St. Paul Boy

chubby2688

多謝你的資料.

哈哈哈, 我都係畢業於其中一所補助學校, 想當年成績屬中上...又如何, 現職C9一名.

做父母一定希望子女入讀最top既學校, 但都要小朋友handle到, 全級150人, 考149...真係mut鬼野自信心都冇啦!  仲有, 考慮自己家庭背景同資金又係咪配合到呢?!

原帖由 jeremyphlam 於 10-10-19 11:42 發表

香港補助學校議會

香港補助學校議會由香港二十二所歷史悠久的英文教會學校所組成。由於這些學校已創立多時，培育過不少社會人才，教學成果有目共睹，而且各校均有獨特的文化傳承，被坊間統稱為傳統名校。香港補助學校議會 ...

arielhoney

而家好多學校都是靠marketing來撐起,死未!
教育改革真偉大.......翻天覆地

diversity

原帖由 arielhoney 於 10-10-19 13:56 發表
而家好多學校都是靠marketing來撐起,死未!
教育改革真偉大.......翻天覆地

同意, 相對某些學校, SPC可算是一間非常低調和有class的school.

jeremyphlam

原帖由 chubby2688 於 10-10-19 13:34 發表
多謝你的資料.

哈哈哈, 我都係畢業於其中一所補助學校, 想當年成績屬中上...又如何, 現職C9一名.

做父母一定希望子女入讀最top既學校, 但都要小朋友handle到, 全級150人, 考149...真係mut鬼野自信心都冇啦!  仲有, ...

好多補助學校都重係津校，唔係好明關家底、資金乜事？

為人父母應該最清楚自己子女的實力，明知唔得梗係唔好勉強。

chubby2688

SPCPS既校長同老師是非常好的, 佢地唔會放棄不聽話同成績較不理想既學生.

原帖由 diversity 於 10-10-19 14:17 發表

同意, 相對某些學校, SPC可算是一間非常低調和有class的school.

chubby2688

我係話巳轉直資嗰d呀.

原帖由 jeremyphlam 於 10-10-19 14:20 發表

好多補助學校都重係津校，唔係好明關家底、資金乜事？

為人父母應該最清楚自己子女的實力，明知唔得梗係唔好勉強。

andrewpapa

So happy to have so many people do the research and talk about St Paul Boy.

Let me share my point of view.  As a father or mother, our prime role is to educate our children and guide them.  P1 interview is not the end but only the beginning.  We still have decade to teach our children.  Why we have sense of disappointment so soon?  Once our children start their P1, disappointment come days in days out.  Not from any particular school but any school. Not from any subject but from all subjects.

Talk about the fairness of an interview or the detail of an interview - is the length of an interview really that matter?  Or the content of the interview should matter?  I am sure each headmaster or headmistress should have their experience on their interview design. No matter what, as parents, we should do as many researches as possible before the interview.  We won’t be known by then. Why compliant thereafter?

Whether the school is famous or not? How to define? BY history, by public exam result or by people impression? How come other will care about that? I think only alumnus, current students or “students to be” will care.

Why parents will care? For our own good feeling? Or really for our children?  Of coz we will think graduated from famous school should have higher chance of success in the future, but is it guaranteed? Without us, the parents' contribution, can or cannot? So 身教是非常重要

最後我一定要說, 我介懷人家的用詞, 人家對學校的態度. 好的我會歡迎, 差的我會自省. 但不友善的, 我會起來維護. 我信這不是SPC or SPCPS 校友, 學生, 及家長獨有的.

I also share at other threads that secondary school has no banding catergory under EDB.  The banding system is for the P6 student to join the central allocation.  Official document per attached.

http://www.edb.gov.hk/FileManage ... ents_100420_eng.pdf

If you want to point out the disappointed result of the secondary school, please only use the school report P24 to 27.  thanks

[ 本帖最後由 andrewpapa 於 10-10-20 01:33 編輯 ]

hui3328

教署是沒有將中學分等級, 因擔心造成標籤效應, 但教育界一些有心人根據各中學的派位情況, 例如收到多少比例Band 1學生,  多少Band 2學生等, 而自行將學校分等級.

