del del del

lawsonmoon

del del del

mimame

Chance is slim but still have hope for an offer!


Wanna to ask current P1 parents of DGJS:

When you received the letter last Dec, for offer and reject, is is the same thickness? Or offer letter is thicker cos there are more papers regarding admission procedures?

THANKS

AnotherHalf

Did the school ask more than once about the address proof ?

I just attended the first interview, so I am just curious about it.

原帖由 lawsonmoon 於 10-11-25 12:08 發表
DGJS 兩次 interview 後, 雖然未有結果, 但有感而發。

校長多次在媒體說取錄與否純看小孩面試表現。但由交報名表開始，不斷要求提供住址證明(水、電費單etc.)。我心想取錄小孩子同他們住什麽地方有何關係? 何需大費周 ...

亞水

樓主老兄：

不斷要求住址證明？？

呢家野，真係無咁既印象播…

會唔會真係你最初漏左 (我去st.pxxx都漏招)，所以追你呀？

lawsonmoon

del del del

原帖由 亞水 於 10-11-25 01:42 PM 發表
樓主老兄：

不斷要求住址證明？？

呢家野，真係無咁既印象播…

會唔會真係你最初漏左 (我去st.pxxx都漏招)，所以追你呀？

[ 本帖最後由 lawsonmoon 於 10-11-25 14:03 編輯 ]

lawsonmoon

del del del

原帖由 lawsonmoon 於 10-11-25 01:55 PM 發表
I also applied 4-5 other schools, they just required to fill in the form, no need to provide bills for address proof. This is a logical question. If someone not consider or concern about this, why nee ...

ChuLuLu

SPCC : Copy address proof must be submitted together with the application form. No checking of original or copy address proof at 2nd-in.

DGJS : Copy address proof must be submitted together with the application form. Checking of original address proof at 2nd-in.

原帖由 chei05 於 10-11-25 14:10 發表
I think only SPCC asked for the proof of home address...DGJS do not asked for this .

share123

[quote]原帖由 AnotherHalf 於 10-11-25 13:25 發表

2in的確要出示住址證明

Rinana

Yes, I remember during the 2nd interview, the lady in the waiting room checked carefully on my electricity bill as well as my daughter's birth certificate

kochiman2004

第二次接見仍要CHECK住址證明, 仲問多一樣點解申請表張相同你個女依家有D唔同, 我回答無乜唔同.根住就2nd int.

OCEP

Why can't we see the proof of address as an internal thing that the school decided, to ensure no one took advantage of writing down very fancy address that didn't belong to them but instead belonging to relatives or friends. Why are we speculating foul play by the school? Why are we even mentioning Equal Opportunities Commission? The school, as a Private Organization does not need to explain it's policies to anyone. As a current parent of a DGJS girl, my daughter went through the old interview process, one single interview by Mrs Dai, I believe Mrs Dai will adopt the fairness approach to selecting your child. We were fortunate our daughter was selected even though we had no expectations. Mrs Dai will look for a variety of students, ranging from academic, sports, music and other special qualities. Some students have just the one or a combination. I am sure there will be other factors as well such as whether the child's mother is a working mother or full time mother. In my daughter class, approximately 2/3 are full time mothers. I can also vouch that address is NOT a factor in the selection process. I live some distance away from the current school location, in the New Territories so I have never doubted DGJS as being unfair and only selecting people from the most exclusive addresses. Whatever the final outcome, pls don't be hard on yourself or your daughter, enjoy the most precious time with your daughter.

maynjune

Don't be too naive lar....

These 尊貴 schools will definitely consider the family backgrounds, so what's the point they ask you to show the address proof?

Live in New Territories?  It is not a matter of how far you live, but how  尊貴 is your living place.  They will accept you if you are in 九肚山.....

Loso

Sorry, 你嘅講法有D矛盾: 學校唔計較地址，但又惊人報假地址揾着數?若果真係唔計較，報乜地址又有乜所謂?

原帖由 OCEP 於 10-11-25 16:56 發表
Why can't we see the proof of address as an internal thing that the school decided, to ensure no one took advantage of writing down very fancy address that didn't belong to them but instead belonging  ...

kinyee125

SUPPORT !!!

原帖由 OCEP 於 10-11-25 16:56 發表
Why can't we see the proof of address as an internal thing that the school decided, to ensure no one took advantage of writing down very fancy address that didn't belong to them but instead belonging  ...

donutbaby

原帖由 Loso 於 10-11-25 17:41 發表
Sorry, 你嘅講法有D矛盾: 學校唔計較地址，但又惊人報假地址揾着數?若果真係唔計較，報乜地址又有乜所謂?

I don't think there's contradiction.  The school wants to make sure that no parents will 'trick' the school by stating an address that does not belong to them.  This is just for the protection of the school's interest.  Afterall, competition is keen and they don't want any mistakes during the process.  Furthermore, some parents may think that borrowing a prestigious address may give them advantage to the admissions process.  The school just wants to make sure that does not happen.  It's just that simple.

lawsonmoon

del del del

原帖由 AnotherHalf 於 10-11-25 01:25 PM 發表
Did the school ask more than once about the address proof ?

I just attended the first interview, so I am just curious about it.

[ 本帖最後由 lawsonmoon 於 10-11-26 17:44 編輯 ]

lawsonmoon

del del del原帖由 donutbaby 於 10-11-25 06:02 PM 發表

I don't think there's contradiction.  The school wants to make sure that no parents will 'trick' the school by stating an address that does not belong to them.  This is just for the protection of th ...

Loso

越嚟越矛盾！學校為保障自己，惊人報假地址呃學校，咁做法唔係即係等於學校"關注"地址囉！若果DG唔睇地址，就冇所謂"惊人報假地址呃學校"囉。不過請不要太敏感，我冇話DG睇地址揀學生；而以為報富貴地址可以有着數亦可能係一些家長一廂情願諗法，始終難揾實証嘛！

原帖由 donutbaby 於 10-11-25 18:02 發表


I don't think there's contradiction.  The school wants to make sure that no parents will 'trick' the school by stating an address that does not belong to them.  This is just for the protection of th ...

eemum

原帖由 maynjune 於 10-11-25 17:19 發表
Don't be too naive lar....

These 尊貴 schools will definitely consider the family backgrounds, so what's the point they ask you to show the address proof?

Live in New Territories?  It is not a matt ...

No one will stop you think this way.  Every year there are people raising such an issue.  I just want to say definitely there are DGJS girls not living in those so call precious district, not even a so call "Middle classed" district.   

Further, it's a private school that can choose their preferred students and they got so many choices.  Why that they cannot choose one that perform smartly in the interview AND the family can support the kid with different activities with lots of family resources?  But surely, that's not the only consideration point.  At least you daughter need to up to their standard in the interview.  If your girls is not selected, first to think if your girls is up to their standard and meets their requirment.  Not on the family background as first consideration.