用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 幼校討論 天主教聖瑪加利大收到信啦。。
樓主: sunnyvivian
go

天主教聖瑪加利大收到信啦。。


195
發表於 10-12-12 21:56 |顯示全部帖子

回復 28# 天賜小公主 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1216
發表於 10-12-12 22:57 |顯示全部帖子
Seriously, the interview turned out as really bad and rush in term of the structure, standard, teacher's attitude and quality. The noisy and messy environment are just a major failure. If the applicants are really too many, why don't they extend their interviews to few more days. At least, every one gets more time, (even better each interview family can have an isolated room which allows an effective communciation) the teacher can get more rest and spend more time to know each student.  Or maybe they are just  as ppl said, they already have a group of candidate in mind. The interview was just a show for your $30 ticket.
I personally do not really care about the admission as I don't want my kid to spend three years in such wore-out campus and cantonese focus. I am just so surprised the way they arranged the interview.

Rank: 2


75
發表於 10-12-13 00:37 |顯示全部帖子

回復 42# cccbaby 的帖子

Is it common to have isolated room for kinder interview per family? I don't think it's common as kids may feel  more frustrated to stay in the isolated room. Even primary school interview will not have single room for each candidate.

Rank: 1


18
發表於 10-12-13 08:21 |顯示全部帖子
你所講就係呢件事係我們家長的心聲
原帖由 cccbaby 於 10-12-12 22:57 發表
Seriously, the interview turned out as really bad and rush in term of the structure, standard, teacher's attitude and quality. The noisy and messy environment are just a major failure. If the applican ...


2640
發表於 10-12-13 08:21 |顯示全部帖子
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4187
發表於 10-12-13 09:52 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 cccbaby 於 10-12-12 22:57 發表
Seriously, the interview turned out as really bad and rush in term of the structure, standard, teacher's attitude and quality. The noisy and messy environment are just a major failure. If the applican ...


因為唔係一條龍所以我都唔報,但有2個朋友及1個同學仔報左,佢地都不約而同地指出大家所講既問題。佢地話好多關連人士interview果日帶晒d哥哥姐姐一齊去in、關連人士又不守interview room規則重騷擾其他未in既小朋友等。

聽完佢地呻后我覺得學校俾preference關連人士實會有(係咪一定收唔知,估計今日聽日就會好多話自己收左但唔係關連人士既人走出來!),但d關連人士做得太揚學校老師應禁止,因為實在騷擾個interview而且亦俾人內定的感覺。

[ 本帖最後由 brrbaby2007 於 10-12-13 11:08 編輯 ]
"即使你是友善的,人們可能還會說你自私和動機不良,不管怎樣,你還是要友善。即使你是誠實的,人們可能還會欺負你,不管怎樣,你還是要誠實。你今天做的善事,人們明天可能就忘記,不管怎樣,你還是要做善事。” 杜麗莎修女。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4449
發表於 10-12-13 09:59 |顯示全部帖子

回復 1# 天賜小公主 的帖子

加油呀, 唔好灰心. 我舊年都係咁, 仲係連續收9封reject letter添, 等到5月, 應該有好消息既, 最好既, 可能留到最後

Rank: 6Rank: 6


9660
發表於 10-12-13 11:04 |顯示全部帖子
天賜小公主,

你囡囡答晒所有問題已經是好叻女~
pls. check pm.

Rank: 2


54
發表於 10-12-13 11:11 |顯示全部帖子
我個仔到而家都無一間收, 咪仲慘, 仲要係9月細仔, 無奈~

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3950
發表於 10-12-13 11:16 |顯示全部帖子

回復 14# mykate 的帖子

我都有幫我姐姐提早攞form (即粉紅色form)...結果都是下午waiting list...所以不要誤會學校會把所有位留給有"色"人士...hehe!!!
我明白大家等待及期盼的心情...每年出生率都不斷上升...大家努力...不要把我們的不快傳給小朋友...我們的寶寶是最叻的...yeah!!!!

[ 本帖最後由 七點半 於 10-12-13 11:22 編輯 ]

Rank: 1


4
發表於 10-12-13 14:46 |顯示全部帖子
前日都收到信, 係pm waiting, 好担心, 係一封regular letter
都唔知應該點, 係咪只係日日等電話同信呢......??

Rank: 3Rank: 3


289
發表於 10-12-13 14:59 |顯示全部帖子

回復 45# 天賜小公主 的帖子

add oil!
囡囡04/12有in 聖大....都一樣回答晒所有問題, 果日老師問問題昤,仲被其他已in完嘅小朋友走來搶答 個果小朋友媽咪仲問佢個囝係咪要同老師玩

我個囡係0809....都算係細囡....出年1月考spk同聖心機會都

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3444
發表於 10-12-13 15:11 |顯示全部帖子
totally agreed with cccbaby.

we were not dissappointed with the result but the whole arrangement from school. the way they interview the candidate was the worst experience I ever had.

they asked the parents to sit behind and let the kids to play alone in the long table. but only few parents sat behind and let their kid interview alone. Some parents were allowed to sit next to their kids for the interview.