另一個參考方法是公開考試(主要是會考成績), 雖然有Ups & Downs, 但也會看到整体趨勢, 某幾間傳統名校近10年成績確實是大幅滑落, 靠食老本, 當然也有一些可以保持水準.

由於目前的資訊透明度太低, 民間的統計數據究竟多準確, 便不得而知.

原帖由 andrewpapa 於 10-10-20 00:46 發表
So happy to have so many people do the research and talk about St Paul Boy.

Let me share my point of view.  As a father or mother, our prime role is to educate our children and guide them.  P1 interv ...

jeremyphlam

原帖由 hui3328 於 10-10-20 09:42 發表
教署是沒有將中學分等級, 因擔心造成標籤效應, 但教育界一些有心人根據各中學的派位情況, 例如收到多少比例Band 1學生,  多少Band 2學生等, 而自行將學校分等級.

另一個參考方法是公開考試(主要是會考成績), 雖然 ...

雖然很多人唔同意又幫忙護航，但某些傳統名校成績下降是不爭的事實。希望轉了直資後可以回升，始終學校是有往績培養出狀元之才。

所以就算係食緊老本我都認為值得揀，始終傳統、視野、校友關係和培養全人發展方面，絕非那些直資學店，甚至地區名校可比。

好成績會對入大學有幫助，但其他所學所見的會夠小朋友一生受用。

[ 本帖最後由 jeremyphlam 於 10-10-20 13:27 編輯 ]

diversity

SPC 正正就是不想食老本, 所以才毅然轉直資, 加強收生自主權. 的確, 它在最近顯示的成績有所滑落, 據了解, 它在轉自資時的strategy是有所不足, 引致一些收生質素的銜接問題, 但transition phase 現已完成. 一两年的成績起落便rule out 整間學校的努力是十分不公平. 要知道, 会考現已成過去, 即將到來的是新334學制, 我們不防放長双眼看看各「名校」的表現吧!

diversity

[quote]原帖由 jeremyphlam 於 10-10-20 12:47 發表

好成績會對入大學有幫助，但其他所學所見的會夠小朋友一生受用。
Well said.

funnyguy

I chose to quit

[ 本帖最後由 funnyguy 於 10-10-21 00:15 編輯 ]

diversity

In Sheung Shui, there is a school called Tang Hin Secondary School. I am afraid most of you may not have heard it before. Even when the school re ... [/quote]

阿得意佬,
你真係幾得意, 對SPC甘有興趣, 講野又不斷重重覆覆都係一個 point. 唔該你睇清楚人講左的乜先啦!又你知唔知decade呢個字点解?唔知就look it up in the dictionary啦!

funnyguy

原帖由 diversity 於 10-10-20 20:54 發表
In Sheung Shui, there is a school called Tang Hin Secondary School. I am afraid most of you may not have heard it before. Even when the school re ...

I chose to quit

[ 本帖最後由 funnyguy 於 10-10-21 00:14 編輯 ]

parenthk

原帖由 appleng 於 10-10-13 14:15 發表
其實都唔一定係架...我個仔話當時排佢之前的三個小朋友都唔肯答老師問題, 我個仔主動話比佢答先, 老師都有比佢答...不過都入唔到2 nd in, 所以真係冇路捉呀.

...

My son had similar experience. He told me that he can answer the questions, he was polite, he can build the lego, and he even helped other applicant submitted the form even. Unfortunately, I got the rejected letter as well. By the way, take it easy and don't give him pressure.

TungTung_daddy

Actually, I believe SPC is a good school. Thus, we applied for it. I checked with my son again. It seems that he made some mistakes during interview.

I talked with some parents. They shared to me their experience. No matter what had happened, their kids always told them that interviews were conducted very well. So, the final result may not match to what they have informed to us.