果時interview完都覺得係吾收佢架,因為我都係照答返個女既日常生活既野,老師問佢生果後再叫佢跳去拎 ...

有準備的家長和沒有準備的家長自然有不同,in完重要不斷blame學校

點評

w_y  好好奇, 呢類家長如幸運有Offer 會唔會俾子女入讀呢?  發表於 12-1-9 18:22
"即使你是友善的,人們可能還會說你自私和動機不良,不管怎樣,你還是要友善。即使你是誠實的,人們可能還會欺負你,不管怎樣,你還是要誠實。你今天做的善事,人們明天可能就忘記,不管怎樣,你還是要做善事。” 杜麗莎修女。

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

醒目開學勳章


46441
發表於 12-1-9 18:27 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 iantsang 於 12-1-9 18:30 編輯
ochan650 發表於 12-1-9 16:47
"To Iantsang" :  Thanks for your suggestion.  Yes, I did already.  SH is a great school.  I am just  ...

no need to be so sensitive!  Everyone are always welcome to give suggestions, but through a right channel.

If you would like to give constructive inputs to a school (any schools I meant), try to provide these suggestions directly to the school.  Posting it here is not a proper channel and I assume you would know how to effectively channel your communication with your corporate experience.

One thing that I would like to remind you, which is exactly the common mistakes many parents make nowadays.  A school/ kindergarten is an education institution.  It cannot works as a business entity and it never should.  It is a sad thing that people use such mind set to consider how a school should works nowadays.

btw, I do want to congratulate you of making the right choice for your family and your child.  


Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

醒目開學勳章


46441
發表於 12-1-9 18:29 |顯示全部帖子
brrbaby2007 發表於 12-1-9 16:29
今年的BK巳變了好多,無謂太認真了
Is it just BK?  I would assume BK is just a reflection of the reality nowadays........  

點評

LittlePanda101  True x 2  發表於 12-1-10 00:57
brrbaby2007  True  發表於 12-1-9 18:42

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

醒目開學勳章


46441
發表於 12-1-9 18:42 |顯示全部帖子
hangyodon 發表於 12-1-9 15:42
面試安排點講都唔算係好架啦........但其他學校可能人手真係多啲都唔奇

間學校design啲問題算幾叻, 可以係幾分鐘時間睇到好多野

Concerning the interview arrangement, just in case the parents are not aware, it is the collective efforts of 70 parent helpers.  All those helping you last Saturday are parents, who sacrifice their own precious time to help co-ordinate this event, so all of you can wait shorter.  The waiting time would have been even longer if these parents didn't make such contribution.  May be it is better to let the parents wait for 1-2 hours for interview next year, then someone can finally appreciate the efforts given by others.  But I guess, everyone just love to complain nowadays, don't we?

For the credits of designing the effective interview questions, please give it to the kindergarten and the teachers.  They totally deserve the praise.  Those are very carefully design so it can always be a mystery what the selection criteria really is, while being able to find the right candidates.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2997
發表於 12-1-9 18:42 |顯示全部帖子
我同意有o的家長o既分析, 學校唔係要求小朋友講個正確答案, 而係睇下佢o的o既態度同處理困難o既應變, 就算唔問家長問題, 家長o係呢o的關頭有咩反應都係態度o既一種。

上年in完, 我都有"in得咁快" o既感覺, 但回程諗返, 要design 問題其實都好有心思。

我個女上年白菜只係答咗菜, 老師話冇錯喇係菜o既一種, 但係佢個名同佢身上有種顏色有關喎....你睇有咩色.....
阿女: 有白色......叫白色菜
老師: 係白菜....
阿女: 白菜

蕃茄佢唔識, 但老師指住蕃茄時,阿女講咗以下說話: (指住頂頭綠色部份)呢度好吉o架, 要小心o的唔好掂到呀! (跟住伸手去摸紅色部份, 因係大蕃茄, 所以阿女成隻手掌去摸)呢度紅色就好滑唔會吉, 你摸下呢度~~

上年interview個老師非常友善, 繼續同阿女explore落去: 小朋友, 係喎, 有好多人鍾意食呢樣蔬果o架, 佢好有營養o架, 你知唔知佢叫咩名呢?  (我個女仍然唔識..) 叫蕃....

阿女: 蕃茄......婆婆有話俾我知好有營養呀!

呢個過程入面, 我間中望老師, 大部份望個女, 我感覺到個老師其實有觀察住我....所以我當時係提醒自己:唔好開聲提個女住, 俾o的空間同機會佢...

無論結果係點, 大家o既小朋友已經盡咗最大o既努力, 我o地應該用好欣賞o既態度去睇interview呢件事, 祝各位成功!



