英粵班和英普班, 應該點揀?

laupig

開始為阿仔諗報K1, 有無經驗媽咪可以分享下點揀呢?

Angine

I picked 英普班. To build the foundation and language proficiency from young for long term development.

ok_ko

如果你係屋企同小孩說普通話，選英普班。如果講廣東話，選英粵吧。如果是講英文的，就無所謂。用一種不是太明白的語言去認知，對3-4歲的小孩好嗎？

傻太

原帖由 Angine 於 11-8-24 17:57 發表
I picked 英普班. To build the foundation and language proficiency from young for long term development.

Dear Angine,

Long time no see.. ...will u apply any k in coming few months???

lyhv

我會咁睇, 首先和最重要係小朋友言語能力, 如果有delay, 我唔建議揀英普班, 因為絕對會阻礙小朋友廣東話嘅語言發展和溝通能力!  其次係, 家人如果平時同小朋友用廣東話溝通時間少而又target主流真資小學, 我亦唔建議英普班, 要知道日後大多數嘅主流真資小學面試係用英語和粵語, 如果平時少用粵語, 會對小朋友面試時不利!  除非你預左小朋友日後只會主要用英語溝通, 或有信心可以令到小朋友英粵普三語發展得到平衡, 否則英普班未必係一個好選擇!  其實好多幼稚園嘅英粵班都有提供普通話課堂, 有需要亦可以再到外面興趣班進修普通話, 對日後銜接小學嘅普通話課程, 應該唔會有大問題!

chowhui97

我讚成報英普班, 我個女都讀緊.

與其花錢和時間課餘時俾小朋友係外面再學 eng / pth, 不如係學校學仲正統同慳時間.  課餘就可以學其他佢喜歡的活動!

小女在家對工人講英文, 父母就講廣東話, so far 我覺得無問題, 佢亦無 language confusion, 小朋友的學習能力好高, 不能少看!

唔好理將來佢小學 interview 用英文, 廣東話定普通話, 學咗的就係佢自己, language 好將來去邊種學校讀書我覺得都會事半功倍!

Angine

Dear 傻太,
Wow haven't seen you around for sometime. You must be busy with two kids now right? Is a younger brother or sister? Hey talk separately as don't want to disturb other's topic.
And yes, may apply some k1...will see.

原帖由 傻太 於 11-8-25 09:12 發表

Dear Angine,

Long time no see.. ...will u apply any k in coming few months???

cpcog

I chose Cantonese because it would be easier for my daughter to adapt the school life. Since K3, there were no more Cantonese class so she could have one year Mandarin class. This arrangement  is quite good in my mind so she can get prepared for the Mandarin in primary school.

funbeauty

如果讀英普的話，小朋友學中文會唔會只識那個詞語PTH的讀法而唔識廣東話架。
另有無過來人經驗是讀開{英普}但適應唔到OR不喜歡而轉回中英文班架？
THANKS