How would you rank St Paul's Boy, SFA, APS, Ying Wa ?

JoshuaN

How would you rank  St Paul's Boy, SFA, APS, Ying Wa ?Would you mind sharing your reasons ?

NKpa

What's your priority?

- academic
- music
- sports
- location
- boy or co-ed
- through-train
- protestant or catholic
- extent of parent involvement

I don't have a list of comparison of these factors among the schools. But I think if you want to know, you may do it yourself and share your view to us.

gentlelam

其實四間都好好，你仔仔都一定係好叻仔先可以考到晒。我會選英華，因為一條龍直升。

bigfatboy

For me, I would choose Ying Wa as I prefer through-train school and we live in Kln side  Location is one of our main concern and SPB is too far away.......

prettygirl2011

I would choose St Paul Boys because these schools are similar in level and St Paul Boys would have a big new campus next year.

KikiDaddy

If you are happy with their feeder schools, YWPD and SPB for sure. If you are willing to spend sufficient time and effort in the next 6 years, studying in APS/SFA will give you a 25% chance to get a place in a better secondary school like DBS, LS, SPCC, QC, Lam Woo & etc. However, the risk is really high.

Ving

This is an interesting topic to see if you would like to enter a feeder school or school with high admission rate to good school. In fact, non-feeder schools has to compete with other schools (not sure how many new DSS schools in coming few years and not sure with government policy), it means there is a risk to good secondary school after 6 years.
I think if you think/expect can keep up with conduct and academic result, then non-feeder school is a choice, however, if u are risk-adverse then feeder school may cure the head-ache.

By the way, anyone have info about new setup DSS/private school in the coming few years?

PWHPOPO

回復 JoshuaN 的帖子

SPCPS for sure(因YW還未肯定收). SPC is the traditional and famous school. 歷史悠久的好學校對小朋友的將來(例如:工作or出國留學)有幫助。當中只有是YW and SPCPS值得想一想。SFA and APS 當然也OK.不過,當年我女兒為了一間有直屬中學的男女津校也放棄了APS, SFA and TT.到現在我也沒有regrets!
SFA,APS可以揷其他好學校,確是真的!不過有幾多是人揷到?最多考頭五名及操行佳才賜個written entrance exams給你。又或者仔仔好似那位音樂神童(沈小朋友)咁勁,就可以由SFA 揷DBSPD!再唔係好似我朋友個女:識人,又可以由SFA插入ST Paul Convent!
想清楚後快放位啦!

Ving

回復 PWHPOPO 的帖子

但聽聞APA都有十多個入男，女拔，吾知真定假。不過都系嗰句，大人小朋友要博。

celinapang

If for ranking., it should be St Paul's boy is more higher than others...

ASamSam

回復 celinapang 的帖子

May I know your ground for the ranking?

Thanks.

Ving

I think if considering for SPCPS, it should consider both (academic+conduct) as a whole but not only academic. As you might have better choice if your consideration is academic only.

Charlotte_mom

Ving 發表於 11-12-26 15:36
回復 PWHPOPO 的帖子

但聽聞APA都有十多個入男，女拔，吾知真定假。不過都系嗰句，大人小朋友要博。 ...

我朋友讀APS, 佢話早2年的確有一界升中特別好, 校長都講笑咁話, 佢個女果年(之後果年)一定無咁好
結果我朋友個女都無去女拔, 去左另一間TOP TIER學校(唔係超級名校喇)

lugano

JoshuaN 發表於 11-12-25 17:03
How would you rank  St Paul's Boy, SFA, APS, Ying Wa ?Would you mind sharing your reasons ?

如果純論名氣和認受性...... 聖保羅和英華可能會高一點, 話哂都係 "Grant School 22" 的成員 (即傳統名校)

但其實 SFA 一點都不遜色, 亦是一間很有質素的學校, 可惜 6 年後要煩多次

Ving

Is it new  term for "Grant School 22"? Does it apply to DSS/private only or other govertnment school? Where can get the list for reference, thx

lugano

Ving 發表於 11-12-28 13:43
Is it new  term for "Grant School 22"? Does it apply to DSS/private only or other govertnment school ...

香港補助學校議會

http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E9%A6%99%E6%B8%AF%E8%A3%9C%E5%8A%A9%E5%AD%B8%E6%A0%A1%E8%AD%B0%E6%9C%83

香港補助學校議會由香港22所歷史悠久的英文教會學校所組成。由於這些學校已創立多時，培育過不少社會人才，教學成果有目共睹，而且各校均有獨特的文化傳承，被坊間統稱為傳統名校或香港名校或名校。香港補助學校議會與香港津貼中學議會等學校議會，對香港中等教育的政策制定都有影響力。

這些學校全早於1973年前受政府指定資助，所以名為補助學校（英語：Grant Schools）。這些學校全部由教會主辦，大部份經費來自政府的補助，但學校的日常運作由辦學的教會負責。

成員學校（依創校年份排序）

英華書院（1818年）[註 1]

聖保羅書院（1851年）

聖保祿學校（1854年）

拔萃女書院（1860年）

嘉諾撒聖心書院（1860年）

拔萃男書院（1869年）

嘉諾撒聖方濟各書院（1869年）

聖若瑟書院（1875年）

英華女學校（1900年）

嘉諾撒聖瑪利書院（1900年）

聖士提反女子中學（1906年）

聖保羅男女中學（1915年）

香港華仁書院（1919年）

九龍華仁書院（1924年）

瑪利諾修院學校（1925年）

瑪利曼中學（1927年）

聖嘉勒女書院（1927年）

喇沙書院（1932年）

協恩中學（1936年）

聖馬可中學（1949年）

循道中學（1958年）

聖保祿中學（1960年）

tkyy

SFA for sure

hkspiderman

最怕呢d家長，當初又話首選邊間邊間，最後又係hold住幾間唔知做吔