玫瑰崗好d定係聖嘉勒好d

pibe

McBonnie

I will pick St Clare.

pibe

I understand St Clare's is one dragon.

Apart from this, can u share why u will pick St Clare's?

yaulinda

I like rosaryhill better -
better language environment,
better teaching approach,
better campus,
better girl-boy ratio

orsiuping

Understand difference parents with difference consideration and worries.

If you were the one of child-oriented, rely on "lucky draw" for P1's placement or your child will go to try private and direct-subsidiary Pri anyway, Rosaryhill absolutely is a better kindergarten to children.  I agreed with what "yaulinda" said but it is not mean St. Clare not good.  If I was child, I would find RSH's teaching approaches are more active, full of fun in the class, children love and enjoy their school life much more there.  

However, we may have some parents also consider about P1's allocation after childred's 3 years kindergarten school life.

General comment is that the standard of Rosaryhill Pri. section is not as good as St. Clare's.  It is not only measure English standard but overall average and moral education as well as discipline training etc. are also taken into our account. If your idea is to have your kid study at St. Clare's Pri Section, I think it is better to have her get start with their kindergarten because they gurantee P1's placement to their kg student and also will take some advantage to their S1's placement in future (extra scores added for their Pri student, details refer to their Secondary school's web).

Yes, I agree that it is difficult for us to make decision as if from parent-oriented.  Happy kindergarten's life or happy primary's life?!

蘇眉小姐

For girl, I will pick St. Clare...but for boy, I think RHS is better...RHS's P1 allocation result is awesome. go and check here : http://www.rhs.edu.hk/kg/

註 Notes:   
  
居住灣仔區的學生派往灣仔區首三志願小學的比例 100%
Students, who live in Wanchai district, have been allocated to Wanchai schools as their first 3 choices
  
居住其他地區的學生派往灣仔區小學的比例 42%
Students, who live in other districts, have been allocated to Wanchai schools
  
居住其他地區的學生派回本區首三志願小學的比例 58%
Students, who live in other districts, have been allocated to schools in their own districts as their first 3 choices

pibe

thx for your sharing.

pibe

原帖由 蘇眉小姐 於 11-12-15 11:20 發表
For girl, I will pick St. Clare...but for boy, I think RHS is better...RHS's P1 allocation result is awesome. go and check here : http://www.rhs.edu.hk/kg/

註 Notes:   
  
居住灣仔區的學生派往灣仔區 ...

yes, seems that allocation result is very good!  dun know if RHS students have advantages at "knock door" stage.

蘇眉小姐

我覺得個"knock door" hit rate不錯 , 叩WanChai區入首三志願42%, 入他區首三志願接近6成人....難怪少於2成人入番原校(因大家有更好嘅選擇嘛....) 好少學校網頁有咁詳細嘅data...係babykingdom, 我睇咗好多家長話去叩門時, 好多名校一聽係RHS出嚟嘅即時comment"嗰小朋友嘅英語水準應該很不錯", 我認為呢嗰comment有實際理據支持, 因RHS用2日全英語教學, 2日全普通語, 1日蒙特梭利..我自已覺得好過每日得20 or 30 mins一堂...當然, 大家也明白其中學唔得, 故如果係女就St. Clare啦..一直上唔使煩....

叮噹媽媽

Thanks 蘇眉小姐 for sharing.

My son got PM offer at both RHS and Precious Blood, I intend to let my son go to RHS due to their curriculum coverage. Do you know if their Primary School ok? Not much student from K to P is due to better allocation or school itself is not good? Feel frustrated !  Thank you !

蘇眉小姐

RHS Primary係私校,據知也很不錯(因小兒也有PN offer所以也不停打聽同研究.. )祇是WanChai區嘅名小校也著實不少(St. Joseph. St. Paul, Marymount, St. Francis...etc, 所以在BK到RHS K3家長心態大都係...有St. Paul, St. Joseph...etc offer就當然轉, 否則都很樂意留係RHS Primary..

Charlotte_mom

小心留意
政府派位, 識唔識字都一樣咁派, 同讀邊間幼稚園更加無關(除左叩門)
如果各位家長未熟悉小一派位方法, 請往以下網址
http://www.chsc.hk/psp/psp_content5.php?lang_id=2

原帖由 蘇眉小姐 於 11-12-15 11:20 AM 發表
For girl, I will pick St. Clare...but for boy, I think RHS is better...RHS's P1 allocation result is awesome. go and check here : http://www.rhs.edu.hk/kg/

註 Notes:   
  
居住灣仔區的學生派往灣仔區 ...

Charlotte_mom

學校網頁無話42%係叩門rate, 只係居住其他地區的學生派往灣仔區小學的比例 42%
睇數字時要小心觀察, 以免日後大失預算

原帖由 蘇眉小姐 於 11-12-16 10:27 AM 發表
我覺得個"knock door" hit rate不錯 , 叩WanChai區入首三志願42%, 入他區首三志願接近6成人....難怪少於2成人入番原校(因大家有更好嘅選擇嘛....) 好少學校網頁有咁詳細嘅data...係babykingdom, 我睇咗好多家 ...

蘇眉小姐

多謝賜教!那就是說此42%當中包括自行分配學額(所謂世襲&計分制)+叩門, 對嗎?

w_y

睇乜都無用, 一見 "頭3 志願" 4 個字, 都可以慳返. 好多家長保守, 根本唔會將區內至強放第二,三, 甚至第一.

Charlotte_mom

如果學校無特別講, 就應該係了
俾另一間學校EXAMPLE你睇, 佢就分得細D
http://www.lingliang.org.hk/top.htm
(右下小一入學情況)

另外, 入唔入3甲, 亦同"策略"有關, (升小一同升中一一樣, 選校要講STRATEGY的), 就算灣仔區, 亦有D無咁熱門既學校, 我就無聽過邊間幼稚園會特別O係政府派位因為咩有利原因而保證入3甲(政府派位一視同仁), 唯一可以解釋, 就係策略(將D穩陣之選擺前面)或者叩門(學你話齋學生特別得校長喜愛)了