Cat 2 是沒有機會

crystalpui

我仲以為港島esf會多d位
因為港島有好幾間esf primary.....

oooray

原帖由 myhappyfamily 於 11-11-15 19:45 發表
當然 呢到有好多人可以好輕鬆咁講 k2考唔到esf Y1 未去考其他IS, 因為你們未去到最後呢步 比人拒絕 而入唔到的感覺, 他們的期望, 計畫一掃而空, 就算 有兄姊 在校就讀, 都依然被拒門外. 到這個時候的你, 我看你未必 ...

你呢點我完全同意。
你個人對esf primary不感興趣我沒有異議；問題是遊戲規則是Cat. 2 applicants機會越來越少，而讀esf kindergarten差不多是Cat. 2 non-silbling, non-staff, non-old boys/gals (我稱之為三無人士)入讀esf primary唯一希望；那對有興趣選擇入讀esf primary而入讀esf kindergarten的家長來說，有錯嗎?
當然，在沒有保證之情況下，個別家長只參考歷史數據而不安排任何contingency plan，後果當然要自己承受。

oooray

原帖由 lovelyteresa 於 11-11-15 22:24 發表
Actually my target is RCHK but don't know if the chance is still very slim...please advise.
I'm a new comer to te school world so would like to know more from bk, thanks a lot!

RCHK does not use the category system as ESF primary (pls. visit their website for details). In fact, ESF kindergarten applicants (eligible to those starting from K1) do have the INTERVIEW priority (note: interview only).

Radiomama

rchk preferred to choose "smart chinese students" (in the previous years) and please equip your kid if your target is this school.

My blog: http://blog.yahoo.com/radiomama
(for your reference)

原帖由 oooray 於 11-11-16 10:16 發表

RCHK does not use the category system as ESF primary (pls. visit their website for details). In fact, ESF kindergarten applicants (eligible to those starting from K1) do have the INTERVIEW priority ( ...

[ 本帖最後由 Radiomama 於 11-11-16 13:42 編輯 ]

Pilotkid

原帖由 oooray 於 11-11-16 10:11 發表

你呢點我完全同意。
你個人對esf primary不感興趣我沒有異議；問題是遊戲規則是Cat. 2 applicants機會越來越少，而讀esf kindergarten差不多是Cat. 2 non-silbling, non-staff, non-old boys/gals (我稱之為三無人士)入 ...

我嘅小朋友去年係讀ESF kinder, 但係三無人仕最後入到小學。若果冇讀ESF kinder三無人仕一定冇機會interview。舊年真係有部份cat2冇得interview。我可以講我小朋友嘅全班同學只有一個入唔到ESF 小學或esf私校，佢最後入到其他IS。以前ESF kinder幾乎所有都入到小學。但由2010開始越來越難。

lovelyteresa

[code][/code]明白了，即是若三無人士入esf kg 就唔好大安旨意， 一定要有後備計劃啦！但rchk唔係後備啩？聽你地呓講唔易入噃？明白了，即是若三無人士入esf kg 就唔好大安旨意， 一定要有後備計劃啦！但rchk唔係後備啩？聽你地呓講唔易入噃？

oooray

原帖由 lovelyteresa 於 11-11-16 14:22 發表
明白了，即是若三無人士入esf kg 就唔好大安旨意， 一定要有後備計劃啦！但rchk唔係後備啩？聽你地呓講唔易入噃？明白了，即是若三無人士入esf kg 就唔好大安旨意， 一定要有後備計劃啦！但rchk唔係後備啩？聽你地呓講唔易入噃？ ...

入到個d咪話易入，入唔到個d咪話難入囉!
人人期望唔同，有唔少人當RCHK係2nd Choice，亦有好多人放棄所有offer去讀RCHK...

Pilotkid

原帖由 lovelyteresa 於 11-11-16 14:22 發表
明白了，即是若三無人士入esf kg 就唔好大安旨意， 一定要有後備計劃啦！但rchk唔係後備啩？聽你地呓講唔易入噃？明白了，即是若三無人士入esf kg 就唔好大安旨意， 一定要有後備計劃啦！但rchk唔係後備啩？聽你地呓講唔易入噃？ ...

其實後備計劃任何時候都應該要有。極大部分人都有申請ESF 小學和 ESF私校RC或 DC。想入ESF小學應該讀英基幼稚園尤其是"三無人仕＂。

Pilotkid

原帖由 lovelyteresa 於 11-11-16 14:22 發表
明白了，即是若三無人士入esf kg 就唔好大安旨意， 一定要有後備計劃啦！但rchk唔係後備啩？聽你地呓講唔易入噃？明白了，即是若三無人士入esf kg 就唔好大安旨意， 一定要有後備計劃啦！但rchk唔係後備啩？聽你地呓講唔易入噃？ ...

我沒有當RC為後備計劃因為RC都是心儀選擇。當時我申請其他IS為後備。

cissyc

well i think it well applies to RC, but definitely not to esf primary as the priority system is about cat 1/cat 2.
when i was told i won't be giving chance for an interview for my kid who is now in TY K2 with sibling at the primary school, i questioned the principal that will all 100% cat 1 be necessary suceeded in the interview, he said even though they fail, there are still many cat 1 in the queue. i hesitate how come there are so many cat 1 and how they make the definition.

lovelyteresa

Hey cissyc, may i
Know which esf p u were applying for ur younger kids? So wierd that even u hv an elder one in still u got no interview...then where do those cat1 come from? Mainland or tw? I know less expatriates now in hk compare with 10 yrs ago...

alpham0m

Lots of Euroasian, Indian, Korean and Japaense kids are all categorized as Cat 1. Look at KJS's mix and you can see how easily those 150 spots in Y1 can be taken up by Cat 1 kids, including the ones who don't go to ESF Kindy.

[ 本帖最後由 alpham0m 於 11-11-16 20:47 編輯 ]

cissyc

KJS是也

原帖由 lovelyteresa 於 11-11-16 18:48 發表
Hey cissyc, may i
Know which esf p u were applying for ur younger kids? So wierd that even u hv an elder one in still u got no interview...then where do those cat1 come from? Mainland or tw? I know le ...

Radiomama

Em...I'd better elaborate a little bit more.
1) good communication skill & proficiency in speaking English
2) knowledgeable
3) well behavior
RCHK should maintain 70% of HK resident and since the applicants are far more than the existing places, they would choose the suitable students.
And the interview time was extended from 30 mins to 1 hour since last year.

Radiomama

For the one who wants to apply RCHK (year one) for your kid, please have a look of the following information which is prepared by the school.

http://www.renaissance.edu.hk/sites/renaissance/files/RCHK_Admissions_2012-13.pdf

FennieMan

For KJS, last year if you are in Cat 2, most of them also no chance for interview!

cissyc

i don't know how was the situation last year, did all the children eventually got interview?

FennieMan

They been offer an interview for RC, DC, but not KJS!