重讀k2定係升k3?

carolsum

想請問各位的意見,我的小朋友是"細仔"學校有位可以比佢重讀k2,今年的小一入學申請(私校,真資)都會比佢試下去面試.但自己都打定輪數冇學校會收.應該比佢重讀k2,定照升k3,如果到時冇小學收再重讀k3?
重讀k2好d定係重讀k3好d?thx!!!

oooray

咁學校因咩原因建議佢重讀k2?係咪進度比人慢?定你自己一廂情願想做大b?

twinsstar1

I'm also thinking about this too. May I know if the K2 reports matter a lot? If repeat K2, the results would propably be better, then would it be an advantage?

wh0709

我咁睇：重讀K2,小學唔知；重讀K3再考小一小學便知。

karen55407

我揀重讀K2

InitialD

Frankly speaking, if the school suggested to repeat ...the performance must be much much below average. It si better off to get better prepared before get to K3 and later P1 ..

原帖由 karen55407 於 11-5-12 16:39 發表
我揀重讀K2

HMmummy

Ha...why should the kid be required to repeat in K2??? It is unbelievable?

panbaby

直資私校名校喜歡收大B, 但唔係超大B, 超大B在比例上是好少的, 點解? 超大B 唔代表你個B 叻, 只代表你的B 偷步, 因為你的B 與其他的適齡的B 起步點不同, 你跑得快是因為你的B 偷步, 並不是你的B 本身跑得快.  要同一起步跑得快的B 才最受歡迎.

InitialD

My understanding is that DSS/private school will pick up the smart one and they don't care the age. However, 大B or 超大B have certain advantage. Please aware that some schools such as DBS only admit children with birthdayfrom 1st Jan to 31st Dec. of the corresponding year, ie, 超大B are not qualifed for application. But for some schools such as PC, they only accept age from 1 Sept to31 August, ie, small B are not qualified.
For lucky draw, no problem for  超大B  or samll B.

pandabonita

agreed if recommended by the kg rather than by the parents.  also if poss, I suggest to move to another kg to repeat rather than staying in the same kg.

原帖由 InitialD 於 11-5-12 23:30 發表
Frankly speaking, if the school suggested to repeat ...the performance must be much much below average. It si better off to get better prepared before get to K3 and later P1 ..

panbaby

同意私小直資收叻的學生, 不如請教吓在讀直資私小學生的媽咪, 同學仔中多超大B 多定適合年歲多?

咁如果官津是不受年紀影响, 咁留班為何?

Sumyeema1

原帖由 InitialD 於 11-5-13 09:49 發表
Please aware that some schools such as DBS only admit children with birthdayfrom 1st Jan to 31st Dec. of the corresponding year, ie, 超大B are not qualifed for application....

真的嗎？

剛剛 call DBS 小學部(tel 3159 4200), 沒有這樣的限制。  請問你能否公開更多資料？

karen55407

我有兩個朋友刻意在K2留班，讓孩子做超大B，佢哋話明顯第二年K2成績表靚得多，一個考到SFA加St Paul Boy，最終揀St. Paul Boy，另一個考到SFA加英華，最終讀LS。佢哋都係原校留班（名幼稚園），我覺得佢哋係明智嘅。

luilui007

原帖由 karen55407 於 11-5-13 11:45 發表
我有兩個朋友刻意在K2留班，讓孩子做超大B，佢哋話明顯第二年K2成績表靚得多，一個考到SFA加St Paul Boy，最終揀St. Paul Boy，另一個考到SFA加英華，最終讀LS。佢哋都係原校留班（名幼稚園），我覺得佢哋係明智嘅。 ...

只為入到名校而已

twinsstar1

honestly, if my kid was born on Oct or Nov, I won't let him repeat, but if he's born on Dec, then I'll consider it.

Sometimes I think it is the schools which do not like picking small kids rather than the parents really want to let their kids to repeat.

I know a Dec kid who repeated K3 and got offers from many famous schools like CKY, YW,  陳守仁 etc after repeating.

原帖由 panbaby 於 11-5-13 10:30 發表
同意私小直資收叻的學生, 不如請教吓在讀直資私小學生的媽咪, 同學仔中多超大B 多定適合年歲多?

咁如果官津是不受年紀影响, 咁留班為何?

InitialD

This is the requirement 3 years ago... not sure if this still apply..I remember the talk from the pricipal "this is to avoid submission for application two times..when he is small B and super big B later". Please double check.

原帖由 Sumyeema1 於 11-5-13 10:47 發表


真的嗎？

剛剛 call DBS 小學部(tel 3159 4200), 沒有這樣的限制。  請問你能否公開更多資料？

jkl

My son is now in K1 and he is small bb. His teachers have already suggested that we may consider to repeat K2 after he finishes his K2 next year.

The teachers said that a lot of the "famous" schools perfer Big bb.

Most of the schools, they will ask for your 2 most recent school reports. If you repeat K3, that means you will be submitting 2xK3 reports which the Primary school will know the kid has repeated in K3. If you repeat K2, there will be no such problem.

And for lucky draw, as far as I know, you can only enter once. If you choose to repeat K3 later, will you choose to do the lucky draw when you are in K3 the 1st time or when you repeat K3. Difficult decision.

I have come across a mum and her boy is small bb also. She said she will promote to K3 first. If her son can't get a good offer for P1, she will choose to repeat P1 instead.

For me, both of my boys are small bb (Oct and Nov) --> may be my fault!! My older son is a small boy in his school but my younger son is a super big boy in his school.

twinsstar1

jkl,

Being a small Boy and a big Boy's mother... which arrangement do you think it is better for boys? Because many said boys develop later than girls so it is worth to repeat.... thx!

原帖由 jkl 於 11-5-13 12:02 發表
My son is now in K1 and he is small bb. His teachers have already suggested that we may consider to repeat K2 after he finishes his K2 next year.

The teachers said that a lot of the "famous" schools ...

jkl

I think boys definetly develop later than girls. I think I perfer them as a big boy. So I will consider repeating my older son in K2.

panbaby

唔... 咁會唔會有 repeat 咗都考唔到呢個咁黑仔可能性?