YORK 人人都收?

Sumyeema1

原帖由 peggyhklam 於 11-8-26 17:25 發表

st cat同根德夠無貼啦, 唔通又話唔好呀

奇啦， 個 topic 講 york, 又有貴校校友話個個考到好學校， 我好奇問一下姐，你又要扯到其他學校？！
我有話過你地學校唔好嗎？

anteater

其實YORK一共有幾多位呢?佢又有分校,應該都收到好多人

JR東日本

原帖由 giantkid 於 11-8-26 17:21 發表

St Cath 同 kv 都無係網站報佢地畢業生考到咩學校啦，貼與唔貼真係咁重要﹖鍾意佢咪讀佢，唔鍾意咪唔讀，每人心中有自己讀與唔讀既原因，何必將自己既意願加諸別人身上﹖每個家長都有選校既原因，點解咁執著別人選什麼﹖ ...

我同意你呀! 都唔明D人點解GUM鍾意針對YORK! 例如買手袋, 我鍾意LV, 她鍾意COACH, 她鍾意PRADA, 她鍾意agnes b, 其實都係好嘢, 只不過每人都因應自己的喜好去買不同東西; 當你背著你喜歡的prada出街時, 你會在街上向背著agnes b, LV, COACH的人用力批評嗎?  何不試試一同欣賞大家的優點呢?

cykk

其實唔係鐘意針對York,係因為洗禮事件學校真係做錯咗,另到其它人對學校印像唔好,但真係無辦法,因為事件唔係傳言,係事實,所以需要用時間做好另人改觀。小女讀KV三年,由K1開始已打聽每年學生升小一成績,因學校從不發放資訊,所以真的很難得到比較全面答案,雖然小女今年結果能孝入一間很好的小學,但也不能對人說KV今年考得好好,所以對傳言KV學生考小學唔係太好絕對不能認同。

MeganTT

No worry.My girl is born at Nov who accepted at am international class even the interview date is a bit late. however, she didn't switch to York as she study in the current kinder......

原帖由 chungmanchung20 於 11-8-26 13:17 發表
見好多POST都話YORK 人人都收。有咁多位咩?我幫仔仔報左，不過學校話佢係細仔所以遲D先IN。我怕收左大仔細仔又無咁多位啦。

chungmanchung20

原帖由 MeganTT 於 11-8-26 18:39 發表
No worry.My girl is born at Nov who accepted at am international class even the interview date is a bit late. however, she didn't switch to York as she study in the current kinder......

Thanks! 我去完簡介會之後都幾鍾意架，學校又大。我相信仔仔都鍾意架。而且我仔仔返playgroup好鍾意NET，所以我都諗住俾佢讀YORK OR STAFFORD。

Jenjo

簡介會通常幾時會開架?n班會唔會有架?在York個website又唔覺有的.

YumYummy

Hi Jenjo,
簡介會通常係你報咗名之後通知你幾時有的!  N班都應該要去聽架!

原帖由 Jenjo 於 11-8-29 18:01 發表
簡介會通常幾時會開架?n班會唔會有架?在York個website又唔覺有的.

Jenjo

Hi, chungmanchung20,
我已經報咗2012年度n班, 但係未收到通知有簡介會. 你仔仔是否報咗2012年度的k呀?? 知唔知大約幾月會interview? Many thanks!

popcorn11202001

算啦,間YORK踩親SUMYEEMA條尾架,
一有YORK既POST佢就一定入黎加把口,
早排仲自篇一個故事黎影射YORK,
其實你咁唔鐘意間學校,你咪唔好入黎睇囉,你又要睇
又要勞氣,做人唔好咁過份啦!
其實你咁得閒,咁關心咁留意間YORK,
你咪日日打電話去叫你口中"個平時好鐘意高調既校
長"叫UPDATE個網頁,寫佢學生叩門既成績到網頁囉,學校會好接受你既意見
架,唔該哂你呀真係!

[ 本帖最後由 popcorn11202001 於 11-8-30 17:43 編輯 ]

fannychan88

原帖由 Jenjo 於 11-8-30 17:05 發表
Hi, chungmanchung20,
我已經報咗2012年度n班, 但係未收到通知有簡介會. 你仔仔是否報咗2012年度的k呀?? 知唔知大約幾月會interview? Many thanks!

Hi Jenjo
我係報2012年K1 .7月12日寄申請表去 ,但收到通知8月20日有家長簡介會,可惜我不在港沒出席.  但有部分通知簡介會時己經有interview日期8月27日.  因為我未能出席簡介會時有打電話去學校, 佢地問我可否出席27號interview日期. 其實我封信係寫住9月中, 我估係分咗幾批In,

Christi

首先,我唔認識sumyeema;

其次,我睇過佢啲post,好多都好中肯;大家都係畀吓意見表達吓睇法,我認為唔駛一下子上綱到[踩親佢條尾]呢個層次去討論. 因為去到呢個層次,係冇得理性討論,只有發洩同埋罵戰.

