用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 小一選校 DBS真係好煩!
樓主: thomasha
go

DBS真係好煩!

Rank: 3Rank: 3


117
發表於 10-9-12 15:45 |顯示全部帖子
thought too much......
佢都比左個比分表你參考
果份野只佔得5%
交左就唔好苦惱甘多啦

原帖由 bbAvalon 於 10-9-12 10:40 發表
As I have called the school whether it is fine to submit 2-3 additional pages as my schhool reports are too much that will over 10 pages requirement.  The lady is strictly said that they will not acce ...

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4468
發表於 10-9-12 16:42 |顯示全部帖子
其實交表時會CHECK 正本嗎?
回 望 這 半 生 也 許 是 場 夢 年 月 已 帶 走 幾 個 秋 與 冬 淚 也 倦 了 夢 也 不 斷 轉 眼 逝 去 生 命 或 許 是 場 空

Rank: 2


91
發表於 10-9-12 18:28 |顯示全部帖子
Still working...

回心一諗,if 10 page is all-inclusive, 咁又係聖公會又係舊生嗰啲咪仲弊?

Rank: 6Rank: 6


5716
發表於 10-9-12 20:25 |顯示全部帖子
No, they won't check the originals.
原帖由 d2343130 於 10-9-12 16:42 發表
其實交表時會CHECK 正本嗎?

Rank: 6Rank: 6


5716
發表於 10-9-12 20:28 |顯示全部帖子
Logically, if they already asked parents to withdraw the excess pages, they would not have a basis to deduct marks unless the collector of forms made a remark somewhere to let interviewers know an excess of pages has been submitted.  As I didn't see any such remarks while the forms were submitted, I suppose the counting will be done by the interviewers themselves and any excess will be penalised directly.
原帖由 bbAvalon 於 10-9-12 10:40 發表
As I have called the school whether it is fine to submit 2-3 additional pages as my schhool reports are too much that will over 10 pages requirement.  The lady is strictly said that they will not acce ...

Rank: 6Rank: 6


5716
發表於 10-9-12 20:30 |顯示全部帖子
Yes, the more you are related to DBS, the tighter your pages. haha
原帖由 angelhair 於 10-9-12 18:28 發表
Still working...

回心一諗,if 10 page is all-inclusive, 咁又係聖公會又係舊生嗰啲咪仲弊?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1498
發表於 10-9-13 00:43 |顯示全部帖子
Please help.  Do the 10 pages mean 10 pages in total or 10 pieces of paper in total.  Do they allow to print both sides?

Rank: 8Rank: 8


15475
發表於 10-9-13 01:23 |顯示全部帖子
According to the headteacher's clarification during the seminar, max. 5 pcs of 2 sided paper.
原帖由 Summer 於 13/9/2010 00:43 發表
Please help.  Do the 10 pages mean 10 pages in total or 10 pieces of paper in total.  Do they allow to print both sides?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1498
發表於 10-9-13 01:28 |顯示全部帖子
huba,

Many thanks to your quick reply.


原帖由 huba 於 10-9-13 01:23 發表
According to the headteacher's clarification during the seminar, max. 5 pcs of 2 sided paper.

Rank: 8Rank: 8


15475
發表於 10-9-13 01:29 |顯示全部帖子
Relax. A parent has asked the headteacher the question about excessive pages caused by lengthy schools reports. The headteacher replied that it's she who read the submitted documents and just 2 or 3 pages in excess is fine for her.

原帖由 bbAvalon 於 12/9/2010 10:40 發表
As I have called the school whether it is fine to submit 2-3 additional pages as my schhool reports are too much that will over 10 pages requirement.  The lady is strictly said that they will not acce ...

Rank: 6Rank: 6


5716
發表於 10-9-13 07:51 |顯示全部帖子
Unfortunately, this happened in the 2nd session of the admission briefing and in the 1st session, in which the headmaster said clearly that marks will be deducted.  
原帖由 huba 於 10-9-13 01:29 發表
Relax. A parent has asked the headteacher the question about excessive pages caused by lengthy schools reports. The headteacher replied that it's she who read the submitted documents and just 2 or 3 p ...

Rank: 3Rank: 3


117
發表於 10-9-13 09:15 |顯示全部帖子
其實大家不用重複又重複甘去估對方會點
老實說你知道什麼是重要什麼是不重要的吧
資料不是多就好, 如果你覺得全都重要, 米比曬佢......
佢5% 的分可能見你多左頁減你幾分, 不過可能見你多出來的資料好正又加反幾分.....
反正沒人估計到佢地最buy 什麼
放鬆一d 啦

原帖由 thomasha 於 10-9-13 07:51 發表
Unfortunately, this happened in the 2nd session of the admission briefing and in the 1st session, in which the headmaster said clearly that marks will be deducted.  

Rank: 6Rank: 6


5716
發表於 10-9-13 09:39 |顯示全部帖子
我已經交左表,其實o係呢度"豬up"都係想將所知所想同其他家長分享,等佢地自己決定點樣處理。

撇開校方發放消息的方法和內容有疏漏同唔一致唔講,其實講到尾只係佔5分,係咪值得花大多周章去諗實在見仁見智。

我係個比較講原則o既人,所以都會盡力符合人地o既要求。不過,如果有d好正o既野想俾校長知,話唔定加o既分仲多過超過篇幅可能扣o既分。

總之,唔好因為呢d野令你顧此失彼,黎緊仲有大把野做架。
原帖由 manmak88 於 10-9-13 09:15 發表
其實大家不用重複又重複甘去估對方會點
老實說你知道什麼是重要什麼是不重要的吧
資料不是多就好, 如果你覺得全都重要, 米比曬佢......
佢5% 的分可能見你多左頁減你幾分, 不過可能見你多出來的資料好正又加反幾分.. ...

Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14


112603
發表於 10-9-13 09:42 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 manmak88 於 10-9-13 09:15 發表
其實大家不用重複又重複甘去估對方會點
老實說你知道什麼是重要什麼是不重要的吧
資料不是多就好, 如果你覺得全都重要, 米比曬佢......
佢5% 的分可能見你多左頁減你幾分, 不過可能見你多出來的資料好正又加反幾分.. ...


I echo your point.

What should be in the portfolio reflect their parents judgement? Important, relevance, number of pages...

If a school's administration or philosophy really bother me or my son, I won't apply for that or drop the interview.

Rank: 4


782
發表於 10-9-13 10:09 |顯示全部帖子
Agree, and thanks for your sharing.  Having more information can let the parents to judge when those parents not yet submit the application form.


原帖由 thomasha 於 10-9-13 09:39 發表
我已經交左表,其實o係呢度"豬up"都係想將所知所想同其他家長分享,等佢地自己決定點樣處理。

撇開校方發放消息的方法和內容有疏漏同唔一致唔講,其實講到尾只係佔5分,係咪值得花大多周章去諗實在見仁見智。

我係個比較講 ...

Rank: 3Rank: 3


244
發表於 10-9-13 11:23 |顯示全部帖子
Last year, I went to St Paul Boys with a 5 pgs portfolio total but binded on the side, when I got there the man who accepted my form and portfolio cut off the side where I had binded to make 5 pgs of loose A4 staple at 1 corner, ended up really ugly. It might not be to my liking but did I want to apply, yes... and personally I didn't think what the big difference was stapled on the side or at the corner, but it was their requirement and if it can be of help to the school then so be it, no point to complain and complain and complain; energy wasted.

You guys take it easy la, I think just common sense can point you guys in the right direction...

http://happypama.mingpao.com/cfm/study1.cfm

Rank: 6Rank: 6


5716
發表於 10-9-13 11:37 |顯示全部帖子
St Paul Boys improved their specifications this year by saying no binding was necessary in their web site and in the "notes to applicants" leaflet.  It seems to make sense as they will destroy the application documents afterwards and it will save their time in removing the binding and shredding the papers.
原帖由 hsbmama 於 10-9-13 11:23 發表
Last year, I went to St Paul Boys with a 5 pgs portfolio total but binded on the side, when I got there the man who accepted my form and portfolio cut off the side where I had binded to make 5 pgs of  ...

Rank: 3Rank: 3


244
發表於 10-9-13 11:54 |顯示全部帖子
http://happypama.mingpao.com/cfm/study1.cfm

I think Ms Lo is pretty clear in explaining the point of view of the school why they are limiting the amount of pages of the portfolio. Personally I think if they don't say 'we are going to deduct points' then all the parents will IGNORE them!!  I think it is a guide to think about what is important to put into your portfolio, 精簡! And if you dare, you don't even have to hand in one!!

cheers

Rank: 6Rank: 6


7293
發表於 10-9-13 12:27 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 hsbmama 於 10-9-13 11:54 發表
http://happypama.mingpao.com/cfm/study1.cfm

I think Ms Lo is pretty clear in explaining the point of view of the school why they are limiting the amount of pages of the portfolio. Personally I think  ...


看了這麼多評論,個人覺得最中肯就是這個。
不知打從何年何月,家長報小一「需要」遞交小朋友的個人槪覽,比見工還認真。真懷疑究竟有多少學校會認認真真去逐本細看設計精美、證書滿載的profile,尤其是至熱門的、動輒數千人報讀的名校。
當然,明白現今家長如果交一份薄薄的profile,始終心中會覺得很不舒服,因為怕給別人厚厚的profile比下去。可是,學校真的要靠這些琳瑯滿目的profile來決定取錄與否嗎?真的很懷疑。
故此,不要給profile頁數多少、或校長會不會真的扣分那麼緊張,到面試時,如果小朋友表現欠佳,要扣的分比那份過厚profile多上幾倍呢﹗

Rank: 6Rank: 6


5716
發表於 10-9-13 12:54 |顯示全部帖子
很同意,profile應該精簡,交得越厚不等於機會一定高一點,反而校長更有可能一眼也不看。

我製作的profile以簡約清楚為主,沒有釘裝,只用釘書機釘著左上角,比賽證書兩三張,推薦信兩三張,再加一個簡單但有條理,像履歷表的文字簡介,就完工了,頂多是有些學校我會多交一張全是照片的放在最後作點綴。
原帖由 littlefaith 於 10-9-13 12:27 發表


看了這麼多評論,個人覺得最中肯就是這個。
不知打從何年何月,家長報小一「需要」遞交小朋友的個人槪覽,比見工還認真。真懷疑究竟有多少學校會認認真真去逐本細看設計精美、證書滿載的profile,尤其是至熱門的、動輒數千 ...