St Paul's Convent vs 協恩

rebeccalo

原帖由 newbkmember 於 10-6-13 07:22 發表
十分多謝大家的寶貴意見. 請問有無人知這兩所學校的功課量, 考試壓力,教學語言...等等? 那一所學校的學生較自信,獨立和靈活?

Hi newbkmenber

hps-小女讀小一,其功課每天4-6樣 , 不是太多.不過時常有小測 .孝試前老師會幫忙温習所教的書本 , 小三中文才用普通話上課 .(吾知今年會吾會改) , 下學期己開始教ニ年級D讀本 ,我自己覺得學校教d事比較其他津校多 ,而學校課外noted 比較深 , 我copy D測驗卷比朋友D小朋友做 ,有許多都未教 ,吾識 . (朋友D小朋友讀聖家 / 陳?其啦沙).經過一年觀察,女女進步不少 , 做事有自信.
SPC -姊姊的女讀過,其功課比較多,捐錢又多,同學與同學比較多 , (不過係幾年前事)

希望比倒一小小意建的

CaCaDad

其實你報或抽時心中應有答案，我希望你放翻個SPC位俾其他人。

suewong

我以前在st.paul's convent附近的女校讀書.  那些女孩個個都好自信, 亦好proud of 自已是st. paul's girl.  感覺上家長們會互相比較大家的家庭背景.

現在在net 35住, 見到不少協恩女孩一樣自信, 但比較謙卑, 樸實.

2間學校也是top school.....看看你比較愛女兒的朋友是那一類型.

不過真係恨死人:D

newbkmember

心目中較喜歡St Paul, 有朋友是St Paul old girl, 而她囡囡現在就讀St Paul 二年級, 對她們的感覺很好, 沒有架子, very humble, 她的囡囡很有禮貌,很主動學習,且自信. 她highly recommended 這學校.
老實說, 本人知道這學校很難考入, 沒有甚麼其望,去年寫了一封信去St Paul, 抽協恩時還未考入, 六月同一時間抽到協恩及收到St Paul offer, 真的感到意外, 但我的St Paul 朋友不熟悉協恩, 所以很難比較. 但從之前的post所見, 好像協恩較St Paul 壓力大, 但會考成績好像是St Paul 較特出(我看過這兩所學校的網站), 可能協恩花較多時間在課外活動上, 我的囡囡愛閱讀多於運動, 所以我認為St Paul 較適合她, 況且, 協恩在數年後會轉直資, 變數較大.

真的多謝各BK 會員提供的意見, 我會release 協恩位, 希望
各位正在扣門協恩的小朋友如願以償, add oil!

原帖由 CaCaDad 於 10-6-13 14:04 發表
其實你報或抽時心中應有答案，我希望你放翻個SPC位俾其他人。

o^^o

但好似冇人提一間係天主教, 一間係基督教, 你可以比較吓兩類宗教學校的教學特色, 再講,既然比得起, 咪讀spc囉, 個人認為, 私校如果你比咗留位費, 霸住個位, 冇人可以出聲, 但津校就最好快d放返個位比人啦

chingchingfa

Dear newbkmember,
Released the other one? Some years ago, I was same as you for my daughter. One was SPCSPR and other one was one of the top girl schools. Finally, I chose SPCSPR for her. Subsidy or government schools are so hard to "fight" the band 1 secondary seats. You have to be the fighter to face the pressure everyday. Though the fee is free, you have to considerate if you are OK to keep the best (at least top 30% in the class).

Best regards,
chingchingfa

newbkmember

Samuellor,

You seems to pick HY at the very first beginning, is it only due to your religion background only? How about your niece? Does she enjoy her school? Sorry for so many questions, you seems to be the only one that I know to have information about two schools.  How do you compare these schools?

chingchingfa,

It's a tough choice though, but I think it's less risky to pick SPC.  Both schools can get into top Eng secondary schools.   You are right, to fight for the top 30% band 1 student is not an easy task.  
SPC has a better chance.

chingchingfa

Dear newbkmember,
If you could not make decision up to now, try to bring the user (your daughter) to both of schools during their dismissal times, she may be advised her individual and outstanding comment to you.

Best regards,
chingchingfa

newbkmember

Hi Chingchingfa,

Thanks.  I shall take her both schools, let see if she make the same decision as me.

原帖由 chingchingfa 於 10-6-14 16:21 發表
Dear newbkmember,
If you could not make decision up to now, try to bring the user (your daughter) to both of schools during their dismissal times, she may be advised her individual and outstanding co ...

ricenoodle

rebeccalo,

I don't quite understand what do you mean by "SPC 捐錢又多", such as what kind of donation?  Is it obligatory?

Why outsiders think SPC parents like to compare with each other, you mean in terms of school results or family background?

Many thanks!

原帖由 rebeccalo 於 10-6-13 09:06 發表


Hi newbkmenber

hps-小女讀小一,其功課每天4-6樣 , 不是太多.不過時常有小測 .孝試前老師會幫忙温習所教的書本 , 小三中文才用普通話上課 .(吾知今年會吾會改) , 下學期己開始教ニ年級D讀本 ,我自己覺得學校教d ...

chingchingfa

1) I have just paid a few dollars per donation. 捐錢又多?
2) Normally, homework could be finished within 1.5 hr. 功課比較多?
3) All Paulinians would like to challenge in academy, not about the "family background". 同學與同學比較多 ?

Best regards,
chingchingfa

原帖由 rebeccalo 於 10-6-13 09:06 發表
SPC -姊姊的女讀過,其功課比較多,捐錢又多,同學與同學比較多 , (不過係幾年前事)

winchoy16888

真係恨死人

YongXin

We called ourselves Paulinians. We are St Paul's Convent School.

No offense. Just to supply the correct information here.

chingchingfa

As Yongxin said, my daughter is one of Paulinians at St Paul's Convent School. She has studied for 6 years, none of "noble" I feel. Most of us are "ordinary family".

Best regards,
chingchingfa

leschelems

I know your usage of  "ordinary family" means no offence.  But bear in mind there are a lot of families who can't afford the tuition fee or live too far away from Causeway Bay.  They are not "not ordinary families".

原帖由 chingchingfa 於 10-6-15 22:54 發表
As Yongxin said, my daughter is one of Paulinians at St Paul's Convent School. She has studied for 6 years, none of "noble" I feel. Most of us are "ordinary family".

Best regards,
chingchingfa