Rank: 5Rank: 5


1159
發表於 12-1-9 19:08 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 Yipapa 於 12-1-9 19:10 編輯
iantsang 發表於 12-1-9 18:27
no need to be so sensitive!  Everyone are always welcome to give suggestions, but through a  ...

There are really some kindergartens that work as business corporate.  They will close the school (students there will have extra holidays) for a couple of days for interviewing.  Candidates may be better off but in the expense of students.  Better or worse depends on which side you are standing.
BTW, I had seen a father that kept her daughter fully entertained during the 45 minutes waiting time.  The girl was still full of energy and joy when she was entering the interviewing room.
A role model to us

Perhaps patience is also the Key characters that the School is looking at.  If it is a good school that I admire, I can wait with my daughter for more than 45 minutes.
Perhaps exaggerated: 天將降大任於斯人也,必先苦其心志,勞其筋骨,餓其體膚,空乏其身


3038
發表於 12-1-9 19:13 |顯示全部帖子
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
簽名被屏蔽

Rank: 4


883
發表於 12-1-9 19:17 |顯示全部帖子
I like this school very much.

Rank: 4


582
發表於 12-1-9 20:25 |顯示全部帖子
每一所學校都有佢地認為合適的程序,也可能因應學校的環境設計而有不同的分流的方式。所以再好的安排也難滿足全部人的需要。
我囡囡已付出了佢的努力,我就只有把所有交給主的安排。
好多謝各位義工家長的幫忙及辛苦你們了。

Rank: 6Rank: 6


6266
發表於 12-1-9 20:30 |顯示全部帖子
其實好多學校都係要等。
等左咁耐,如果個小朋友都係活力十足無扭計,咁老師已大概可以估到,家長在呢45MIN時間,是能夠HANDLE佢既小朋友
此亦間接反映,最少小朋友最CLOSE既人,係有佢既辦法去處理小朋友情緒 ﹣ 即最少呢個小朋友不是一個不受控的孩子。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2261
發表於 12-1-9 21:55 |顯示全部帖子
我都好鍾意間學校!! 我女女平時好多野講, 係門口排隊時仲識叫老師早晨, 一入到去in 時唔點解好似啞咗咁! 唉......

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2830
發表於 12-1-10 00:05 |顯示全部帖子
回復 iantsang 的帖子

我呢D連續2年 in 既....就好明顯睇到今年既改變...今年真係好好多.....見到咁多義工家長..就一定知大家都對學校好有歸屬感....如果唔係...邊樹搵到咁多人俾咁多心機去安排, ...今年我地係 sister in, 我見到隔離間房都有 sister, 我第一個反應係 ..哇連 sister 都出動埋, 呢番心意, 我一廂情願諗係想多D人 in, 等大家早D in 完,

我阿Q咁諗...就算唔收...起碼呀仔學左樣野....咩叫青瓜...

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3385
發表於 12-1-10 00:49 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 lovelinda 於 12-1-10 00:49 編輯

回復 w_y 的帖子

w_y, say 個 hi 先..........:loveliness:

舊年我個女in 時, 佢都係只答到"菜", 答唔到"白菜", 但我們都有offer, 所以我諗老師/ 學校想要的答案, 未必一定是問題的答案, 而是從 interview 的過程中, 找到佢(學校)想要的答案........

而且, 我都明白好多家長都好質疑學校的收生條件, 因為interview 的時間實在很短, 但我可以講, 有經驗的老師真是一睇(從你行入來開始), 就已經可以知道好多野架啦!

anyway, 各位mami加油!!

點評

w_y  Hi...好同意, 如果青瓜真係咁重要, 相信下午面試者會著數好多.  發表於 12-1-10 18:02

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3385
發表於 12-1-10 00:51 |顯示全部帖子
回復 CoffeeCake 的帖子

我個係中b, 去年都是pm offer........

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3385
發表於 12-1-10 01:04 |顯示全部帖子
回復 iantsang 的帖子

.................Those are very carefully design so it can always be a mystery what the selection criteria really is, while being able to find the right candidates...................

Hi Ian, long time no talk la, 所以我都話...........最重要唔係間學校是否你杯茶, 而是你是否學校杯茶.........  

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3385
發表於 12-1-10 01:08 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 lovelinda 於 12-1-10 01:12 編輯

回復 布希亞 的帖子

唔好意思, 我認同sh是一間不同其他幼稚園咁市繪商業的傳統幼稚園, 但我唔認同是"唯一"一間.......

我相信仍然有很多熱心辦學的好學校架