資優小朋友有沒有公文數

ballcat

請問你地小朋友有沒有學公文數學, 我個囝現在有一個問題, 就係佢每一日做完大量數學後, 就會好興奮, 會手舞足蹈, 會有少少控制唔到自己咁, 是不是正常?
但是他從小到大, 也很愛數字和數學~

mio8390

資優教育學院的課程多數是奧數，是沒有公文數教的。

原帖由 ballcat 於 11-7-10 11:01 發表
請問你地小朋友有沒有學公文數學, 我個囝現在有一個問題, 就係佢每一日做完大量數學後, 就會好興奮, 會手舞足蹈, 會有少少控制唔到自己咁, 是不是正常?
但是他從小到大, 也很愛數字和數學~ ...

ANChan59

原帖由 koala_choco 於 11-7-10 22:31 發表
有個疑惑, 其實資優小朋友點會鐘意公文架 ?

I have the same question......

Some boy doesn't do much calculation, but his problem solving skills even better than  Olympiac Maths students ..... I guess this is gifted and by drilling in Kumon or OM....... the gifted kid's maths giftedness will be declined very soon....

mio8390

公文的教育方法是不停重複做，資優生一般喜歡靈活思考，奧數是比較好的訓練。

ANChan59

原帖由 mio8390 於 11-7-11 11:42 發表
公文的教育方法是不停重複做，資優生一般喜歡靈活思考，奧數是比較好的訓練。

They can try on-line maths programs by top notch universities in USA, like EPGY or John Hopkins..... You can get some credits.....

OM is another way of drilling...... from my limited knowledge.

小曳人

公民數唔係俾叻人學架！叻嘅人要挑戰，唔係重複練習呀！

我個仔都好鍾意做習作，因為佢仲細，我未開始煩教佢嘅問題，今年升K2，做緊小3嘅數學習作

CCHmama

同意~~"公文的教育方法是不停重複做，資優生一般喜歡靈活思考，奧數是比較好的訓練。"

如果要我個仔做公文數,佢一定會發脾氣,資優生比較喜歡挑戰困難.

Aerosol_Ma

I totally agree. I have stopped asking my kid doing routine algebra.  In fact I don't know how to teach my kid as he is in K2 and he knows +,-,x,/,fraction, decimal and negative numbers. So I don't think he is suitable to 公文的教育.

For those with gifted in Maths, they learn by themselves and they should be challenged with more advanced problem. Nevertheless I don't know what advanced problems suitable for him.

peremum

So, are you teaching him high school maths now? If he can already master the 4 operation of fraction/decimal, you are strongly suggested to do so.

You also mentioned algebra.  May I ask what do you mean by "routine algebra"which you have stopped asking your kid to do?  2 levels polynominal? Solving equation?  Sim. equation? Quadratic? Cubic?

Aerosol_Ma

其實我很少教他 (除了除數和分數),絕大多數是他自學. 好似最近–星期, 他問我2-5 是多少? 我對他說這個你不會懂, 他說２不夠減5, 答案是-3.

Algebra 是很淺, 5x=15, x = ?
Polynominal?! 不要嚇我吧, he is just 4 year 9 months old only. 有冇奥數班適合他上?

原帖由 peremum 於 11-7-15 18:48 發表
So, are you teaching him high school maths now? If he can already master the 4 operation of fraction/decimal, you are strongly suggested to do so.

You also mentioned algebra.  May I ask what do you m ...

Sunnyland

As far as I know, there is very few Maths Olympiad course for kindergarten students.  I know a body offering such course is the HK Mathematical Olympiad Association.  They have Maths Olympiad contests for kindergarten students and provide related preparation courses.

Your kid is highly talented in Maths.  What kind of primary school would you arrange for him?

Aerosol_Ma

In HK there is no "real" gifted school so what I am going to choose are "through-train" primary schools. I know very little school interview will assessed math skills, so I just add his IQ assessment sheet in the application form. Helpful or not, yet to find out.

Thanks for the info for the math couse. Will explore more later.

ANChan59

***Deleted***

[ 本帖最後由 ANChan59 於 11-7-16 11:39 編輯 ]

mio8390

太細個，奧數可能不太適合，做家長的也不用太急。

原帖由 Aerosol_Ma 於 11-7-15 21:08 發表
其實我很少教他 (除了除數和分數),絕大多數是他自學. 好似最近–星期, 他問我2-5 是多少? 我對他說這個你不會懂, 他說２不夠減5, 答案是-3.

Algebra 是很淺, 5x=15, x = ?
Polynominal?! 不要嚇我吧, he is just 4 ye ...

Aerosol_Ma

我也明白所以現在都是由他自由發展。他問我就回答，不再教他。相反什麼課外補充也不做。

Hello媽媽

小兒IQ144, 是資優小朋友, 在K3時學公文數,在小一時學奧林匹克數, 他自小很喜歡公文數, 因公數可以提升他的數學領域, 今年小六, 他已學到中五數, 並且拿了很多奧林匹克數獎, 我認識很多數學叻的人都是有學公文數, 所以不好一般而言.

smartcar

奧數連成年人都看不懂

解難又有趣（我個仔話）

學過公文數一個summer，跟本同寫copy book 冇分別，

要problem solving 不要drilling.

[ 本帖最後由 smartcar 於 11-7-27 00:44 編輯 ]

mio8390

同意，公文數是太死板，資優生沒有理由會喜歡，所以資優教育沒有教公文數，只有奧數和代數。

原帖由 smartcar 於 11-7-27 00:42 發表
奧數連成年人都看不懂

解難又有趣（我個仔話）

學過公文數一個summer，跟本同寫copy book 冇分別，

要problem solving 不要drilling.