再其次,作為路人甲,我一啲都唔覺得佢之前的post有任何得罪york之處. 況且,如果啲KG都將升小成績公開放上網,大家有晒數據唔駛靠口耳相傳,咁,乜唔係大家家長之福咩?

再再其次,都係嗰句,我相信,無論讀邊間學校的家長(包括york)都係想仔女得到最好,之前的爭議已過去,我相信沒有人會刻意歧視york,也很很很希望york的家長不要太過神經敏感,對於一些批評或者質疑,就冠上[歧視]標籤.如果隨便溜覽一下BK,亦會發現很多KG(包括很多名KG)都有網友質疑.

最後,面對質疑時,亦請不要一下子認為個別的質疑即=否定全間學校=否定教師的努力=否定家長的選擇.這樣想的話,一嚟想錯想多了,二嚟亦令自己無端端唔開心.

原帖由 popcorn11202001 於 11-8-30 17:41 發表
算啦,間YORK踩親SUMYEEMA條尾架,
一有YORK既POST佢就一定入黎加把口,
早排仲自篇一個故事黎影射YORK,
其實你咁唔鐘意間學校,你咪唔好入黎睇囉,你又要睇
又要勞氣,做人唔好咁過份啦!
其實你咁得閒,咁關心咁留意間YORK ...

[ 本帖最後由 Christi 於 11-8-30 23:24 編輯 ]

萬樂豬

其實當我同朋友講報 york 時, 佢地既反應一樣係咁大, 又話校風唔好影響升小學,  又話氾收費, 仲話預計每個月起碼 表6-7仟蚊....搞到我都心大心細....最後都有報 york , 無論點, 都希望多一個機會, 因為佢英文真係教得好好.....

peggyhklam

原帖由 Christi 於 11-8-30 23:17 發表
首先,我唔認識sumyeema;

其次,我睇過佢啲post,好多都好中肯;大家都係畀吓意見表達吓睇法,我認為唔駛一下子上綱到[踩親佢條尾]呢個層次去討論. 因為去到呢個層次,係冇得理性討論,只有發洩同埋罵戰.

再其次,作為路人 ...

咁唔該你都去st cat同kv 的post入面提其他家長叫學校都post每年的成績上去呀, 唔該你做下好心幫幫手, 我都想知點解st cat同kv 無post, 但又無人話st cat同kv?

iantsang

版主按 :

懇請大家能保持冷靜討論的氣氛，不要人身攻擊或作出侮辱性的言詞。

多謝大家合作!

iantsang

popcorn11202001 and peggyhklam,

I fully understand the pressure that you have to face, and I have shared this with other current or previous parents.  However, as you have made the decision to choose a school then the best way is to focus on what are good for your children.

Although I seldom talk about it but I have spent large amount of time on York.  Although we eventually didn't choose it but we had considered it as a reasonable sound school.  At least, I chose not to apply St. Cat and rather choose York in our list back then!

At the end, the choice of schools are totally a personal preference.  I trusted you have chose it with a good reason.  So, don't be irritated by others' comments as this couldn't help the school's image.  Just share your positive feelings and experience to let time prove what you have done is right!

At the end, there are simply no guarantee of being accepted by private or DSS schools even though they are students from any of those Kowloon Tong kindergartens.  Some ppls like to say good things about their own schools just to make themselves feel better only.  So, just let it be.  At the end, it is how your children grow up with the parents support that will come out the winner.

All the best!

Ian

[ 本帖最後由 iantsang 於 11-8-31 10:34 編輯 ]

peggyhklam

我不是勞氣呀, 而係我真係好想知st cat and kv的K3學生考小學的戰績, 因我想知是否真的好好

iantsang

原帖由 peggyhklam 於 11-8-31 10:37 發表
我不是勞氣呀, 而係我真係好想知st cat and kv的K3學生考小學的戰績, 因我想知是否真的好好

frankly, of course not.  At the end, those P1 allocation results are meaningless.  Schools will just like to highlight the few outstanding ones and parents pay attention to that alone.  But honestly, this assumption force everyone has the same preferences!

Like if we don't apply to SPCC and DGJS (and yes we won't), does it mean my daughter is not as smart?  People nowadays force everyone to select schools on a particular "ranked" list.  But in reality, rational and caring parents CHOOSE those that is indeed suitable for their own children.  

Ian

小曳人

睇學校嘅畢生生派位成績，對於我，只係呢d家長嘅選校傾向，唔係畢業嘅小朋友受咩學校歡迎！(假設，大部份嘅小朋友都有超過一個offer)
講到底，人地鍾意去讀邊間，同自己嘅關於不大！如果我個仔俾db同yw收咗，我會揀yw架！咁係唔係可以話呢間學校嘅小朋友唔受db歡迎呢？太多嘢無响數據度表現出嚟 (more than佢表現出嚟嘅) ，咁~ 無得睇都唔係d咩嘅損失呀~