蘇浙 vs 柴灣聖米迦勒

stseng

Which one is better?

kochiman2004

原帖由 stseng 於 10-11-30 21:56 發表
Which one is better?

柴米 because it's nearly topest one primary school in HK East

stseng

I heard that 蘇浙小學 academic level is higher than 柴灣聖米迦勒...... is this true?

小佳

有認同, 學術成績來說, 蘇浙在東區的小學中是姣姣者. 校風也很好, 只是功課較多.

原帖由 stseng 於 10-12-1 17:26 發表
I heard that 蘇浙小學 academic level is higher than 柴灣聖米迦勒...... is this true?

GIPW

原帖由 stseng 於 10-11-30 21:56 發表
Which one is better?

I will vote for 蘇浙  

ap_cheung

蘇浙入band1達8至9成, 而柴米 約4至5成,
但蘇浙 需學費, 柴米 不需 學費.

原帖由 stseng 於 10-11-30 21:56 發表
Which one is better?

stseng

原帖由 ap_cheung 於 10-12-3 09:27 發表
蘇浙入band1達8至9成, 而柴米 約4至5成,
但蘇浙 需學費, 柴米 不需 學費.

Noted KCS is a traditional school, it is amazing to know that they are using activity approach teaching method from their website.  "本校一至六年級推行活動教學，使學生通過遊戲，實踐及活動，享受學習的樂趣。培養學生自發、自覺的精神，發揮他們的潛能。"  
Is that true?
Do students still have pressure in school life, eg homework, passages memorising, dictations, tests and exams.
How do teachers help students with their study?

mimi1102

KCS 係一間出名谷的傳統小學, 背書默書我諗應該走唔甩, 英文讀深一年, 一開學冇耐就要英默, 中默. 但係大部份小朋友都可以响學校完成功課.
係有壓力, 但係好多小朋友都讀得好開心. 聽過有家長話, 佢每日都好小功課 (因為可以响學校完成), 平時好少理佢, 不過佢又讀得唔差.
讀 kcs 有一樣可以保証的, 就係普通話一定得.

原帖由 stseng 於 10-12-3 23:43 發表

Noted KCS is a traditional school, it is amazing to know that they are using activity approach teaching method from their website.  "本校一至六年級推行活動教學，使學生通過遊戲，實踐及活動，享受學習的樂趣。 ...

tzehin

My niece is studing in KCC. She is enjoying school life very much. Very good academic training.

stseng

This sounds amazing - like a dream school:
"出名谷, 有壓力" but at the same time, "好多小朋友都讀得好開心. 每日都好小功課 (因為可以响學校完成)"

Do you know how do KCS manage it?  Is it because it combines traditional and activity-based teaching?

ap_cheung

谷得來, 都讀的好開心, 真是幾難得, 也好難明, 不知有冇更詳細的.....
也有听到有些媽媽說, 在基灣讀到太谷太大壓力, 後來小朋友轉去蘇浙讀, 開心番.....

原帖由 stseng 於 10-12-4 21:18 發表
This sounds amazing - like a dream school:
"出名谷, 有壓力" but at the same time, "好多小朋友都讀得好開心. 每日都好小功課 (因為可以响學校完成)"

Do you know how do KCS manage it?  Is it because it com ...

stseng

原帖由 ap_cheung 於 10-12-4 22:25 發表
谷得來, 都讀的好開心, 真是幾難得, 也好難明, 不知有冇更詳細的.....
也有听到有些媽媽說, 在基灣讀到太谷太大壓力, 後來小朋友轉去蘇浙讀, 開心番.....


...

Yes - I want to know more about it -谷得來, 都讀的好開心.  Can any one share with us?
In KCS website, they say they are activity-based teaching but I heard from some saying that it is a very very traditional school.

Jack0128

KCS is very small, because kindergarten and primary school share one basketball field only.
柴灣聖米迦勒is also good at acdemic, 3 tests, 3 exam.
Both of them have a lot of dictation.

原帖由 stseng 於 10-12-4 22:46 發表


Yes - I want to know more about it -谷得來, 都讀的好開心.  Can any one share with us?
In KCS website, they say they are activity-based teaching but I heard from some saying that it is a very very tr ...

stephanielaw

我認同

原帖由 stseng 於 10-12-1 17:26 發表
I heard that 蘇浙小學 academic level is higher than 柴灣聖米迦勒...... is this true?

GIPW

Basically, students from KCS are all very happy.  Though there are many tests and exams (3+3) in a year, so far they have not felt any pressure.  If that is the way to study in earlyhood then they will think exam and test are sth horrible.   Another thing that I noticed from KCS is there is more and more students who are from an "international" background, say some from France origin, America, South East Asia, China and etc.  The parents have a common vision are to polish their PTH when their children are small and that is the easier way to learn .  Just like on the parents say: you do not have to worried about PTH.  Some parents share the view that as compare with their elder kids who are in international school, they think KCS gives their child a better foundation.  Some might target to go to international school after P6 and others will stay at the local school.
KCS has a good sec school allocation last year:
12 - Cheung Cheuk Shan
5 -  BPS

3 - St Paul Co-ed

1- DGS

1 - DBS

4 - St Stephen College

1 - St Stephen Girl

4 - St Paul Boys'

2 - Marymont

1- St Stephen Covent

6- St Mark
12 - Chong Wah Fund

Criticism of the shcool will be there is not much ECA and the campus is small.  
Hope this helps.

Sorb

What GIPW has written should be the 2010 result, not being published in school website.

My niece is studying in KCS P3.  I have asked her several times, but every time, she told me she had no pressure from study at all though she had a lot of dictations and tests/exams.

Homework is not too much, just 4-6 piece per day. For full day class, most can be finished in school.

[ 本帖最後由 Sorb 於 10-12-8 10:46 編輯 ]

Sorb

KCS primary is 傳统教學.  Not similar to "一些活動教學的直資".

Sorb

This statement needs correction: "Kindergarten and primary school share one basketball field".  
The true fact is the school buses occupy the basketball field for most of the time.  Kidgergarten and primary students can seldom enjoy.  But primary school has a sport field on the roof of the campus.