Umm, I can say the whole interview is just a waste of time. (two hours!!)

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4187
發表於 10-12-13 15:23 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 mandy_ma 於 10-12-13 14:59 發表
add oil!
囡囡04/12有in 聖大....都一樣回答晒所有問題, 果日老師問問題昤,仲被其他已in完嘅小朋友走來搶答 個果小朋友媽咪仲問佢個囝係咪要同老師玩

我個囡係0809....都算係細囡....出 ...


看來你的糟遇同我朋友一樣,佢話有個已in完既關連人士媽媽抱左個小朋友去佢b張枱騷擾佢b,個朋友想出手但老師話明家長要坐后面佢驚俾人扣分所以忍住,結果我朋友個b差d就過枱揾嘢玩。o甘聽落個interview arrangement都幾差吓,希望校方以后可改善吓啦。

[ 本帖最後由 brrbaby2007 於 10-12-13 15:26 編輯 ]
"即使你是友善的,人們可能還會說你自私和動機不良,不管怎樣,你還是要友善。即使你是誠實的,人們可能還會欺負你,不管怎樣,你還是要誠實。你今天做的善事,人們明天可能就忘記,不管怎樣,你還是要做善事。” 杜麗莎修女。

Rank: 1


18
發表於 10-12-13 15:29 |顯示全部帖子
我絕對認同你所講 : we were not dissappointed with the result but the whole arrangement from school,去過幾間學校面試,都未試過統籌咁失敗。當然人係自私的,既得利益者一定會覺得冇問題,有人會覺得我地唔忿氣,食不到的葡萄是酸的。但呢個先係最恐佈...家長覺得冇問題,理直氣壯,覺得自己雖然有早取form,但學校都冇收佢所以冇問題。
點都好,呢次我當一次經驗去認識呢間學校,仲會好好曾惜其他認真對待學生的學校

原帖由 cereal 於 10-12-13 15:11 發表
totally agreed with cccbaby.

we were not dissappointed with the result but the whole arrangement from school. the way they interview the candidate was the worst experience I ever had.

they asked the ...

Rank: 3Rank: 3


394
發表於 10-12-13 16:56 |顯示全部帖子
如父母違規要陪小朋友坐 ===> 小朋友不能獨立
父母不好好管理小朋友讓他周圍騷擾人 ===> 这家庭没礼貌
老帥会否扣分就不知了..

Rank: 3Rank: 3


289
發表於 10-12-13 17:47 |顯示全部帖子
呢間學校嘅interview arrangement 真係要檢討
初初以為係3/F 會有另外一 part interview......點知係張table玩一陣, in in 吓又有小朋友搶答, 咁就in完....我只係覺得好兒戲
原帖由 brrbaby2007 於 10-12-13 15:23 發表


看來你的糟遇同我朋友一樣,佢話有個已in完既關連人士媽媽抱左個小朋友去佢b張枱騷擾佢b,個朋友想出手但老師話明家長要坐后面佢驚俾人扣分所以忍住,結果我朋友個b差d就過枱揾嘢玩。o甘聽落個interview arrangement都幾 ...

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1216
發表於 10-12-14 00:39 |顯示全部帖子

回復 15# Almond. 的帖子

Isolated room refers to quiet environment with no or at least minimal interruption. Parents can sit with the child and spoke with the teacher privately without kids or parents playing, talking or walking around. Some schools may put two or three interview groups together into one room as space is limited. I found couple examples,  蘇浙, 明慧 actually have done that so it is not uncommon. Maybe the school like 流水式作業 la so it can speed up the interview process. Like lots of parents  stated, not even the teacher can concentrate what do you expect from a 2 or 3 yrs old kids.

My kid actually feeling unusual when my husband and I have to sit behind her. She kept turning to us and asked us to sit close to her. I also noticed some parents just ignored the instruction. My kid was fine in the beginning but lost her patience on our strange acts (in her eyes) after waiting for ten minutes before the teacher came to interview.

Rank: 3Rank: 3


271
發表於 10-12-14 01:12 |顯示全部帖子
恭喜晒收到offer既小朋友, 好可惜我地錯過左download form, 最後有好心既bk parents轉寄俾我地, 好可惜已經約唔到interview...

至於學校既interview安排, 因為無機會去, 所以comment唔到, 不過好似出左result先comment唔係太好...純粹個人意見, 不喜勿插

Rank: 3Rank: 3


218
發表於 10-12-14 08:37 |顯示全部帖子

回復 16# hoholam 的帖子

我in日,甚至有家長帶埋家姐一齊入房in,老師仲同佢地一家四口講笑,你地話有冇人情分加呢?
我囡囡St Clare pm waiting, 聖大am waiting, 經過St Clare 的挫敗,今次明知12點半派信,夜晚8點先check信箱。
已有2間offer, 希望大坑TL ok啦,好鐘意呢間學校,SH 同 ST Paul都唔洗點唸!
記住,呢個只係一個遊戲,睇開D呀!大家嘅B都係叻仔叻女!!!